"One clever fellow, a well-paid lawyer for the Tohono O'odham Nation in southern Arizona, recently guessed - correctly - that I had authored a Republic editorial that criticized the tribe's plan to build a new casino-resort adjacent to Glendale on land the tribe bought in 2003. He wrote me a letter in response. A not-nice letter, I'm sorry to say.

On behalf of The Republic, I wrote on July 31 that the casino plan is not a good idea. I'll shake out a few of the details later in this column, but, generally speaking, we - which, yes, includes me - believe the Glendale casino proposal threatens the exclusive hold tribes now enjoy regarding casino gambling.

We said the casino project mocks the expectations of voters, who in 2002 gave tribes the exclusive right to operate casinos in Arizona, albeit with a number of conditions. Big among those conditions - maybe the biggest - was that the number of casinos in metro Phoenix would not grow. Uncounted politicians, legal experts and tribal leaders assured the voting public then that the number of casinos was fixed.

Alas, there was fine print. Casinos could be built only on official tribal trust land. But that didn't mean that tribe-owned land that, under certain conditions, later became trust land couldn't eventually become casino-ready land.

I'm thinking that clever lawyers like my letter-writing friend helped the tribe weasel its way through that fine print. Just a guess, but I think so."

Get the Story:
Doug MacEachern: A beleaguered editorial writer takes umbrage at lawyer's note (The Arizona Republic 8/15)

Relevant Documents:
Larry Echo Hawk Letter to Tohono O'odham Nation (July 23, 2010)

Related Stories:
City plans suit on Tohono O'odham Nation off-reservation casino (8/9)
Editorial: Tohono O'odham Nation mocks voters with bid for casino (8/2)
BIA will acquire off-reservation parcel for Tohono O'odham Nation (7/26)
Hearing scheduled in Tohono O'odham Nation casino lawsuit (5/19)
Gila River Tribe asks to join Tohono O'odham casino lawsuit (5/17)
Bill targeting Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino dead (5/12)
Bill that targets Tohono O'odham Nation casino advances (4/13)
Bill against Tohono O'odham Nation casino back on agenda (4/8)
Poll backs Tohono O'odham Nation off-reservation casino (4/2)
Gila River Tribe slams Tohono O'odham off-reservation bid (4/1)
Tohono O'odham Nation hails end to anti-casino measure (3/30)
Lawmaker halts bill that targeted Tohono O'odham casino (3/29)
Editorial: Casino foes seek to steal Tohono O'odham land (3/24)
Tohono O'odham Nation sues over off-reservation casino (3/23)
Tohono O'odham Nation slams bill targeting casino bid (3/18)
Vote planned on bill targeting Tohono O'odham casino (3/16)
Tohono O'odham Nation loses ruling in gaming site case (3/12)
NCAI joins Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino fight (3/9)
Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bid still at BIA (3/8)
Bill affects Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bid (2/26)
Bill targets Tohono O'odham off-reservation casino bid (2/3)
Tohono O'odham Nation 'more committed' to casino (1/28)
Sen. Kyl voices opposition to Tohono O'odham casino (1/27)
McCain joins opposition to off-reservation casino bid (1/21)
Tohono O'odham Nation won't drop off-reservation bid (1/20)