Opinion

Opinion: 'Geronimo' name problematic for Indian Country





"What's in a name? Shakespeare had a point when he had Juliet telling Romeo that "a rose by any other name would smell as sweet." But don't tell that to the many Native Americans furious at the Pentagon for code-naming Osama bid Laden "Geronimo" in the raid that found and killed him.

Members of that community have taken to pen, Internet and radio denouncing the usage, highlighted last Sunday by President Barack Obama on the CBS News show "60 Minutes." In a long description of the raid into bin Laden's hideaway compound in Pakistan, the president told of how one of the Navy SEALs reported by secure radio from the site the phrase "Geronimo E-KIA," meaning "enemy killed in action."

In the daily online magazine Religion Dispatches, an Emory University-sponsored site devoted to "analysis and understanding of religious forces in the world today," Joseph Geronimo, a great-grandson of the famous Apache chief, is quoted as calling the reference "a slap in the face" to three generations of Geronimo descendants who served in the U.S. military."

Get the Story:
Jules Witcover: Geronimo: Bin Laden's problematic code name (The Baltimore Sun 5/16)

Related Stories:
Steven Newcomb: Obama confirms 'Geronimo' codename (5/13)
Doug Cuthand: Use of 'Geronimo' codename a poor choice (5/13)
Doug Cuthand: Use of 'Geronimo' codename a poor choice (5/13)
Johnny Flynn: Indian Country irate over use of 'Geronimo' (5/12)
Lance Morgan: Indians as terrorists is a long-running trend (5/11)
Opinion: Use of 'Geronimo' as codename was unacceptable (5/11)
Opinion: The 'Indian wars' continue to play a role in culture (5/11)
Opinion: Geronimo's 'terrorist acts' were based on revenge (5/10)
Depree Shadowwalker: Use of codename an insult to Apache (5/9)
Ruth Hopkins: Geronimo and the myth of Indians as savages (5/9)
Jay Tavare: Names perpetuate false images of Indian people (5/9)
Opinion: Use of 'Geronimo' a tribute to famed Apache warrior (5/9)
Opinion: The truth about Geronimo and Osama bin Laden too (5/9)
Harlyn Geronimo statement for Senate Indian Affairs hearing (5/6)
Democracy Now: LaDuke on militarization of Indian Country (5/6)
Editorial: 'Geronimo' codename causes headache for Obama (5/6)
Opinion: Nothing wrong with use of 'Geronimo' as codename (5/6)
Opinion: Use of 'Geronimo' name defames American Indians (5/6)
MP3: Senate Indian Affairs Committee hearing on stereotypes (5/5)
Tina Marie Osceola: Apology due for US treatment of Natives (5/5)
Oneida Nation statement on use of 'Geronimo' as codename (5/5)
Rep. Albert Hale letter to President Obama about 'Geronimo' (5/5)
NMAI statement on military use of 'Geronimo' as codename (5/5)
Terry Rambler: Saying goodbye to our young Apache leader (5/5)
L.M. VanEvery: Use of 'Geronimo' codename was 'offensive' (5/5)
Lise Balk King: The Indian Wars still alive and well in the US (5/5)
IPR: Indian Country bristles at use of 'Geronimo' codename (5/5)
Rep. Cole says military didn't have to use 'Geronimo' name (5/5)
Defense Department says 'Geronimo' was chosen randomly (5/5)
Native Sun News: Veterans upset by 'Geronimo' codename (5/4)
Fort Sill Apache Tribe to President Obama about 'Geronimo' (5/4)
Seminole Tribe letter to President Obama about 'Geronimo' (5/4)
Navajo president's statement on 'Geronimo' as codename (5/4)
SCIA to address use of 'Geronimo' as codename at hearing (5/4)
NCAI statement on use of 'Geronimo' for Osama codename (5/4)
Steven Newcomb: US still treats Indian people like terrorists (5/4)
Lise Balk King: US drops bomb with 'Geronimo' as codename (5/4)
Military use of 'Geronimo' codename was apparently recent (5/4)
Onondaga Nation leaders criticize military use of 'Geronimo' (5/4)
Fort Sill historian doesn't think 'Geronimo' use is a big deal (5/4)
Opinion: Geronimo back in the news with Osama bin Laden (5/4)
Opinion: US slanders Geronimo's name with Osama mission (5/3)
Rep. Pearce: White House crowd celebrates Osama's death (5/2)

Join the Conversation