Intelligence Report: Hate crimes in border town
"William Blackie's money ran out near midnight. His luck soon followed.

It was a Saturday night, last June 4, when Blackie, a 46-year-old Navajo, left the bar at the Anasazi Inn on foot, walking west along one of Farmington's main drags. He later told police he'd only made it as far as the parking lot of the American Furniture store, a few blocks from the inn, when three white youths in a white pickup, who later admitted they were trolling for a victim, pulled alongside. They offered to give him a ride if he'd buy them beer with their money.

Blackie agreed, and one of the men, C.L. Carnie, 20, got out of the cab and into the bed of the pickup, leaving Blackie to slide in next to passenger Freddie Brooks, also 20. In the driver's seat was 18-year-old John Winer, 6-foot, 5-inches, a ball cap pulled over his shaved head.

As the truck pulled away from the parking lot it headed the wrong direction, away from town.

Winer announced they weren't buying beer after all. Instead, he said, they were going to a "party" in a secluded area just north of town known as The Glades, a scrubby system of juniper- and sage-lined trails frequented by teenage partiers and mountain bikers.

Blackie sensed trouble. He asked Winer to pull over so he could relieve himself and Winer did, but no sooner had Blackie stepped out than he was clocked hard and fast in the head with a club. He fell to the ground and tried to crawl away as the men stomped and kicked his prone body, shouting, "Die nigger! Just die!"

When Blackie's pockets revealed only crumpled receipts and a bottle of medicine, Winer later told police they decided to "cut their losses," and left their victim bleeding in the desert. The taillights of the truck disappeared into the night.

Blackie didn't need a mirror to know he was in a bad way. He could smell the blood pouring from the gaping wound in his head, and taste it streaming past his lips. Blood coated his neck and arms and quickly saturated his T-shirt.

When he was sure the attackers had gone, Blackie dialed 911. He told the dispatcher he'd just been beat up by three white guys, didn't know where he was, and pleaded for help.

Police were able to track his location through his cell phone and arrived 10 minutes later. Their report characterized Blackie's demeanor upon their arrival as "traumatized, untrusting and intimidated." He repeatedly begged officers not to shoot him."

Get the Story:
Indian Blood (Southern Poverty Law Center Intelligence Report Winter 2007)

Relevant Links:
Navajo Nation -
Navajo Nation Council -

Related Stories:
Few Natives seek public office in border town (1/17)
Navajo woman runs for mayor of border town (1/12)
Hate crime suspects set for trial in Farmington (1/4)
Hate crime trial in border town scheduled for January (11/14)
Forum in Gallup addresses racism in border towns (11/02)
Farmington combats image as racist border town (10/30)
Navajo Nation Council hears report on racism (10/19)
Navajo council considers human rights bill (10/16)
Man accused of hate crime also charged with burglary (10/12)
Border town racism on Navajo Nation Council agenda (10/4)
Racial tensions fester in Navajo Nation border town (09/18)
Suspect pleads not guilty to beating of Navajo man (9/12)
Men face hate crimes charges for Navajo beating (9/7)
Hundreds attend memorial march in Farmington (9/5)
Editorial: March shows discrimination still exists (9/5)
Navajo Nation to march in Farmington on Saturday (8/31)
Chickasaw Nation business buys building for $7.8M (8/31)
Attack on Native officer considered a hate crime (08/23)
Judge denies treating Indians, non-Indians differently (08/11)
Permit requested for Navajo march in border town (8/8)
Navajo Nation to hold two marches in border town (8/3)
Farrakhan shocked by conditions on reservation (8/1)
Letter: No need to study racism in border towns (7/31)
Investigation sought into shooting of Navajo man (7/27)
DOJ won't investigate fatal shooting of Navajo man (7/26)
Farrakhan brings message of self-reliance to Navajos (7/21)
Controversial leader Farrakhan visits Navajo Nation (7/20)
Navajo Nation to march against border town racism (7/19)
Navajo Nation Council debates border town racism (7/18)
Indians with discrimination claims sent to sex chat (7/14)
Border town racism an issue again in Farmington (7/13)
Navajo Nation approves study of racism in border towns (7/7)
Racial tension in Farmington prompts meetings (6/29)
Farmington Mayor: City sensitive to Navajos (6/29)
Navajo leaders angered by incidents in Farmington (6/26)
George Joe: Battle lines drawn over Farmington (6/26)
Three suspects arrested for attack on Navajo man (6/19)
Navajo man attacked by white males in Farmington (06/13)
Paper examines Indian race relations, civil rights (03/24)
Paper examines Indian race relations, civil rights (3/23)
Paper examines Indian race relations, civil rights (3/22)
Editorial: Race relations improving in Farmington (03/02)
Navajo race relations subject of Civil Rights report (3/1)
Navajos turn out for civil rights commission hearing (05/03)
Civil rights panel to hold hearing in Farmington (4/29)
Racism still a sore subject 30 years after murders (4/27)
Navajos see bias in New Mexico city's justice system (4/26)
Navajo homeless men claim assault by white youth (4/23)
Navajos recall discrimination by local businesses (4/22)
1974 murders of Navajo men stir strong feelings (4/21)
This story is tagged under:
Share this Story!

You are enjoying stories from the Indianz.Com Archive, a collection dating back to 2000. Some outgoing links may no longer work due to age.

All stories in the Indianz.Com Archive are available for publishing via Creative Commons License: Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)