Opinion

Scott Starr: Conservative politics affect Cherokee ICWA case






Cherokee Nation father Dusten Brown and his family in Oklahoma. Photo Courtesy National Indian Child Welfare Association

Scott Starr, a student at the University of Oklahoma, discusses the politics of the Indian Child Welfare Act dispute involving Cherokee Nation citizen Dusten Brown:
The ICWA was put in place in order to help Tribes maintain cultural continuity and as a counter balance to the effects of colonialism and the ongoing breakdown of Native American families and cultures brought on by it. It was designed to prevent situations just like the one with baby Veronica, where Native American children are opportunistically whisked away from their Indian relatives and placed in situations where their cultural heritage is most often downplayed or ignored, thus contributing to the once clearly stated aims of the U.S. federal government to completely assimilate the Native American or the “kill the Indian and save the man” program of one Richard Henry Pratt, founder and longstanding superintendent of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School at Carlisle, Pa.

The case has garnered national attention and involved governors Mary Fallin of Okla. and Nikki Haley of S.C. It is my firm belief that there is some “conservative” ideology behind how both governors have handled this case, particularly Fallin.

Dating back to the days of the venerated Ronald Reagan, certain elements of the Republican Party and of conservative ideology have held that the U.S. federal government’s relationship with Native American tribes is tantamount to socialism and is the major contributing factor for ongoing poverty and other sagging measurements of well-being for American Indians. Their basic philosophy is that Indians have not prospered because the U.S. has given them too much —of course having nothing to do with an ongoing legacy of dehumanization and treaties broken or ignored by the U.S.

Get the Story:
Scott Starr: Battle for Baby Veronica presses on in Supreme Court (OU Daily 9/11)

Related Stories:
UN official urges consideration of culture in adoption dispute (9/11)
Cherokee Nation father files second appeal in adoption dispute (9/9)
Cherokee Nation father out on bail pending extradition hearing (9/6)
Oklahoma governor signs extradition order for Cherokee father (9/5)
Court puts hold on transfer of Cherokee girl to non-Indian couple (9/4)
Cherokee Nation father files appeal in Oklahoma's highest court (9/3)
Court hearing in custody dispute over Cherokee Nation girl (8/30)
South Carolina officers in Oklahoma for Indian custody case (8/29)

Join the Conversation