Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
UND won't be taken off NCAA's Indian mascot list
Thursday, September 29, 2005

The "Fighting Sioux" logo of the University of North Dakota. ™ UND.

The NCAA refused to take the University of North Dakota off its Indian mascot list on Wednesday, citing the "hostile" and "abusive" environment created by the school's "Fighting Sioux" nickname and logo.

In a statement, the NCAA said the school didn't have the clear support of Sioux tribes in the state. The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, the Sisseton-Wahpeton Sioux Tribe and the board of the United Tribes of North Dakota have passed resolutions against the use of the controversial nickname and logo.

The Spirit Lake Nation, the Sioux tribe located closest to school, has expressed conditional support in the past but tribal members have since voted to oppose the name. The NCAA said it was awaiting clarification from the tribe but reiterated its position on the use of Indian imagery in athletics.

"Although the University of North Dakota maintained that its logo and nickname are used with consummate respect, the position of the namesake tribes and those affected by the hostile or abusive environment that the nickname and logo create take precedence," Bernard Franklin, the senior vice president for governance and membership. "The decision of a namesake sovereign tribe, regarding when and how its name and imagery can be used, must be respected even when others may not agree."

Franklin, however, said UND will still be allowed to host an ice hockey championship in March 2006 without being forced to cover up the thousands of Indian head logos at the Ralph Engelstad Arena. The NCAA said it was "not reasonable" to require the school to comply with this portion of the mascot policy for the previously scheduled playoffs.

The decision brought praise from David M. Gipp, a UND alumnus who serves as president of the United Tribes Technical College. As a leading opponent of the "Sioux" name, he said the school must work with tribes to choose a symbol that is not offensive to Native people.

"Now's the time to work with the tribes to form a strategic plan for how to make that change," Gipp said in a statement yesterday. "Complying with the NCAA is the first step in a process to help UND become the premier, American Indian serving institution it claims to be. As long as this is unresolved, UND will not be supported and recognized for the value of its contributions through its American Indian programs, as it should be."

UND President Charles Kupchella, however, vowed to appeal to the NCAA executive committee and said legal action in court was possible. He questioned why three other schools have been taken off the list but didn't mention tribal opposition to the nickname and logo.

"Even those here opposed to the use of the nickname on campus recognize that UND offers perhaps the best opportunity for many American Indian students to get an education," he said in a statement. "I would also note, that the schools exempted thus far have been exempted on the basis of a 'special relationship' with American Indian tribes, yet our proportionate number of American Indian students and the number of substantive programs in support of American Indian students exceeds that of all of the exempted schools combined."

Of the four schools that have brought appeals, UND is the only one to have been denied. The Florida State University "Seminoles," the University of Utah "Utes" and the Central Michigan University "Chippewas" were taken off the list after the local namesake tribes expressed support for their respective mascots and logos.

A fifth institution, the University of Illinois, is expected to seek an exemption for its "Chief Illiniwek" mascot. But like UND, the school, can't point to clear tribal support for the controversial symbol.

A total of 18 schools were placed on the NCAA's list when the mascot policy was announced on August 5. Most haven't stated their plans but at least one school, Midwestern State University in Texas, has already decided to give up its "Indians" nickname rather than fight.

The policy doesn't require any school to give up its mascot, nickname or logo -- it only bars the use of Indian imagery during post-season tournaments. Schools that choose to keep their Indian symbols won't be allowed to host playoffs in the future. Previously scheduled games will still occur as long as Indian imagery isn't displayed.

UND was re-examining the use of "Fighting Sioux" in 2000 when the North Dakota Board of Higher Education ended the debate by voting to keep the name. The move came after Ralph Engelstad, a wealthy UND alumnus, threatened to withdraw financial support for the school, and the arena that was still under construction, if the name was dropped.

Engelstad, a Las Vegas casino owner, died in 2002, but not before seeing the opening of "The Ralph," as the $100 million arena is known. He purposely had thousands of Indian heads placed throughout the facility and placed a sculpture of an Indian warrior riding a horse out front. Engelstad "dedicated" it to Sitting Bill, the revered Lakota leader.

Most Native American students and alumni at UND, along with Native and non-Native faculty, oppose the nickname and logo. But the overwhelming majority of non-Native students and alumni support the name.

NCAA Decision:
Statement by NCAA Senior Vice-President for Governance and Membership Bernard Franklin on University of North Dakota Review(September 28, 2005)

NCAA Policy:
NCAA Executive Committee Issues Guidelines for Use of Native American Mascots at Championship Events (August 5, 2005)

Relevant Links:
University of North Dakota - http://www.und.edu
The Ralph - http://www.theralph.com
Fighting Sioux - http://www.fightingsioux.com
NCAA Minority Opportunities and Interests Committee - http://www1.ncaa.org/eprise/main/
membership/governance/assoc-wide/moic/index.html
National Coalition on Racism in Sports and Media - http://www.aimovement.org/ncrsm

Related Stories:
Spirit Lake Nation's stance an issue in 'Sioux' fight (9/28)
Letter: UND president wants to trick tribes on 'Sioux' (9/27)
Spirit Lake Nation said to cancel UND meeting (9/27)
UND president to meet with Spirit Lake Nation (9/26)
Opinion: Why would Indians attend 'abusive' school? (9/26)
NCAA asks for tribal views on 'Fighting Sioux' (9/22)
Yellow Bird: Clearing the air on the 'Sioux' name (9/14)
Poll: 63 Indians want 'Fighting Sioux' nick changed (9/9)
UND president meets with Spirit Lake Nation on nickname (9/9)
Tribal panel discusses future of 'Fighting Sioux' name (9/8)
Spirit Lake Nation tables vote on 'Fighting Sioux' (9/6)
Turtle Mountain chair won't oppose 'Fighting Sioux' (9/2)
Column: UND should get rid of 'Fighting Sioux' nick (9/2)
Opinion: 'Fighting Sioux' hurts Native students (9/1)
Spirit Lake Nation members oppose 'Fighting Sioux' (8/31)
Tribes set to oppose 'Fighting Sioux' nickname (8/29)
UND president wavers on tribal support for 'Sioux' (08/26)
Editorial: Tribes have final say in mascot decisions (8/25)
Other universities encouraged by NCAA decision (8/24)
Opinion: 'Fighting Sioux' nickname hurts Natives (8/18)
Column: Nazi-loving Ralph keeps Indian logo alive (8/17)
Schools appeal NCAA policy on Indian mascots (8/15)
North Dakota governor criticizes NCAA policy (8/11)
Even more reaction to NCAA policy on mascots (8/10)
Editorial: Good riddance to 'demeaning' mascots (8/10)
Jeb Bush calls mascot policy 'offensive' to tribe (8/10)
NCAA announces revised Indian mascot policy (8/8)
Mixed reaction to change in use of mascots (8/8)
Opinion: Everyone, 'Fighting Sioux' is here to stay (05/16)
Editorial: UND's 'Fighting Sioux' report not truthful (5/6)
Group protests university's 'Fighting Sioux' name (03/28)
UND asked to study 'Fighting Sioux' name again (02/17)
School holding off on Indian mascot policy (01/17)
Campaign targets 'Fighting Sioux' items (01/08)
Defender of 'Fighting Sioux' name dies (11/27)
Activist sees growing anti-mascot push (11/26)
UND students holding mascot forum (11/21)
N.D. student group to host mascot forum (10/29)
NCAA panel wants Indian mascot review (10/16)
'Honkies' exhibit draws attention at school (10/8)
Opinion: Change 'Fighting Sioux' nick (10/4)
Editorial: UND gets off easy on 'Sioux' name (9/23)
Harassment festered over 'Fighting Sioux' (9/17)
Yellow Bird: 'Fighting Sioux' debate (4/22)
UND law school opposes 'Fighting Sioux' (4/4)
Opinion: 'Fighting Sioux' not fight (3/26)
Minn. schools oppose mascots (2/22)
'Fighting Sioux' matchup to go on (10/23)
School: 'Fighting Sioux' is hate speech (10/22)
'Fighting Sioux' arena opens (10/9)
'Fighting Sioux' opponents rally (10/5)
'Fighting Sioux' statue wanted removed (10/4)
UND president finds LaDuke 'interesting' (10/4)
Letters: 'Fighting Sioux' controversy (10/4)
UND mascot conference opens today (10/3)
UND arena to have 'Sioux' statue (10/2)
'Fighting Sioux' arena to open (10/1)
Street for 'Fighting Sioux' friend sought (9/27)
'Fighting Sioux' school sets goals (9/26)
LaDuke to speak at mascot conference (9/11)
'Fighting Sioux' arena cost is $100M (8/16)
'Fighting Sioux' logo removed at school (8/3)
Letters: 'Fighting Sioux' nickname (8/2)
Head of UND Indian Studies quits (5/30)
Means may protest 'Fighting Sioux' school (5/9)
'Fighting Sioux' School: Place For Indians? (3/29)
'Fighting Sioux' still debated (3/26)
Schools condemn Indian mascots (3/22)
'Sioux' school being investigated (3/15)
Tribe protests 'Fighting Sioux' charges (2/28)
'Fighting Sioux' protest held (2/26)
'Fighting Sioux' protest planned (2/22)
'Fighting Sioux' debate rages on (2/19)
'Sioux' controversy focus of talk, article (2/16)
AG won't investigate 'Sioux' decision (2/14)
Civil rights complaint against school (2/13)
Bill seeks to help 'Fighting Sioux' school (2/8)
Dispute over 'Fighting Sioux' continues (1/30)
'Fighting Sioux' supporter tied to school funds (1/29)
Board won't reconsider 'Sioux' vote (1/26)
'Fighting Sioux' discussion set (1/25)
Tribe blasts 'Fighting Sioux' decision (1/18)
School board votes to keep Sioux name (12/22)

Copyright © 2000-2005 Indianz.Com