“As this matter moves forward to appeal, as we anticipate, we will continue to fight for what rightfully belongs to federally-recognized tribes,” said President Jonathan Nez of the Navajo Nation, one of the plaintiffs in the case. The possibility of further appeals means tribes won’t have much flexibility in spending what’s left in the coronavirus relief fund. Through the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act, also known as the CARES Act, Congress required the money to be spent by December 31. If not, the funds will revert back to the Department of the Treasury, the agency whose handling of the COVID-19 relief has been marred by repeated delays, a breach of sensitive tribal data and, of course, litigation. “This win, of course, comes at a cost to tribal governments of something very valuable: time,” said Chief Chuck Hoskin, Jr. of the Cherokee Nation, whose tribe was involved in a different CARES Act lawsuit against the Trump administration.
U.S. District Court of Appeals rules in favor of Federally-recognized tribes in CARES Act litigation pic.twitter.com/ewJfg3Zswo— Navajo Nation President Jonathan Nez (@NNPrezNez) September 25, 2020
Yet the same deadline applies to the ANCs. Should they eventually prevail, they won’t have much time to spend the money either, even though their shareholders and the communities they serve have been dealing with the coronavirus for just as long as the rest of Indian Country. “This ruling is a devastating blow to Alaska Native communities facing an alarming increase in COVID-19,” the ANCSA Regional Association and the Alaska Native Village Corporation Association said of the September 25 decision from the appeals court. “We fear this deeply flawed ruling will only make things worse by keeping critical health services and economic relief from reaching our remote communities and villages who are most at risk,” the organizations added in a statement. “As a leading voice for Alaska’s Native communities, the ANCSA Regional Association and Alaska Native Village Corporation Association will continue to fight for the federal assistance our people need to survive this pandemic,” they said.
Cherokee Nation Principal Chief @ChuckHoskin_Jr issues the following statement today on the court’s opinion regarding Alaska Native Corporations non-entitlement to CARES Act funds. pic.twitter.com/Jt3dX2FVgy— CherokeeNation (@CherokeeNation) September 25, 2020
Trump has nominated Amy Coney Barrett, a federal appeals court judge with virtually no experience in Indian law, to fill the vacancy left by Ginsburg’s passing on September 18 at the age of 87. Republicans are moving quickly to confirm the president’s pick, with confirmation hearings scheduled to begin on October 12. Through the CARES Act, Congress authorized a total of $150 billion in COVID-19 relief for tribes, states and local governments. Of the overall amount, $8 billion was set aside for tribal governments, though the law did not explicitly define the term. The CARES Act instead made reference to “Indian tribes,” as defined by the Indian Self- Determination and Education Assistance Act. The landmark law, which dates to 1975, authorizes tribal governments, as well as Alaska Native corporations, to manage federal programs as they see fit. Relying on the long-standing definition, the Department of the Treasury concluded that ANCs are entitled to shares of the $8 billion coronavirus relief fund. The D.C. Circuit, however, said Treasury got it wrong. While ANCs are “Indian tribes” for purposes of self-determination contracts, they are not “recognized” governments that enjoy a unique relationship with the United States by virtue of their inherent sovereignty, Judge Katsas wrote for the court. “The ANCs have not satisfied the recognition clause as we construe it,” Katsos observed after recounting the history of the termination era, in which some tribes lost their government-to-government status, that preceded the age of self-determination. “They do not contend that the United States has acknowledged a political relationship with them government-to-government,” he said of the Native corporations, of which there are more than 200 in Alaska. Alaska is also home to more than 220 sovereign tribal governments. Like their counterparts in the lower 48, they too have received shares of the coronavirus relief fund. But Treasury’s allocation method has exposed a disparity in Alaska. While about $535 million has been set aside for the ANCs, the tribes in the 49th state have received only about $308 million, according to data posted on usaspending.gov, a federal government site that was recently updated with COVID-19 spending.
With their campaigns at stake, Republicans are rushing to confirm a federal judge with virtually no experience in Indian law to the nation's highest court. #AmyConeyBarrett #SupremeCourt #NativeVote #NativeVote20 #NativeVote2020https://t.co/lnovZ5SPfz— indianz.com (@indianz) September 29, 2020
Dispute over COVID-19 relief for tribal nations spills into Biden administration
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Native America Calling: When to turn to speech therapy
Native America Calling: The value of Native-owned bookstores
Cronkite News: Republican pardoned in connection with Oak Flat land deal
Native America Calling: Oak Flat at a crossroads
Day 1 of the Joe Biden administration: Actions affecting Indian Country
Schedule for Joe Biden inauguration and first actions in office as president
Native America Calling: New administration, new agenda
Federal prosecutors label Cowboys for Trump figure ‘racist’ for attacks on Native and Black people
Self-proclaimed Native Republican Jorge Riley charged for role in U.S. Capitol attack
Tim Giago: Will Republicans pay the price for January 6?
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation preserves hunting and fishing sites
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week