A statue featuring a nearly naked Native man at the feet of a cowboy and a Catholic missionary is coming down in San Francisco, California.
"Early Days" is part of the Pioneer Monument
near city hall. The symbols and imagery on it are told "from a Euro-American point of view," the staff on the city's arts commission said in a report that was written following deadly
in Virginia last fall.
“It’s more than just racist,” activist Mariposa Villaluna of Take Down The 'Pioneer' Statue in San Francisco Now
told The New York Times. “It celebrates human subjugation.”
According to the art commission staff report
, "Early Days" features symbols of key people and key periods of time in California history. It pays tribute to the gold mining era, which contributed to genocide of Native peoples and the loss of their homelands, and to people like Junipero
, who was the founder of the brutal
Indian mission system
But indigenous peoples, their history or their contributions to the state, are not depicted at all except for the statue of the Native man who is clad in just a blanket. A panel in "Early Days" also features a series of Native people "naked and barefooted," the staff report stated.
All of those portions will be gone once "Early Days" is removed and placed in storage. There are no plans for a replacement monument but a plaque will be installed to explain why it was removed.
The San Francisco Arts Commission voted unanimously to remove "Early Days" at a meeting on Monday
Read More on the Story:
SF to remove ‘Early Days’ statue over racist depiction of Native Americans
(The San Francisco Examiner March 5, 2018)
San Francisco will remove pioneer statue some call racist
(The Associated Press March 6, 2018)
Arts Commission Unanimously Votes To Remove 'Early Days' Statue
(Hoodline March 6, 2018)
San Francisco Will Remove Controversial Statue of Native American Man
(The New York Times March 7, 2018)
After final vote, city will remove racist Pioneer Monument statue
(Curbed SF March 7, 2018)
San Francisco to remove what's been called a 'racist and disrespectful' statue
(CNN March 8, 2018)
Join the Conversation
looks at symbols of White supremacy in mascots, monuments
(March 1, 2018)
Francis fails to address mistreatment of tribes in California
mass features reading in Native language from California