“Dineh Benally and his investors sought to take advantage of what they believed to be a jurisdictional gap on the Navajo Nation that would allow them to operate outside the law,” Navajo Nation President Jonathan Nez said in a statement Tuesday. “They did not count on the diligence or effectiveness of the Navajo Nation Department of Justice to be able to enforce our own laws through our own courts,” Nez’s statement said. Benally started his hemp operation last year and it now includes over 1,000 greenhouses and spans more than 400 acres in the Four Corners area, according to the Navajo Justice Department. The land is leased from Navajo farmers who formerly used it to raise corn. Benally appeared to ramp up operations on his farms after the COVID-19 pandemic hit, according to reporting by Searchlight New Mexico, exploiting Chinese workers from California, many of whom said they lost their jobs because of the pandemic.
The Navajo Police Department is informing the public that a multiagency operation is underway in Shiprock, N.M. At this time, we stress that there is no threat in the community and we ask the public to refrain from interfering with police activity. More info will be provided. pic.twitter.com/vjDjCAlYCP— Navajo Nation President Jonathan Nez (@NNPrezNez) November 9, 2020
These reports led Sen. Martin Heinrich, D-New Mexico, to ask the U.S. Attorney for New Mexico to look into “disturbing reports of human trafficking and child labor” on the farms, including “children as young as 10 … reportedly among the vulnerable labor pool, working in hazardous conditions with reports of numerous Navajo Nation Environmental Protection Agency violations.” Benally’s business stirred up strong feelings in Shiprock, where neighbors protested his operation for much of the summer, according to ongoing reporting by the Navajo Times. Neighbors told the Times that Benally’s operation was illegal, that he was bringing in workers from off the reservation despite the COVID-19 lockdown and they criticized the Navajo Nation for not moving more quickly to investigate Benally. In June, the Navajo Nation sued Benally and his two companies, Native American Agriculture Co. and Navajo Gold Co. After a September hearing and “overwhelming testimony from community members and Navajo Nation officials,” the Navajo Nation’s Shiprock District Court granted a motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction halting Benally’s operations. According to documents in that suit, the Navajo Nation does not allow cultivation of cannabis with THC levels above 0.3% and it does not allow hemp production – with the exception of one pilot project – because it has yet to create a regulatory system for the product.
Here are some pictures of Navajo EPA inspections of Dineh Benally’s hemp greenhouses and hoop houses in Northern Navajo Agency. pic.twitter.com/v5J22g0W2F— Arlyssa Becenti🗞🖊 (@ABecenti) October 8, 2020
Benally’s attorney could not be reached for comment Tuesday. But in published reports, Benally maintained that his hemp operation is legal, producing only low-THC, over-the-counter products. He claimed he had authority to issue hemp permits as president of the Navajo Nation’s San Juan River Farm Board – a job he lost last week to Beatrice Redfeather-Benally, an outspoken critic. Benally’s business partner, Irving Lin, said in an October affidavit that he “came to understand that the promises and representations made … to get me to invest in his operation were not true.” “I have come to realize that the ‘hemp’ permits for which I paid Dineh Benally were in fact complete fabrications as Benally has zero authority to issue any permits on behalf of the Navajo Nation or even the San Juan River Farm Board,” said Lin, a Los Angeles-based real estate agent and investor in Benally’s farm operation. After it won the temporary restraining order, Navajo officials gained access to Benally’s farms and confirmed some of the neighbor’s other complaints, including that “a significant portion of the crop being grown appeared to be marijuana,” the Navajo Justice Department said. “It became apparent that a significant number of foreign workers had been employed by these operations with significant financial investment.” Based on “an extensive inspection and review of the farming operations,” the Navajo Environmental Protection Agency believes the operation may have violated tribal and federal EPA regulations. “The lands of the Navajo Nation belong to the Navajo people who depend on it for survival,” said Navajo Nation EPA Director Oliver Whaley. “The Navajo Nation EPA will continue to work to ensure the lands are safely and properly restored to their proper state following the abuse of these farming operations.” Despite the court orders, Lin said Benally told him in early October that farm operations were continuing and that scheduled deliveries would go on. Late last month, the Navajo Nation also sued the 33 farmers whose land Benally leased for his operations. Navajo Nation Attorney General Doreen N. McPaul said the nation “is committed to continuing to work in close coordination with our federal partners while aggressively pursuing justice in the courts of the Navajo Nation.” For more stories from Cronkite News, visit cronkitenews.azpbs.org.
Shiprock community along with American Indian Movement protesting Dineh Benally’s hemp greenhouse.— Arlyssa Becenti🗞🖊 (@ABecenti) September 14, 2020
Not surprised I see no local leadership such as chapter president or council delegates. pic.twitter.com/vl86iVBuUK
Note: This story originally appeared on Cronkite News. It is published via a Creative Commons license. Cronkite News is produced by the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University.
National Congress of American Indians | State of Indian Nations #SOIN2021
Cronkite News: State of Indian Nations remains ‘strong’ despite numerous challenges
Indian Health Service ‘ahead of schedule’ with COVID-19 vaccination rollout
Recap: #DebForInterior confirmation hearing (Day 2)
Native America Calling: February in the news
Judge Diane Humetewa | Justice in Indian Country
Bureau of Indian Affairs opens consultation on federal recognition
Department of Housing and Urban Development hosts tribal consultation
Native America Calling: Deb Haaland’s road ahead
A call to action: Native communities’ priorities in focus for the 117th Congress
Tim Giago: We need a Native American on the federal judge’s bench
Chuck Hoskin: The Cherokee Nation must honor its word
Hearing to Consider the Nomination of the Honorable Debra Haaland to be the Secretary of the Interior (Day 2)
Recap: #DebForInterior confirmation hearing