Who are Ohetica Win Elyxis Gardner, 13; Alexandria White Plume, 14; and Winter Rose Thomas, 15? If you don’t know you are not alone. Millions of people may never know about these three young ladies because for all intent and purpose, the national media has seen fit not to cover their unsolved deaths on the Wind River Indian Reservation in Wyoming.
The people of Wind River have not forgotten them. Jake Bell, the grandfather of Ohetica, is still mourning her death and he is still trying to find out how and why she died in a rental home in the Beaver Creek housing development on the Wind River Reservation on June 6, 2008.
Winter Rose had just graduated from the eighth grade. She was learning the Arapaho language and was respectful of her grandmother, who had raised her since she was a baby. Friends say she was outgoing, attractive, took pride in her health and appearance and she sang beautifully.
All three girls were members of the Northern Arapaho Tribe of Wyoming. It now seems they have become statistics and their families and friends will never find closure, but will continue to mourn until someone can lets them know how these children died.
Winter Rose Thomas was the daughter of Julianne Standing Elk but was raised by Lloyd and Debra Jenkins of Arapahoe, Wyoming. Ohetica Win Gardner was the granddaughter of Rachel and Oscar Hollow Horn of Wounded Knee, S. D. on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. Rachel, now deceased, was one of the descendants of the Survivors of Wounded Knee. Alexandria is the daughter of Alex White Plume from Manderson on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation.
The Beaver Creek housing development, where the bodies of the three girls were discovered, sits on a nearly treeless, windswept hill. The Tribes’ new Wind River Casino, sits directly across the road from the housing. Several of the rental homes have their windows boarded up and the yard and areas around the homes is strewn with cardboard cups, wrappers and broken glass, according to a report in the Casper Tribune.
In a twist of irony, while many members of the Tribe celebrated the grand opening of their new casino, across the street cars filled with family members and others filled with friends, pulled into the Beaver Creek housing where the bodies of the girls were found the night before.
The Wind River Reservation is like many of the Indian reservation scattered across the Northern Plains; out of sight and out of mind to the majority of Americans. Many of these reservations have been infiltrated by drug dealers mostly from Mexico and they have managed to find willing accomplices among tribal members to sell and distribute the illegal drugs, particularly crack-cocaine, that is devastating the lives of so many Indian youngsters.
While the national media can fill nearly every news spot with seemingly endless and mindless stories about the “Balloon Boy” and can give 24-hour coverage to the disappearance of one, young white girl, the mysterious deaths of three Arapaho teenagers goes unnoticed.
Hispanics and African Americans have been complaining for years that they have been witnesses to many kidnappings and murders of their young people also, but these happening are either never reported upon by the national news media, or are printed so far on the inside pages of the major newspapers as to be virtually invisible. The same can be said of the 24/7 television news stations like CNN and MSNBC. They fill their broadcasts with so many idiotic, nonsensical stories that they have become irrelevant to the news hungry minorities just dying to see something pertinent to their very existence. But Hispanics and African Americans do get 1,000 times the coverage as Native Americans.
If you have never heard of the deaths of these three young Arapaho girls I hope you now know why. It usually follows that unseemly deaths like this are followed by rumors, but in this case, where many residents believe nothing is forthcoming because of the bungling and inadequacy of the local law enforcement agencies, there needs to be honest answers made available.
To keep an entire Indian reservation in darkness while its people continue to wonder and mourn the deaths of these young girls; who were daughters, nieces, cousins and friends to many at Wind River, is a perpetuation of their deaths. If justice cannot be served, at least give the people some honest answers.
Tim Giago, an Oglala Lakota, is the publisher of Native Sun News. He was the
founder and first president of the Native American Journalists Association, the
1985 recipient of the H. L. Mencken Award, and a Nieman Fellow at Harvard with
the Class of 1991. Giago was inducted into the South Dakota Newspaper Hall of
Fame in 2008. He can be reached at email@example.com.
More Tim Giago:Tim Giago: Tribe responds to corruption
(11/4) Tim Giago: Tribal governments
(11/2) Tim Giago: Airing
allegations of tribal corruption
(10/26) Tim Giago: Native Sun a watchdog for tribes, public
(10/21) Tim Giago: Can ceremonies save
(10/19) Tim Giago:
'Wizard' author backed genocide
(10/12) Tim Giago: Indians left out of bison roundup
(10/9) Tim Giago: Racism against Native
(10/5) Tim Giago: Another nail
in the coffin of smokers
Sun Editorial: Mascots are not an honor
(9/22) Tim Giago: Leaving the anger and the meanness
(9/21) Tim Giago: Indian Reorganization
Act turns 75
(9/14) Tim Giago: They
could not kill Lakota spirituality
(9/7) Tim Giago: Don't take IHS criticism at face value
(8/31) Tim Giago: Coffee and bagels with
(8/24) Tim Giago: Real
problems of US health care
Giago: Sotomayor puts dent in glass ceiling
(8/10) Tim Giago: Standing ground at Mount Rushmore
(8/3) Tim Giago: Voting Native and
(7/27) Tim Giago:
Rapid City is changing for the better
(7/20) Tim Giago: Frontier mentality still alive in 2009
(7/13) Tim Giago: The execution of Chief
(7/6) Tim Giago: McDonald's
mentality needs revamp
(6/29) Tim Giago:
National health care debate and IHS
(6/22) Tim Giago: South Dakota restricts tribal growth
(6/15) Tim Giago: No more status quo for
(6/8) Tim Giago: Being
Indian and being independent
Giago: Let Oglala Sioux president do her job
(5/27) Tim Giago: Memorial Day speech at Black Hills
(5/25) Tim Giago: Small victories in
battle against mascots
(5/18) Tim Giago:
A day of tribal victory at Little Bighorn
(5/11) Tim Giago: Negative Native images in the news
(5/4) Tim Giago: Resolving ownership of
the Black Hills
(4/27) Tim Giago: Good
things and bad things come in April
(4/20) Tim Giago: An open letter to South Dakota governor
(4/13) Tim Giago: Nostalgia and South
(4/6) Tim Giago: An
older brother who paved the way
(3/30) Tim Giago: Sticks and stones and Charles Trimble
(3/17) Tim Giago: Pine Ridge team
triumphs at tournament
(3/16) Tim Giago:
Announcing the Native Sun News
Giago: No winners at Wounded Knee 1973
(3/5) Tim Giago: The real victims of Wounded Knee 1973
(3/2) Tim Giago: No outrage over abuse
(2/23) Tim Giago: A
perspective on the fairness doctrine
(2/16) Tim Giago: Throwing Tom Daschle under the bus
(2/9) Tim Giago: Native people out of
sight, out of mind
(2/2) Tim Giago:
Native veteran loses fight against VA
(1/26) Tim Giago: The Wellbriety Journey for Forgiveness
(1/19) Tim Giago: The stolen generations
in the U.S.
(1/12) Tim Giago: Indian
Country looks to Tom Daschle for help