Dina Gilio-Whitaker: Winners and losers in Cobell settlement
Tuesday, December 11, 2012
Filed Under:
Cobell
|
Opinion
More on: bia, dina gilio whitaker, land consolidation
"Now that we have the obstacles cleared for the federal government to start making payouts under the Cobell settlement, we can expect tribal governments to begin their land consolidation processes. Recall that the settlement allocated $1.5 billion to be paid out to individual Indian holders of IIM accounts, $60 million for an Indian scholarship fund and the remaining $1.9 billion for tribal governments to consolidate fractionated allotment interests. According to the Department of the Interior, as of 2009 there were more than 4 million fractionated interests totaling somewhere around 11,000,000 acres of land; to put it into perspective, this is equivalent to a land area that would be larger than the states of Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island combined. The Tribal Court Clearinghouse says that it costs $33 million (which is between 50% to 75% of the BIA’s realty budget) per year to administer those fractionated interests, many of them which may not even produce the amount of money it costs just to maintain the accounts.
Clearly, it's a problem. The fractionated interests are framed as a problem for tribes and individual Indians not just because of how much money it costs the BIA, but because they are said to have no value due to their "uselessness." Because hundreds or thousands of people may own interests in one allotment and law requires that if the land was to be developed by anyone of those people (even for something as simple as building a house), they would need the consent of at least 51% of the other landholders, a scenario unlikely to happen anywhere. This renders the land “useless” and “valueless.”"
Get the Story:
Dina Gilio-Whitaker:
Who Were the Biggest Winners of the Cobell Settlement (Besides the Lawyers)?
(Indian Country Today 12/10)
Related Stories:
Upwards of 15K from Turtle Mountain Band to
share in Cobell (12/10)
Cobell trust settlement expected to bring $23M
to Wyoming (12/10)
Dennis Gingold withdraws as
counsel in Cobell trust fund case (12/7)
South Dakota could see $115M in first round of
Cobell payout (12/3)
Editorial: Elouise
Cobell worked tirelessly for trust settlement (12/3)
Editorial: Priceless lessons learned from Cobell
trust fund case (12/3)
Opinion: Cobell
trust fund settlement payout 'insultingly small' (12/3)
NPR: South Dakota beneficiaries await share of
Cobell payout (11/30)
Jay Daniels:
Christmas and Cobell - what about the day after? (11/29)
Upwards of 50K in Oklahoma share in $3.4B Cobell
settlement (11/29)
Tribal members in
Wyoming could see $8M from Cobell payout (11/29)
Cobell settlement comes too late for beneficiaries
who passed (11/29)
Checks for $3.4B
Cobell settlement expected in mid-December (11/28)
About 350K to share in first round of Cobell
settlement payout (11/27)
Obama
announces final approval for Cobell settlement payout (11/26)
About 30K in Arizona expected to benefit from
Cobell payouts (11/14)
Geoffrey Rempel:
The truth behind the withdrawn Cobell appeal (11/12)
Ask Elouise: Appeals of $3.4B Cobell trust
settlement dismissed (11/8)
Cobell
settlement cleared after Supreme Court dismisses appeal (11/8)
Mary Aurelia Johns explains reasons for dropping
Cobell appeal (11/08)
Supreme Court
refuses to take Kimberly Craven's Cobell appeal (10/29)
Secretary Salazar anticipates Cobell payments by
end of year (10/23)
Beneficiaries want
Supreme Court to review Cobell settlement (09/24)
Obama nominates Vince Logan, Osage, as new Special
Trustee (09/24)
S.E. Ruckman: Indian
Country wants to see Cobell payouts (09/18)
ICT refused to run Keith Harper's response on
Cobell stories (09/18)
Keith Harper: Just
a few truths about Obama, Cobell and me (9/12)
Ask Elouise: Lead counsel Dennis Gingold on status
of payout (09/11)
Native Sun News: Cobell
settlement on hold with more appeals (08/31)
Reply for Kimberly Craven's Cobell appeal due
September 21 (08/24)
Kimberly Craven
appeal delays $3.4B Cobell settlement again (08/23)
Cobell critic asks Supreme Court to review $3.4B
settlement (08/20)
Copyright © Indianz.Com
Subscribe