FROM THE ARCHIVE

Rival Oneida group denied status in land claim suit

Facebook Twitter Google+
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 16, 2003

The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals last week refused to allow the Marble Hill Oneidas of New York to join the Oneida land claim suit.

In a unanimous, unpublished opinion, a three-judge panel said the Marble Hill group was adequately represented by the New York Oneida Nation. The court also said the group failed to show that it is a separate tribe.

The Oneida claim involves 64,000 acres of land illegally transferred to the state of New York. The plaintiffs are the Oneida of New York, the Oneida of Wisconsin and the Oneida of Canada. The defendants are the state of New York and two counties.

The decision in Marble Hill Oneida Indians v. Oneida Indian Nation was issued April 8.

Relevant Links:
Oneida Nation of New York - http://www.oneida-nation.net

Related Stories:
Oneida Nation land claim talks at standstill (02/10)
Mediation over land claim extended (12/06)
N.Y. land claim talks called 'fiasco' (8/12)
Oneida Nation claim could be limited (7/2)
Judge issues ruling on Oneida claim (4/3)
Oneida land deal faces major doubts (2/21)
Oneida land deal being rejected (2/20)
Wisconsin Oneida blast agreement (2/19)