Home > News > More Headlines > Judge strikes down a trust claim in royalty suit
Printer friendly version
Judge strikes down a trust claim in royalty suit
THURSDAY, JULY 3, 2003

The federal government doesn't have a trust responsibility to "maximize" oil and gas revenues for Indian beneficiaries, a federal judge ruled last month.

On June 9, Judge Emily C. Hewitt, a judge for the U.S. Court of Claims in Washington, D.C., ruled on a motion in a long-running case involving the Eastern Shoshone Tribe and the Northern Arapaho Tribe. Siding with the Bush administration, she dismissed one of the tribes' breach of trust claims.

Hewitt relied in part on the Supreme Court's ruling in U.S. v. Navajo Nation, decided this past March against the Navajo Nation. Department of Justice attorneys interpret the outcome to mean that the government has no fiduciary duty to "maximize" Indian royalties without specific statutory, regulatory, or contractual obligations.

Hewitt agreed on this point, concluding that the tribes cannot force the Department of Interior "to go contrary to and beyond" existing law to maximize their revenues.

At the same time, Hewitt said the government is not off the hook for other mismanagement claims. She cited the existence of numerous statutes and regulations governing the handling of oil and gas royalties, finding a fiduciary relationship that would give rise to money damages if breached.

"The court, however, agrees with plaintiffs that the discretion afforded the Secretary here is not so wide as to protect defendant from liability," Hewitt wrote.

The tribes, which share the Wind River Reservation in Wyoming, filed suit in 1979 to recover millions in missing oil and gas payments. They allege that the Minerals Management Service (MMS) failed to collect the proper amount for their trust assets.

MMS is responsible for monitoring the annual collection of $6 billion in royalties and fees for minerals produced from federal and Indian lands. It plays a significant role in Interior's role as trustee but its exact fiduciary obligations to tribes and individual Indians are sometimes in dispute.

In the ongoing Cobell trial, special trustee Ross Swimmer suggested that the agency has a limited fiduciary responsibility. When MMS collects payments from an oil company, he said last Thursday, it doesn't necessarily know that the money belongs to an Indian beneficiary. That determination lies with the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and the Office of Special Trustee (OST, he testified.

As head of OST, Swimmer has oversight over MMS. The agency, in late 2001, finalized a "re-engineering" project as part of the Clinton administration's trust reform blueprint. Swimmer testified that he considered the effort a success.

Get the Decision:
Shoshone v. U.S. (June 9, 2003)

Relevant Links:
Minerals Management Service - http://www.mms.gov

Related Stories:
Audit files for Navajo lease recreated (6/11)
Navajo leaders criticize upheaval at trust fund office (05/09)
Royalty ruling impacts Indian trust (04/30)

Copyright © Indianz.Com

Stay Connected

On Facebook

On Twitter

On Google+

On SoundCloud

More Headlines

President Obama meets Native leaders after landing in Alaska (9/1)
Transcript: Obama remarks following Native leaders roundtable (9/1)
94-year-old Alaska Native elder greets Obama with Denali song (9/1)
Politicians in Ohio oppose return of Alaska Native name for peak (9/1)
Supreme Court takes up petition in Kialegee Tribal Town dispute (9/1)
Native Sun News: Teens attacked on Rosebud Sioux Reservation (9/1)
Clara Caufield: Cheyenne brothers and sisters share language (9/1)
Terese Marie Mailhot: Shutting down a new generation of hate (9/1)
Navajo Nation hires firm to pursue Gold King Mine spill lawsuit (9/1)
Young tribal members cited for wild rice harvest in Minnesota (9/1)
Lake named for war secretary who pushed for removal of tribes (9/1)
Tribal college students participate in NASA challenge in Virginia (9/1)
La Jolla Band welcomes visitors to longest zip line in California (9/1)
Chukchansi Tribe still aiming for reopening of casino this month (9/1)
President Obama restores Alaska Native name of highest peak (8/31)
BIA announces $1.75M in grants fot tribal education programs (8/31)
Multiple Capitol Hill hearings set into disaster at Gold King Mine (8/31)
Native Sun News: Oglala Sioux counselor combats youth suicide (8/31)
Native Sun News: Lakota 57 parents seek counseling for incident (8/31)
Ernestine Chasing Hawk: I remember I am alive and a survivor (8/31)
Mary Annette Pember: Native women betrayed in violence fight (8/31)
Dina Gilio-Whitaker: Blood quantum used to judge Indian people (8/31)
Sally Jewell: Native youth serve as Ambassadors for the Arctic (8/31)
Turtle Talk Poll: The enduring legacy of Supreme Court decision (8/31)
First Native woman Ashley Callingbull wins Mrs. Universe title (8/31)
Native boy lands role as son of Leonardo DiCaprio in new film (8/31)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe considers petition to legalize hemp (8/31)
Spirit Lake Nation declares state of emergency to fight drugs (8/31)
Mississippi Choctaws pick Phyllis Anderson as chief once again (8/31)
Former Pokagon Band leader to leave Michigan civil rights post (8/31)
More executives targeted in Chippewa Cree Tribe criminal probe (8/31)
Pueblo water system held hostage by county in trespassing spat (8/31)
Kootenai Tribe to create recovery plan for last wild caribou herd (8/31)
Chair of Duwamish Tribe presses Secretary Jewell on recognition (8/31)
Opinion: Islamic extremists are making inroads on reservations (8/31)
Quapaw Tribe still willing to sign no-casino pledge in Arkansas (8/31)
Seneca Nation plans $40M expansion of off-reservation casino (8/31)
Grand Portage Band works on expansion of casino near border (8/31)
BIA clarifies timeline on Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe casino bid (8/31)
Fort Mojave Indian Tribe celebrates grand reopening of casino (8/31)
EJ Montini: Horses treated better than Tohono O'odham Nation (8/31)
Native Sun News: First Nations Sculpture Garden breaks ground (8/28)
Native Sun News: Lower Brule Sioux Tribe misses Cobell deadline (8/28)
James Giago Davies: There's trouble brewing on the racist horizon (8/28)
more headlines...

Advertisement

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.