Indianz.Com > News > Cronkite News: Court rules against Navajo voters in ballot lawsuit
Court: Mailed Navajo ballots should not get extra time to be counted
Monday, October 19, 2020
Cronkite News
WASHINGTON – Native Americans may face barriers to voting in general, but that is not enough to require that ballots mailed from the Navajo Nation get 10 extra days to be counted, a federal appeals court said Thursday.
The ruling by a 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel upheld a lower court that rejected the suit by six Navajo voters. The courts said the plaintiffs failed to show that their voting rights would be harmed by postal delays or helped by an extension – or even that they planned to vote by mail this election.
The ruling
is the latest in a flurry of election challenges heard by the court in recent weeks. It was welcomed by election officials in northern Arizona who said an extension for Navajo ballots would be neither fair nor practical.
“I just don’t think it’s really feasible and we would want to do it for all voters, not just voters on the Navajo Nation,” said Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen. “That to me would be not correct” because most of the county is rural, not just the part that is Navajo Nation land.
A consultant working on the Navajo voters’ case conceded that Thursday’s ruling probably means the fight is over for this election – but said it’s not the end of the larger fight.
“Sometimes these battles take awhile,” said Bret Healy of the Native American advocacy group Four Directions.
Furthermore, the solution the voters asked for was not feasible, just weeks before the election, and would not fix the problem, the court said. “Even assuming that it is possible to tell whether a given mail ballot originated from the reservation and not somewhere else in the precinct, the record does not indicate how to tell whether the ballot was cast by an enrolled member of the Navajo Nation,” the court wrote, pointing out that not everyone on the reservation is an enrolled tribal member. Hansen said her office has put some measures in place to make sure mailed ballots are not delayed, such as having the Postal Service “trap” ballots in Flagstaff so they “don’t get sent down to Phoenix and back up here.” “We try really hard to make sure we can count the ballots … and try to go the extra mile,” she said.An update on our #NativeVote2020 Navajo Nation GOTV program. Please consider making a donation using the link in our profile to support our programs. And visit us at https://t.co/5P85DxKNJ5 for more links and information. pic.twitter.com/sCqW6Du9uY
— Four Directions Native Vote (@4directionsvote) October 18, 2020
The court also cited the Purcell doctrine – named for former Maricopa County Recorder Helen Purcell – which discourages court-ordered changes to election procedures close to Election Day. “Dismissal of this last-minute challenge to a decades-old rule should be fair notice to plaintiffs who want to tackle the deadline in the future,” the court said. Healy said time is not the only challenge Native Americans face in court. “I’m not sure when a Native American plaintiff would have to bring a case to be successful,” he said.Sec. Hobbs: Yazzie v Hobbs lead plaintiff Darlene Yazzie “had to complete her ballot the moment she received it — in the doorway of the Dennehotso post office, which social-distancing rules forbade her to enter — because taking it home might have meant submitting it too late.” https://t.co/04JFnX8k1D
— Four Directions Native Vote (@4directionsvote) October 15, 2020
Note: This story originally appeared on Cronkite News. It is published via a Creative Commons license. Cronkite News is produced by the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University.
Search
Filed Under
Tags
More Headlines
Native America Calling: One fan’s vision to share his collection of Native music
Native America Calling: Confronting persistent racism in North Dakota high school sports
Native America Calling: Successful strategies to reduce bullying
KUNC: Gila River Indian Community charts own course when it comes to water supply
AUDIO: Becerra v. San Carlos Apache Tribe / Becerra v. Northern Arapaho Tribe
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation fights for clean water in Oklahoma
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Native America Calling: Remembering Seward from the Alaska Native perspective
Native America Calling: The Exxon Valdez oil spill
Native America Calling: Western tribes weigh in on Colorado River water sharing
Native America Calling: Native hoops highlights
Native America Calling: Whiskey Tender by Deborah Jackson Taffa
Cronkite News: Congress takes up ban on popular TikTok app
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation focuses on needs of our children
More Headlines
Native America Calling: Confronting persistent racism in North Dakota high school sports
Native America Calling: Successful strategies to reduce bullying
KUNC: Gila River Indian Community charts own course when it comes to water supply
AUDIO: Becerra v. San Carlos Apache Tribe / Becerra v. Northern Arapaho Tribe
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation fights for clean water in Oklahoma
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Native America Calling: Remembering Seward from the Alaska Native perspective
Native America Calling: The Exxon Valdez oil spill
Native America Calling: Western tribes weigh in on Colorado River water sharing
Native America Calling: Native hoops highlights
Native America Calling: Whiskey Tender by Deborah Jackson Taffa
Cronkite News: Congress takes up ban on popular TikTok app
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation focuses on needs of our children
More Headlines