Environment | Law | National | Politics

War of words escalates on mine at sacred Apache site in Arizona






The Apache Stronghold was denied a meeting with Rep. Paul Gosar (R-Arizona) after a rally at the U.S. Capitol on July 22, 20215. Photo from Facebook

Rep. Paul Gosar (R-Arizona) took pains last week not to mention the San Carlos Apache Tribe while slamming a "misinformation campaign" against a controversial mine on a sacred site in Arizona.

In his press release, the Arizona Republican blamed "environmental extremist groups" for raising questions about the mine at Oak Flat, a sacred gathering, ceremonial and burial site. He only mentioned the tribe in quoting the four-year-old testimony of a former chairman whose views do not represent the current position of the Apache people or their leadership.

But Gosar was more blunt in a Dear Colleague letter that his office has not circulated to the media. In it, he claimed that tribal leaders -- though he did not mention them by name -- were participating in a "severely misguided" effort to repeal the land swap that allows the Resolution Copper mine to go forward.

And earlier this month Gosar was even more critical. Again, without mentioning them by name, he accused the tribe and its leadership of making "deceitful" statements about the sacred nature of Oak Flat.


Indianz.Com SoundCloud: House Natural Resources Committee Debate on Sacred Sites

"We have to be truthful about what we designate as a sacred site," Gosar said at the House Natural Resources Committee markup on July 9. "We have to be forthcoming and not just make erroneous claims."

"They're no different than anybody else," Gosar said of tribes and their leaders. "They have to be held to the letter of the law."

Gosar's negative comments were one of the reasons why the Apache Stronghold, a group led by San Carlos Apache council member Wendsler Nosie Sr., came to Washington, D.C., last week. Supporters called on Congress to pass H.R.2811, the Save Oak Flat Act, a bill that repeals the land swap, in a rally at the U.S. Capitol.

Rally participants -- some of whom drove over 2,000 miles from Arizona -- tried to meet with Gosar to discuss his views but were told to leave by his staff and the Capitol Police. Nosie, a former chairman, accused the Republican lawmaker of "cowering behind a locked door" rather than face his opponents.


YouTube video by Wendy Kenin: #ApacheStronghold #SaveOakFlat Attempt to Lobby Rep Gosar's Office

"Rep.Gosar should apologize for that, as wellas for his strange and insulting ‘Dear Colleague’ letter," Nosie said in a press release.

Rep. Raul Grijalva (D-Arizona), the sponsor of H.R.2811, is also challenging Gosar's view of the controversy. In two Dear Colleague letters that were sent out today, the ranking Democrat on the House Natural Resources Committee said the facts support the tribe.

"The most offensive part is the continued claim by Resolution and its corporate boosters that it will not cause harm to Oak Flat or other nearby sacred lands such as Apache Leap, where a group of warriors leapt to their deaths to avoid capture by pursuing U.S. cavalry," Grijalva said in one of the letters. "The truth is that these sacred lands face the risk of severe damage if the Resolution Copper project moves forward."

"The San Carlos Apache know this, which is why they have forthrightly opposed this giveaway from the beginning," Grijalva said.

Congress approved the mine as part of the 1,648-page National Defense Authorization Act that was passed in the final hours of the last legislative session. Grijalva's bill repeals Section 3003 but it has not yet received a hearing before his own committee.

Join the Conversation

Related Stories:
EJ Montini: Money wins in war to protect sacred Apache site (7/24)
San Carlos Apache Tribe clashes with Rep. Gosar after rally (7/23)
San Carlos Apache Tribe lands in DC to rally for sacred site (7/22)
Interview: San Carlos Apache Tribe fights mine at sacred site (7/20)
Ernie Stevens: Support sacred Oak Flat and the Apache Stronghold (07/08)
Company pushing mine at sacred site gives $10K to Apache youth (07/08)
House adds sacred sites amendment to Interior appropriations bill (07/08)
Save Oak Flat caravan exits Arizona for journey to nation's capital (7/7)
Sen. McCain deemed responsible for land swap at sacred Oak Flat (7/2)
Save Oak Flat caravan plans journey to DC to protect sacred site (7/1)
Bill repeals land swap for mine on sacred Apache site in Arizona (06/19)
Supporters open national prayer days to protect sacred places (6/19)
March planned in nation's capitol over mine at sacred Apache site (06/04)
Steve Russell: Take fight over sacred Apache site to higher court (6/3)
Lydia Millet: Selling off sacred Apache land to foreign interests (5/29)
Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick to challenge Sen. John McCain in 2016 race (5/27)
Wendsler Nosie: US government approves theft of sacred land (02/20)
San Carlos Apache Tribe leads 40-mile march for sacred site (02/06)
San Carlos Apache Tribe to hold spiritual march to sacred site (2/3)
Michael Paul Hill: Saving sacred Apache land from exploitation (2/3)
Opinion: Tribal sovereignty ignored when it becomes unprofitable (01/19)
White House responds to petition against mine at sacred site (01/13)
Steven Newcomb: Sacred lands are Christmas gift for mining firm (12/29)
Apache Messenger: Crowd protests copper mine on sacred lands (12/22)
Congress passes bill with mine on sacred Apache land in Arizona (12/15)
Senate heads to final vote on package with mine on sacred land (12/12)
Rep. Gosar won't apologize for calling Native Americans 'wards' (12/11)
Jon Kyl: Land swap for mine on sacred Apache land isn't unusual (12/11)
Terry Rambler: Defense measure raids sacred places for one mine (12/10)
Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians join fight against mine deal (12/9)
Great Plains tribes call for removal of land swap from defense bill (12/8)
Senate expected to approve defense bill for mine on sacred lands (12/8)
Opinion: No sacred Apache lands in swap for copper mine project (12/8)
House approves bill to authorize mine on sacred site in Arizona (12/4)
Apache Messenger: Younger generation returns to sacred site (10/10)
San Carlos Apache Tribe testifies against land swap measure (11/21)
Tribal lobbying halts measure for copper mine by sacred site (11/14)