The Bush administration will have to defend its controversial historical accounting of
the Indian trust at a trial this October.
In a five-page order issued on Friday, Judge James Robertson ordered
the Interior Department to present its accounting of the Individual
Indian Money (IIM) Trust at a trial starting October 10.
He noted that it has been more than seven years since
the government was told to account for at least $13 billion owed
to more than 500,000 Indian beneficiaries across the country.
"More than seven years (and
twenty-eight quarterly status reports) after Cobell V, it is both
prudent and well within the supervisory powers of this court to
review the accounting project in detail, and to do so in open
court, where the government may present, and plaintiffs may test
or challenge, the methodology and results of the accounting
project up to the time of the hearing," Robertson wrote, citing
the landmark December 21, 1999, decision that upheld the duty
to account for the trust.
Robertson called the open-ended trial to address several unresolved questions
in the long-running Cobell case.
He hopes to determine whether the government has cured the breaches of
trust identified in the December 1999 ruling, whether the accounting
satisfies fiduciary trust standards
and whether the accounting was "unreasonably" delayed.
With the proceedings set to "continue as long as necessary," Robertson
also envisioned a visit to Interior's Indian records repository in Lenexa, Kansas.
The Bush administration opened the center to maintain documents related to the IIM
trust, which was created in 1887.
The decision marks Robertson's strong intention to resolve the 11-year-old case,
which he inherited just four months ago after Judge Royce Lamberth was removed
at the request of the Bush administration. It was Lamberth who wrote
the Cobell V decision on the accounting, an order that was upheld by the
District of Columbia Court of Appeals.
Keith Harper, an attorney for the Cobell plaintiffs, welcomed the decision
to call the trial. He said it will finally prove that the government cannot account
for the money owed to Indian beneficiaries.
"We can absolutely, conclusively demonstrate without any doubt that the United States cannot --
no matter how long they are given, no matter how many resources
they are provided -- perform the accounting that is required by law," said Harper,
a member of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma.
Government officials disagree. They say the accounting projects have uncovered
only a handful of errors in the IIM trust, which sees about $300 million to
$400 million a year in revenues from land-based activities such as oil and gas
drilling, the distribution of
judgment funds and the distribution of per capita funds.
After spending $175 million, "in large part, we're pretty darn close to where
we want to be," said Jim Cason, the associate deputy secretary at Interior,
at a recent House hearing.
Cason cautioned that the projects have mainly looked at judgement fund
and per capita fund accounts, which are not as complex and document-intensive
as the land-based accounts.
But he suggested further examination of the land-based accounts wouldn't
turn up any major errors.
Where the plaintiffs and the government agree is that at least $13 billion passed
through the IIM trust since the early 1900s. The trial, as Robertson outlined
in his order, would seek to determine whether all of the money has been accounted.
Under common trust law, it is the duty of the trustee to prove the money
went to the correct beneficiary. If that can't be shown, the beneficiary
is entitled to the money.
"So far, the way the system is set up, they don't have to prove
anything," Cason said of the plaintiffs' trust law strategy.
Citing destroyed documents and missing evidence, Harper said it is "impossible"
for the government to account for all of the funds.
He said Robertson would be able to restate the account balances
based on information the plaintiffs plan to provide at trial.
"It is up to the court to determine what alternative equitable remedies are
available to the beneficiaries," Harper said.
"That's what trust law provides."
Based on the assumption that a certain percentage of the $13 billion
was paid to the correct beneficiaries, the plaintiffs have suggested
a restatement of at least $27.5 billion, a figure that includes interest on missing payments.
The Bush administration has proposed a far lower amount, somewhere in the low
millions.
A bill introduced last year would have provided $8 billion to
settle the case. The legislation never moved forward because the Bush
administration failed to respond before the end of the 109th Congress.
Efforts to resolve the case have been renewed in the 110th Congress.
But they are tainted by the Bush administration's proposal to
settle more than 200 tribal trust lawsuits, in addition to Cobell,
and resolve other trust reform issue for up to $7 billion.
Tribes have objected to the proposal, which they have termed
"termination" of the trust. Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-North Dakota),
the chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee, said he objects
to the inclusion of tribes in any Cobell settlement.
With an eye toward the October 10 trial, Robertson plans to hold
a series of status hearings. The first is scheduled at 10am on May 9
in the federal district courthouse in Washington, D.C.
Court Order:
Cobell v. Kempthorne
(April 20,2007)
Settlement Letter:
Kempthorne-Gonzales to SCIA (March 1,
2007)
Relevant Documents:
Alberto
Gonzales Testimony (March 1, 2005) | SCIA
Views and Estimates (March 1, 2007)
Relevant Links:
Indian Trust: Cobell v. Kempthorne - http://www.indiantrust.com
Cobell
v. Norton, Department of Justice - http://www.usdoj.gov/civil/cases/cobell/index.htm
Related Stories:
Judge orders Cobell accounting trial for October
10 (4/20)
Jodi Rave: Cobell
calls for accountability (4/12)
Editorial: No justice in $7B offer to settle Cobell
(4/6)
Lawmaker questions $7B plan to
settle trust cases (4/4)
Gonzales' trust
testimony downplayed (3/30)
Listening
Lounge: House hearing on BIA-OST (3/30)
Mediator suggests $7-9B settlement for Cobell
(3/30)
Jodi Rave: Cobell calls trust
offer 'insulting' (3/30)
Senate hearing
on Indian trust fund litigation (3/29)
Gonzales won't testify on trust fund
(3/28)
Supreme Court refuses Cobell
appeals (3/27)
Editorial: The
billion-dollar question (3/26)
Senate
hearing on trust fund litigation on Thursday (3/26)
The downfall of J. Steven Griles (3/26)
Blast from the Past: NBC segment on Cobell
(3/21)
Opinion: US owes Indians billions
for theft (3/14)
Bush aide linked to
Special Trustee firing resigns (3/14)
BIA names new director for Navajo regional office
(3/14)
Mother Jones: Pennies on the
dollar for Cobell (3/12)
Bush proposes
$7B trust fund settlement (3/8)
Dorgan
and Thomas disagree on Cobell settlement (1/22)
Jodi Rave: Cobell sees hope for case in new
year (1/20)
NewStandard: Tribes turn to
court over trust funds (01/08)
Jodi
Rave: Interior mum on class action tribal suit (01/05)
Tribes file class action trust accounting
lawsuit (01/04)
Cobell honored by AARP
Magazine for trust work (12/19)
New
Cobell judge knows Interior Department (12/13)
Rahall outlines Indian agenda for 110th Congress
(12/11)
New judge assigned to Cobell
trust fund case (12/08)
Cobell wins
Impact Award from AARP Magazine (12/7)
Editorial: No hope for a Cobell-only settlement
(12/1)
McCain staffer: No 'hijinx'
during lame-duck (11/24)
Editorial:
Another good shot emerges for Cobell (11/10)
Cobell says Bush kills legislative settlement
(11/9)
Tribal opposition to trust reform
bill growing (11/2)
Editorial: End
federal management of trust (11/1)
Tribes face trust challenges from Bush
administration (10/31)
Cobell attorney
criticizes Bush changes to bill (10/27)
Staff confirms Bush behind Cobell proposals
(10/26)
Bush seeks major changes to
Cobell bill (10/24)
Senate committee
holds more Cobell meetings (10/23)
Time
running out on Cobell settlement bill (10/23)
Cobell sees parallels in Aboriginal wage theft
(10/16)
NCAI to consider resolution in
support of Cobell bill (10/6)
Bush
assailed for 'ambush' on Indian health care (10/5)
Latest delay in Cobell settlement tied to White
House (10/3)
Cobell: Interior mishandles
Indian money too (10/2)
Navajo woman
fights for trust fund accountability (9/25)
Senate committee sends Cobell letter to Kempthorne
(9/18)
Interior delays Cobell settlement
legislation (9/15)
McCain firm on $8B
settlement for Cobell (9/5)
Senate staff
to discuss Cobell settlement in Tulsa (8/30)
Cobell shifts appeal strategy to keep judge on case
(8/29)
Cobell fights for judge in trust
fund case (8/25)
Senate committee to
discuss Cobell settlement (8/24)
Human
Rights Magazine: Cobell, Native issues (8/22)
Editorial: Justice for Indian account holders
(8/18)
Professor: Removal of Judge
Lamberth a tragedy (8/7)
Cobell eager to
settle Indian trust fund lawsuit (8/7)
Letter: Nearly $1B wasted on Swimmer's trust reform
(8/7)
Editorial: Stop delaying settlement
to Cobell (8/4)
McCain puts twist in
Cobell settlement bill (8/3)
Bush
officials asked McCain to delay Cobell settlement (8/3)
Cobell settlement bill 'dead' in Congress
(8/2)
Time running out on Cobell
settlement bill (7/28)
Editorial: It's
time for settlement on Cobell (7/28)
Ross Swimmer: Interior still 'working' on trust
(7/28)
Cobell issues statement on
settlement talks (7/25)
Cobell
settlement awaited in Indian Country (7/25)
Jodi Rave: Cobell worried about settlement
legislation (7/24)
Mark Trahant: It's
time for the U.S. to keep its word (7/17)
Editorial: Lamberth too honest in trust fund case
(7/17)
Cooler heads sought in Indian
trust fund fight (7/14)
Lamberth removed
from Cobell trust fund case (7/12)
Lamberth is third judge removed by D.C. Circuit
(7/12)
Cobell settlement rumored to be
in the billions (7/5)
Cobell rallies for
support on trust fund lawsuit (06/19)
Editorial: Give Kempthorne a chance on Cobell
(6/15)
Cobell files contempt charges
against Kempthorne (6/13)
Editorial:
Dirk Kempthorne arrives in Washington (6/13)
Swimmer calls Cobell settlement 'reparations'
(5/8)
Cobell: Settle Indian trust fund
case for billions (4/20)
Cobell to appear
on C-SPAN Washington Journal (4/12)
Cobell renews call for receiver as court hears case
(4/12)
Cobell vows fight to resolve
trust fund lawsuit (4/10)
Cobell plans
big showing on day of court hearing (4/4)
Jodi Rave: Tribes alarmed at trust reform
initiative (4/3)
Cobell addresses trust
fund mismanagement (3/30)
Ross Swimmer:
Indian trust not about mismanagement (3/29)
Norton denies fraud or major problem with trust
(3/29)
GAO report warns of billions in
lost oil, gas royalties (3/29)
Witness
list for hearing on Indian Trust Reform Act (3/28)
DOI trust reform meeting set for Portland, Oregon
(3/24)
Kempthorne faces hot issues at
Interior Department (3/21)
DOI pressed
for more clarity on trust initiative (3/3)
Congress urged to settle Cobell lawsuit for
billions (03/02)
Listening Lounge: Joint
hearing on Cobell v. Norton (03/01)
Interior hits the road with new trust reform
initiative (02/08)
Jodi Rave: Garcia
calls for settlement of Cobell (2/3)
Cason slashes BIA budget and blames it on Cobell
(2/3)
Tribes discuss trust reform bill,
Cobell settlement (1/31)
Commentary:
Swimmer still not telling the truth on trust (1/26)
Opinion: Indians want $12B of 'YOUR' money
(01/10)

Cobell
Cobell judge orders historical accounting trial
Monday, April 23, 2007
Stay Connected
Contact Us
indianz@indianz.com202 630 8439 (THEZ)
Search
Top Stories
Most Read
1 Film set on Pine Ridge Reservation already called one of the year's best
2 Top Trump officials skipped out on tribal consultation session amid big changes
3 Tribes prepare for takeover of troubled Indian Health Service hospital
4 Navajo Nation mourns passing of Code Talker Roy Hawthorne at age of 92
5 Chippewa Cree Tribe breaks ground on youth-driven skate park on reservation
2 Top Trump officials skipped out on tribal consultation session amid big changes
3 Tribes prepare for takeover of troubled Indian Health Service hospital
4 Navajo Nation mourns passing of Code Talker Roy Hawthorne at age of 92
5 Chippewa Cree Tribe breaks ground on youth-driven skate park on reservation
More Stories
Three guilty for hate crime attacks in Utah Sand Creek Massacre site to be dedicated this week
News Archive
2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000