Home > News > More Headlines > Judge denies existence of trust relationship
Printer friendly version
Judge denies existence of trust relationship
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 15, 2003

A federal judge late last month rejected an Arizona tribe's attempt to recover legal fees that it said arose out of the United States' trust obligations.

In a December 27 decision, James F. Merow, a senior judge for the U.S. Court of Claims, said the Hopi Tribe, and not the federal government, was in control of its own destiny. Ruling that Congressional attempts to resolve a land dispute with the Navajo Nation did not create a fiduciary relationship, he denied a claim for millions of dollars in attorneys' fees.

"In this case, the government did not exercise elaborate control over the land belonging to the Hopi Tribe because it did not control the presentation of the tribe's interests in [court] litigation," Merow wrote. "Instead, the tribe controlled the defense of its rights by bringing suit on its own."

The ruling stems from a decades-old land dispute between the Hopi and Navajo tribes, neighbors in northeastern Arizona. As early as 1934, Congress enacted laws that attempted to settle the reservation boundaries but only exacerbated matters.

In 1974, a settlement act was passed to allow the tribes to bring suit against each other. It was required because the government, as a trustee, could not defend and fight both sides of the case.

But that general trust relationship only goes so far, Merow reasoned. Even though the land in question is held in trust, he said Congress never intended to establish a fiduciary relationship that would give rise to money damages if it is breached, as the Hopi Tribe asserted.

"The [Interior] Secretary in no way exercised any control over plaintiff's defense of its rights," he wrote.

Merow's analysis was based on the Mitchell Supreme Court precedents that are used by courts in breach of trust cases. The Bush administration has said these decisions are not specific enough and the Supreme Court, on December 2, heard oral arguments in two cases that could limit the government's responsibilities to tribes.

If the Hopi Tribe prevailed in the current case, it could have recovered at least $2.8 million for defending its land rights. But under a policy approved by former Secretary Bruce Babbitt on the last full day of the Clinton administration, these legal fees are subject to the discretion of the Department of Interior and are not an "entitlement."

In a similar case decided in 1991, the Court of Claims affirmed the existence of a fiduciary relationship concerning litigation over Indian assets. The court said that the federal government breached its trust to two Arizona tribes for "inadequate" representation that resulted in the loss of the tribes' water rights.

Get the Decision:
Hopi Tribe v. U.S. (December 27, 2002)

Relevant Laws:
Navajo-Hopi Settlement Act of 1974 (Public Law 93-531)

Relevant Links:
Hopi Tribe - http://www.hopi.nsn.us

Related Stories:
McCaleb learned about trust 'on the job' (12/23)
Panel predicts Apache victory (12/4)
Navajo 'deception' gets Supreme Court hearing (12/03)
Trust duties to Apache Tribe questioned (12/03)
Supreme Court takes on trust (12/2)
Review disputes 'costly' Indian trust litigation (10/21)
Tribes await Supreme showdown (10/17)
Peabody sides with Bush administration on trust (09/04)
Legal tactics land Peabody in hot seat (7/22)
Griles slammed for ignorance (7/12)
Griles can't explain trust standards (6/27)
Navajo royalty case accepted (6/4)
Don Hodel's Navajo Folly (6/4)
Supreme Court accepts Navajo trust case (6/3)
Navajo royalty case up for review (5/30)
Supreme Court considers 'deception' of trust (5/22)
Action due on Navajo trust case (5/20)
Leave no Apache school behind (3/29)
Bush wants Navajo ruling reversed (3/27)
Court rules Navajo Nation owed money (8/14)
Apache Tribe wins trust case appeal (5/17)

Copyright © Indianz.Com

Stay Connected

On Facebook

On Twitter

On Google+

On SoundCloud

More Headlines

Supreme Court puts an end to another tribal jurisdiction dispute (6/28)
Native women hail Supreme Court decision on domestic violence (6/28)
Navajo Nation leaders reflect on historic Supreme Court session (6/28)
Lakota Country Times: Runners take 500-mile Black Hills journey (6/28)
Mark Trahant: Navajo Republican drops out of race for Congress (6/28)
Brandon Ecoffey: Oglala Sioux Tribe must update its constitution (6/28)
Editorial: Lakota treaty council supported work at Wounded Knee (6/28)
Alex Jacobs: Our elected leaders do little to address gun violence (6/28)
St. Croix Chippewa Tribe ousts 10 people from rolls amid debate (6/28)
Film exposes police harassment of Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe (6/28)
Northern Arapaho Tribe asserts more control over health system (6/28)
Trump rehashes 'Pocahontas' slur as Warren hits road for Clinton (6/28)
Schaghticoke Tribal Nation still fighting for recognition and casino (6/28)
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe casino foes lose big source of funding (6/28)
Big Sandy Rancheria remains optimistic on plan for second casino (6/28)
Little River Band credited with sharing $30.4M in casino revenues (6/28)
Editorial: Let's leave gaming to tribes and kill Arkansas casino bid (6/28)
Supreme Court deals setback to tribes in labor sovereignty dispute (6/27)
Washington tribes win major fishing rights decision at appeals court (6/27)
Shinnecock Nation hits the end of the line with ancestral land claim (6/27)
Supreme Court won't hear Pauma Band compact negotiation case (6/27)
Witness list for Senate Indian Affairs Committee hearing on 3 bills (6/27)
Lakota Country Times: Teams compete for Indian horse relay title (6/27)
Native Sun News: Rebuilding the Lakota Nation through education (6/27)
Vi Waln: Don't be afraid to come pray with your Lakota relatives (6/27)
Clara Caufield: Out fishing on the Upper Boulder River in Montana (6/27)
Opinion: Supreme Court exposes Indian people to federal powers (6/27)
Anonymous: Fighting back against victimization in Indian Country (6/27)
Michael Sandoval: San Felipe Pueblo respects rights of neighbors (6/27)
Andre Cramblit: Fond memories of growing up with Muhammad Ali (6/27)
Linda Greenhouse: Supreme Court goes silent in high-profile case (6/27)
Partial land-into-trust fix being watched by non-Indian interests (6/27)
Omaha Tribe cooperates with federal investigation into payments (6/27)
Northwest tribes take a stand against oil terminal in Washington (6/27)
Indigenous Digital Archive Project wins grant for online database (6/27)
Donald Trump fares poorly against Hillary Clinton in national poll (6/27)
Senate provision targeted tribes with commercial gaming plans (6/27)
Poarch Creeks in deal to acquire commercial casino in Louisiana (6/27)
Kootenai Tribe hopes to lure Canadian customers back to casino (6/27)
Tribes rest easy as Supreme Court wraps up a surprising session (6/24)
Tribes in northern California take action to protect salmon runs (6/24)
Aaron Payment re-elected as chairman of Sault Ste. Marie Tribe (6/24)
Gun Lake Tribe hosts annual Sweet Grass Moon Powwow in July (6/24)
Native Sun News: First Native hockey referee 'Butchy' passes on (6/24)
Delphine Red Shirt: Lakota people denied voting rights on our land (6/24)
Ruth Hopkins: Saving sacred Bear Butte from a massive biker bar (6/24)
more headlines...

Advertisement

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.