Indianz.Com > News > Howard Center for Investigative Journalism: Child sexual abuse in Indian Country goes unprosecuted
The federal trust
‘No justice, just unfairness’
Tuesday, August 24, 2021
Howard Center for Investigative Journalism
Chapter 2 of four parts
Every day that Christine Benally looks out of the window of her home, she’s reminded of how the federal government failed to protect her child. Some 200 yards away sits the house of the man she says sexually assaulted her son.
In November 2005, Benally’s then-13-year-old son told her that he had been sexually abused by a relative over several years. What happened next, based on records Benally provided to the Howard Center, was a by-the-book approach to seeking help.
Benally filed a crime report with the Navajo Nation Police Department in Shiprock, New Mexico, and also contacted social services. When she and her son met with police, they provided the names of those involved, including the suspect, the time frame of the incidents and location of the alleged crimes. According to Navajo police records, the suspect “confessed to the allegations.”
Where ‘truth comes to die’
FBI agents are often the federal government’s first representative on the scene of a reported crime in Indian Country, even though they may live and work hundreds of miles away. In Colorado, for example, the Southern Ute Indian Tribe and the Ute Mountain Ute Tribe are between a 320- and 400-mile drive from the Denver offices of the FBI and U.S. attorney. Given that the FBI has no 911-like intake process, agents are always one degree removed from any Indian Country investigation.
The Justice Department’s inspector general also noted that FBI agents received inadequate training, despite the unique cultural, jurisdictional and geographic challenges of working in Indian Country. High-turnover rates among agents working in Indian Country, considered a hardship post under agency guidelines, make it difficult to build relationships with tribal authorities, which ultimately affects the quality of investigations.
Timothy Purdon, the former U.S. attorney for North Dakota, said there was sometimes a “lack of quality investigations” so that when an abuse case reached the federal prosecutor’s desk there was insufficient evidence for a conviction. He said he often encouraged his FBI partners to allocate more resources for investigating child sexual abuse in Indian Country: “You’re constantly fighting with the Bureau to get them to prioritize these cases.”
The former FBI agent in Indian Country, who asked not to be named so that he could speak freely, said the decision to decline a child sex abuse case had a lot to do with a prosecutor’s “comfort level” and that U.S. attorneys were more accustomed to cases that are “cut and dried.”
He also said there was virtually no oversight, beyond front-line supervisors, of FBI agents’ decisions to close cases, and senior management “never ever look at (closed) cases due to insufficient evidence in Indian Country.”
Wyn Hornbuckle, the Justice Department spokesman, highlighted seven cases over the last six years of “significant prosecution” of child sex abuse in Indian Country, leading to convictions, ranging from life to less than two years.
But even when such cases seemingly have everything needed for conviction, they can still fall apart.
In September 2013, Leo Thompson, a member of the Navajo Nation, pleaded guilty to sexually abusing his girlfriend’s granddaughter when she was 12. But before his sentencing hearing, the victim sent two letters to the court recanting her accusation. From there the case collapsed — charges were dropped, and Thompson went free.
Indianz.Com
Researchers Grace Oldham and Rachel Gold contributed to this story. It was produced by the Howard Center for Investigative Journalism at Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication, an initiative of the Scripps Howard Foundation in honor of the late news industry executive and pioneer Roy W. Howard. For more see azpbs.org/littlevictims. Contact the Howard Center for Investigative Journalism at howardcenter@asu.edu or on Twitter @HowardCenterASU.
Related Stories
Howard Center for Investigative Journalism: Child sexual abuse in Indian Country goes unprosecuted (August 18, 2021)
Search
Filed Under
Tags
More Headlines
Native America Calling: Successful strategies to reduce bullying
KUNC: Gila River Indian Community charts own course when it comes to water supply
AUDIO: Becerra v. San Carlos Apache Tribe / Becerra v. Northern Arapaho Tribe
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation fights for clean water in Oklahoma
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Native America Calling: Remembering Seward from the Alaska Native perspective
Native America Calling: The Exxon Valdez oil spill
Native America Calling: Western tribes weigh in on Colorado River water sharing
Native America Calling: Native hoops highlights
Native America Calling: Whiskey Tender by Deborah Jackson Taffa
Cronkite News: Congress takes up ban on popular TikTok app
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation focuses on needs of our children
Native America Calling: Native liver disease and transplants
Joint Statement: Organizations demand support for our youth
More Headlines
KUNC: Gila River Indian Community charts own course when it comes to water supply
AUDIO: Becerra v. San Carlos Apache Tribe / Becerra v. Northern Arapaho Tribe
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation fights for clean water in Oklahoma
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Native America Calling: Remembering Seward from the Alaska Native perspective
Native America Calling: The Exxon Valdez oil spill
Native America Calling: Western tribes weigh in on Colorado River water sharing
Native America Calling: Native hoops highlights
Native America Calling: Whiskey Tender by Deborah Jackson Taffa
Cronkite News: Congress takes up ban on popular TikTok app
NAFOA: 5 Things You Need to Know this Week
Chuck Hoskin: Cherokee Nation focuses on needs of our children
Native America Calling: Native liver disease and transplants
Joint Statement: Organizations demand support for our youth
More Headlines