Last week President Barack Obama held his first town hall on Twitter. A really great idea and I plunged in with this question:
Indian Cntry's unemployment rate is unacceptable. Cutting govt jobs will make this situation far worse. What steps to fix this?” @TrahantReports
A Twitter town hall is a great idea. In theory. This first round revealed three huge problems.
First, the president didn’t play the game. Twitter requires focus, honing and shaping ideas into 140 characters. This is not an easy thing to do, but its very nature it changes the conversation. Twitter captures raw essence, not routine answers. The president stuck with routine answers.
Second, the town hall was impossible to participate in as a reader. The posts were flying by so fast that it was impossible to get any sense of the issues or the nation. It was better to read the threads later -- after the event. One way to fix that problem would be to create multiple hashtags -- or search cues -- that create mini-conversation threads. So #AskObama would be followed by #Ndnissues ... or something like that.
Third, and this one really troubles me, a town hall of this sort makes it even more impossible for a smaller demographic groups to participate. The Twitter universe for Native Americans is tiny -- not enough buzz to warrant attention. Again, in theory. But that needs to be fixed. Twitter (or any other social media) ought to be ideal for reaching constituent groups that are rarely heard from in general conversation. I love that this president has had tribal leaders’ forums, but I would also like to see Indian questions appear in a general forum such as the Twitter town hall.
I have a good example of that. Many remember my question to President Bush about tribal sovereignty
. But my second question, the one that’s not replayed on YouTube
, was about the payroll tax. Too many politicians politicians treat the payroll tax as if it doesn’t exist and it doesn’t contribute to the government. This is the federal tax that impacts Indian Country the most. In fact, it now generates 36 percent of the government’s revenues
, more than double that of corporate taxes. Yet when the discussion about taxes pops up ... it’s income or corporate taxes that must be cut; not the tax that matters to most of us.
The payroll tax is particularly difficult for people who are self-employed (disclosure: that’s me). We get to pay double. Most people only pay half, their employer pays the other half. But if you work for yourself, well, write a check. Or two.
I wanted to ask the president about government jobs because I don’t see how we avoid a second recession dive with so many layoffs ahead. Friday’s employment report
put this trend into perspective, saying: “Employment in government continued to trend down over the month (-39,000). Federal employment declined by 14,000 in June. Employment in both state government and local government continued to trend down over the month and has been falling since the second half of 2008.”
“Big” government has been getting smaller for nearly two years. And if Republican budget proposals are enacted, this trend will exacerbate. It is a fantasy to think that the private sector will replace these jobs any time soon. Unfortunately with more government reductions ahead that “minus 39,000 jobs” might look like the good old days.
I am a huge fan of Twitter. I’m there every day. But President Obama was right to answer town hall questions in long form rather than trying to tap out 140 character answers. This country’s problems are complicated. And too many -- read this The House Republicans -- favor simple, easy slogans, answers that might even fit on a line of Twitter. But every policy choice ahead has pluses and minuses. There is no easy way to fix for our debt, balance our demographic challenges
or anything else. What we need are thoughtful, messy, imperfect solutions that match the challenges of this particular era. Or as I might write on Twitter: Solving US money woes in 140 characters equals #fail.
Mark Trahant is a writer, speaker and Twitter poet. He is a member of the
Shoshone-Bannock Tribes and lives in Fort Hall, Idaho. Trahant’s new book, “The Last Great Battle of the
Indian Wars,” is the story of Sen. Henry Jackson and Forrest Gerard.
Related Stories:Mark Trahant: Tribes and counties better off
(6/27) Mark Trahant: It's
time for tribes and states to work together
(6/21) Mark Trahant: More than 10 million US jobs lost in
(6/14) Mark Trahant: Indian
Country stuck in permanent recession
(6/6) Mark Trahant: 2012 elections important for Indian
(5/23) Mark Trahant: Republicans
divided over Medicare reforms
(5/16) Mark Trahant: Tribes should prepare for the worst
(5/9) Mark Trahant: Debt
limit debate matters to Indian Country
(5/2) Mark Trahant: Rising gas prices hit Indian Country
(4/25) Mark Trahant: Some tall
tales about taxes in United States
(4/18) Mark Trahant: Bringing stories of abuse in Alaska
in the light
(4/12) Mark Trahant: GOP
proposal for Medicaid affects Indian Country
(4/4) Mark Trahant: Termination returns in the health
(3/28) Mark Trahant:
Investing in young people before we all go broke
(3/22) Mark Trahant: Tragedy in Japan puts Yucca Mountain
(3/14) Mark Trahant: Policy
will costs thousands of Indian Country jobs
(3/7) Mark Trahant: Tribes tested by budget cuts to
(2/28) Mark Trahant:
Tribes need a Plan B in case of federal shutdown
(2/22) Mark Trahant: Budget for Indian programs mostly a
(2/15) Mark Trahant: The
Indian Health Service and state budget shortage
(2/7) Mark Trahant: Protecting the budget for Indian
(1/31) Mark Trahant:
The sky doesn't have to fall on Indian health budget
(1/24)Mark Trahant: Real fight over health care reform
all about funding
(1/17) Mark Trahant:
Finding a way to a more civil discourse in America
(1/10) Mark Trahant: Indian health care a GOP target in
the new Congress
Join the Conversation