Home > News > More Headlines > Mont. court accepts tribal court convictions
Printer friendly version
Mont. court accepts tribal court convictions
WEDNESDAY, JUNE 25, 2003

Tribal court records can be used against tribal members in state courts, the Montana Supreme Court ruled this week.

In a near unanimous decision, the court recognized four tribal court DUI convictions of Eugene Spotted Eagle, a member of the Blackfeet Nation. The vote in Monday's ruling was 5-1.

"To disregard a valid tribal court conviction would imply that Montana only recognizes the Blackfeet Tribe's right to self-government until it conflicts with Montana law," wrote Justice James C. Nelson for the majority.

The decision means that Spotted Eagle faces a felony, rather than a misdemeanor, sentence for a September 2001 drunk driving incident. State law allows prosecutors to "enhance" a DUI charge using tribal court records.

Spotted Eagle challenged the law on the grounds that the Blackfeet court system does not provide him with adequate protections under the U.S. Constitution. In Blackfeet court, for example, criminal defendants are not guaranteed a right to be represented by a lawyer. In state court, Spotted Eagle would be covered under the Sixth Amendment.

But the state countered that it should respect a tribe's right to self-governance. "A fundamental aspect of sovereignty is the respect accorded a sovereign by other sovereigns," wrote assistant attorney general Mark W. Mattioli in a brief. "Spotted Eagle's assertions that his prior DUI convictions were valid for purposes of tribal law, but not for purposes of Montana or federal law, is to accord second-class status to tribal sovereignty."

The majority of the Montana Supreme Court agreed with this line of thinking, noting that the state law in question is not used to determine guilt. But a dissenting judge questioned this logic and said he would have sided with Spotted Eagle.

"In true oxymoronic fashion, our court has said to Mr. Spotted Eagle, 'Out of deference to your tribe, we accord you fewer protections than guaranteed to individual citizens by the Montana Constitution,'" wrote Justice W. William Leaphart.

The Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 provides certain guarantees to tribal members, many of which follow the U.S. Constitution. But it doesn't force tribes to comply with a Sixth Amendment right to counsel or a First Amendment separation of church and state.

Get the Decision:
State v. Spotted Eagle (June 23, 2003)

Relevant Documents:
Briefs, Opinions in State v. Spotted Eagle (State Law Library of Montana)

Copyright © Indianz.Com

Stay Connected

On Facebook

On Twitter

On Google+

On SoundCloud

More Headlines

Mark Trahant: Bernie Sanders is right about Indian Health Service (7/1)
Native Sun News: Oglala Sioux Tribe celebrates historic victories (7/1)
Brandon Ecoffey: Attorney general is no friend to Indian Country (7/1)
Ivan Star Comes Out: Education system continues to oppress us (7/1)
DVIDS: Grand Ronde Tribes host local disaster training exercise (7/1)
Rachael Lorenzo: Food policies must include indigenous women (7/1)
Santa Ana Pueblo acquires large ranch that was listed for $33M (7/1)
Quapaw Tribe welcomes family home for 144th annual powwow (7/1)
White Mountain Apache Tribe recognizes student achievement (7/1)
Another guilty plea in Chippewa Cree Tribe corruption scandal (7/1)
Lumbee Tribe settles suit over unauthorized use of trademarks (7/1)
Musician brings Native language to stage in Canada Day concert (7/1)
Very few Native Americans working for technology giant Google (7/1)
Editorial: Keep guns out of hands of domestic violence offenders (7/1)
Tigua Tribe implements border controls after losing gaming case (7/1)
Supreme Court takes a pass on tribal labor sovereignty dispute (7/1)
Chasing the Dream: The impact of tribal gaming in North Dakota (7/1)
Grand Traverse Band casino employees credited with saving life (7/1)
National Park Service finalizes rule for tribal gathering of plants (6/30)
Five tribes donate over $500K to Democratic party's convention (6/30)
Bureau of Indian Affairs still hoping to reach land-into-trust goal (6/30)
Port Gamble S'Klallam Tribe secures proclamation for 410 acres (6/30)
Seminole Tribe takes a big step forward with land-into-trust bid (6/30)
Tohono O'odham Nation signs health self-governance compact (6/30)
Native Sun News: Lakota and Cheyenne people join forces again (6/30)
Lakota Country Times: Paper continues to reach large audience (6/30)
Cronkite News: Senate committee takes on tribal water issues (6/30)
Dave Archambault: A day for all of Indian Country to remember (6/30)
Vi Waln: Don't let politics get in way of our children's education (6/30)
Leonard Peltier: My last best hope for freedom lies with Obama (6/30)
Shinnecock Nation weighs options to reclaim ancestral territory (6/30)
White Mountain Apache Tribe welcomes 'significant' discovery (6/30)
Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes press for water pact (6/30)
Mille Lacs Band slams county for ending law enforcement deal (6/30)
County might end Grand Traverse Band land-into-trust appeal (6/30)
Tlingit and Haida Tribes acquire government contracting firm (6/30)
Donald Trump approved Indian gaming attack ads in New York (6/30)
Judge focuses on Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe casino decision (6/30)
Eastern Cherokee youth push for change in gaming per capita (6/30)
Buena Vista Rancheria signs updated Class III casino compact (6/30)
Connecticut tribes still working on plan for potential new casino (6/30)
Effort builds for missing and murdered Native women and girls (6/29)
Native talent among diverse group asked to join film academy (6/29)
more headlines...

Advertisement

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.