Editorial: Anti-immigrant law proves to be 'costly failure'

Monday, April 25, 2011  

"A year later, SB 1070 looks like a big, expensive con. It brought us boycotts, lost business, a sullied reputation, another court battle and a betrayal of Arizona's heritage.

Oh, yes. And it did nothing to make the border safer or reduce illegal immigration.

The national spotlight made Arizona look like a place where extremism is the norm. International media lapped up each outrageous statement from SB 1070 supporters. Comedians ripped a hole in the state's dignity bigger than the Grand Canyon.

Yet SB 1070 initially got good poll numbers. It was popular for two reasons. 1) The leaders who sold it to the state were that convincing. 2) People were frustrated with federal inaction. Some saw SB 1070 as a wake-up call to Washington. A year later, Congress is still sleeping.

Recent discussions from the White House about comprehensive immigration reform were the result of President Barack Obama's need to woo Latino voters before the 2012 election. Not SB 1070."

Get the Story:
Editorial: SB 1070 has been a costly failure (The Arizona Republic 4/23)

Related Stories:
Cherokee Nation joins tribes in opposing Arizona immigrant law (8/18)
Judge blocks major provisions of Arizona's anti-immigration law (7/29)
Arizona governor redirects some stimulus money to border tribes (07/20)
Tohono O'odham Nation submits brief in immigration law dispute (7/15)
Obama administration sues to block Arizona anti-immigrant law (7/7)
Rodriguez: Anti-immigration law spurred by manifest insanity (6/21)
Arizona governor wants tribal cooperation on immigrant law (6/15)
Rihanna moves concert to venue at Pascua Yaqui Tribe casino (6/9)
Boycott of Arizona not affecting Pascua Yaqui casino venue (6/8)
Rodriguez: Arizona is speeding towards an apartheid state (05/31)
Tohono O'odham Nation opposes state anti-immigration law (5/21)
Muscogee Nation weighs stance on Arizona immigration law (5/13)
Editorial: Taking a stance against state's immigration law (5/7)
Arizona tribes worried about state's anti-immigration law (5/3)