indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Fredericks Peebles & Morgan LLP
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Group's challenge to sacred site policy rejected
Wednesday, March 31, 2004

A group of non-Indians who challenged government policy aimed at protecting a sacred site in Utah saw their lawsuit thrown out by a federal appeals court last week.

On March 23, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that non-Indian visitors to the Rainbow Bridge National Monument failed to show how they were harmed by being asked to stay away from the sacred Rainbow Bridge. As a result, they can't sue the National Park Service for allegedly violating their constitutional rights, a three-judge panel concluded.

"They fail to identify any personal injury suffered by them as a consequence of the alleged constitutional error," wrote Judge Robert H. McWilliams for the majority, quoting precedent set by another sacred site case.

But in dismissing the case, the court left open the question of whether workers at the monument can tell nearly 300,000 visitors a year not to approach and walk under the world's largest natural bridge. By determining that the non-Indian plaintiffs lacked standing, McWilliams said "we do not reach the merits" of this policy.

Several tribes, including the Navajo Nation and the Hopi Tribe, consider Rainbow Bridge to be an important religious site that people should not approach for fear of upsetting the balance of life. The concern was so great that at one time the Navajo Nation sued to stop all access to the bridge. The case was eventually thrown out.

As far back as the 1980s, the monument posted signs asking visitors to respect these religious beliefs. But it wasn't until the mid-1990s, with the adoption of an executive order on sacred sites by then-President Bill Clinton and the signing of an agreement with five area tribes, that the policy became an issue.

The Mountain States Legal Foundation, a conservative group that represented the non-Indian visitors, contends the policy promotes Indian religion in violation of the U.S. Constitution. The plaintiffs say the monument allows tribal members to go to the bridge to hold ceremonies but bars everyone else.

In response to last week's ruling, William Perry Pendley, the group's president, said it "ignores both the facts of this case and the law of the Tenth Circuit as to when users of public land may demand compliance with the Constitution's Establishment Clause." He added: "We will file a petition that the entire Tenth Circuit review the panel's ruling.

Mountain States, which formerly employed Interior Secretary Gale Norton, has represented other non-Indians in a variety of cases affecting sacred sites and treaty rights. In one significant case, the group representing climbers who challenged a voluntary ban on climbing at Devils Tower National Monument in Wyoming, which is used by area tribes for Sun Dance ceremonies.

The group's track record is not positive. Almost every case, including the Devils Tower one, has been decided in favor of tribal rights. The U.S. Supreme Court has refused to accept the group's appeals.

Currently, Mountain States is challenging Indian-teacher training programs at several universities. In letters to school officials, Pendley said the programs are illegal in light of the U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision in an affirmative action case.

Get the Decision:
Natural Arch and Bridge Society v. Alston (March 23, 2004)

Relevant Links:
Rainbow Bridge National Monument - http://www.nps.gov/rabr
Rainbow Bridge Case, Mountain States Legal Foundation - http://www.mountainstateslegal.org/legal_cases.cfm?legalcaseid=53

Related Stories:
Norton aides silent on sacred sites (7/18)
Group bolsters argument with Indian law (06/12)
Zuni Pueblo takes mine fight on the road (7/17)
House clears sale of sacred site to church (6/18)
Input sought into sacred sites (6/5)
Congress considering sacred sites (5/21)
Supreme Court rejects property-rights claim (04/24)
Victory on sacred site case (04/19)
Tribes push action on sacred sites (3/21)
Tribe prevails on sacred site case (3/19)
Norton denies politics played role in drilling (6/7)
Norton hit on exploration of sacred site (6/6)
Myers reversing sacred site opinion (10/25)
Bush nominee has no 'agenda' on Clinton decisions (6/21)
Babbitt denies Calif. gold mine (1/19)
BLM recommends mine rejection (11/10)

Copyright 2000-2004 Indianz.Com
More headlines...

Latest Headlines:

Senate Committee on Indian Affairs schedules hearing on tribal gaming industry
Trump hire at Bureau of Indian Affairs to make first appearance on Capitol Hill
Wife of Sen. McCain on witness list for hearing on trafficking in Indian Country
Tim Giago: Media in Indian Country still finds strength in the face of bad news
Mark Trahant: #NativeVote18 field grows with 7 Native candidates for Congress
Cronkite News: Sen. McCain delivers blow to latest Republican health care bill
Mary Annette Pember: New mural is a symbol of Native resilience in Minnesota
Secretary of Health and Human Services took private plane to tribal meetings
Lytton Band questions poll that shows opposition to land-into-trust legislation
Pokanoket Nation signs agreement to preserve ancestral land in Rhode Island
Gun Lake Tribe draws in more allies as Supreme Court considers casino case
Iowa Tribe promises to launch long-delayed online poker site sometime in fall
Ho-Chunk Nation sees support from Congress in bid for off-reservation casino
Mark Trahant: States complain to Senate about burdens of Indian health care
Cronkite News: Tribal leaders focus on marijuana industry at NIGA conference
The Conversation: Collaboration can help with Canada's indigenous water crisis
Museum acquires tribal collection from religious college with troubled record
President Trump headed to Alabama to campaign for land-into-trust opponent
Key Republican revives bill to strip Bureau of Indian Affairs of recognition powers
Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians choose Leonard Forsman as new president
California Tribal College names Blackfeet Nation citizen Billie Jo Kipp as president
Mark Trahant: Indigenous community in Dominica takes major hit from hurricane
Bill John Baker: Cherokee Nation shares more than $444K with our public schools
Democracy Now: Judges try to end legal defense program for #NoDAPL resisters
Cronkite News: Republicans in Senate aim for vote on Obamacare replacement
Mary Annette Pember: Native advocate can't trust Trump team due to instability
Dakota Access enters settlement for 'unanticipated discovery' of tribal artifacts
Navajo Nation plans to sue Trump administration to protect Bears Ears in Utah
Grand Portage Band celebrates trust status for 145-acre island at Lake Superior
Suquamish Tribe looks to address homelessness on reservation with tiny houses
Seneca Nation prepares for arbitration in gaming dispute with state of New York
YES! Magazine: Program aims to bring Native perspective into the classrooms
Cronkite News: Senate committee takes up bill to combat online sex trafficking
Yankton Sioux Tribe blasts police officers for use of force against elderly citizen
Former Indian Country editor blames demise on non-Indian gaming operations
Blackfeet Nation reaches deal to acquire assets of troubled town on reservation
Nottawaseppi Huron Band arrests casino patron who left son at home to gamble
Forest County Potawatomi Community names chief executive officer for casino
Flandreau Santee Sioux Tribe claims victory in long-running state taxation fight
Senate Committee on Indian Affairs reschedules hearing on human trafficking
Secretary of Health and Human Services continues outreach in Indian Country
Seminole Tribe secures emergency declaration in response to Hurricane Irma
New Yorker features Meskwaki word-songs performed by poet Ray Young Bear
Mark Trahant: Another Republican health care bill fails to help Indian Country
YES! Magazine: Sisseton Wahpeton Oyate takes steps toward food sovereignty
Native Sun News Today: Proclamation calls for action on Black Hills land claim
Chitimacha Tribe signed treaty with France at New Orleans nearly 300 years ago
Chris Feliciano Arnold: Indigenous people again at risk with mining rush in Brazil
Connecticut tribes can't get clear answer from Trump team on bid for new casino
White Earth Nation sticks by casino project despite delay in environmental review
Osage Nation secures landmark decision in dispute over construction of wind farm
Tim Giago: South Dakota continues to ignore history with annual buffalo roundup
Mark Trahant: Three fights ahead for the Native vote in United States and Canada
Native Sun News Today: Black Hills Unity Concert honors #NoDAPL participants
Native Sun News Today Editorial: Defending freedom of the press in Indian Country
YES! Magazine: Pueblo activists challenge annual depiction of Spanish 'conquest'
Cronkite News: Plans move forward to cull bison in Grand Canyon National Park
Secretary Zinke goes against tribal interests with monument recommendations
Alaska Natives bring communities together with unique recipes out of cake mix
Trump administration moves to open Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to drilling
Shingle Springs Band wins reversal of $30 million judgment in gaming dispute
Osage Nation celebrates construction milestone for $150 million casino project
>>> more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.