indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Dynamic Homes
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines
Print   Subscribe
Brian Pierson: Big decision in Seminole Tribe's taxation case

Filed Under: Business | Law
More on: 11th circuit, bia, brian pierson, florida, seminole, supreme court, taxation
     


Seminole Tribe Chairman Jim Billie and Interior Secretary Sally Jewell signed a HEARTH Act agreement in January 2015. Photo from Department of the Interior / Facebook

Attorney Brian Pierson discusses the significance of the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals decision in a taxation dispute between the Seminole Tribe and the state of Florida:
On August 26, 2015, the Eleventh Circuit handed down Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Stranburg, 2015 WL 5023891 (11th Cir. 2015), an important decision that, on balance, will be helpful to tribes seeking to prevent taxation of activities on leased land. An appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court would not be surprising.

In Stranburg, the Seminole Tribe of Florida had entered into 25-year leases in 2005, approved by the BIA, with two non-Indian corporations—Ark Hollywood, LLC, and Ark Tampa, LLC (Ark Entities)—to provide food-court operations at each of its casinos. The leases required the Ark Entities to pay “applicable” taxes. The state of Florida sought to impose (1) a commercial rent tax on the “privilege of engaging in the business of renting, leasing, letting, or granting a license for the use of any real property” in the state, assessed against the lessee and collected by the lessor, based on the total amount of rent paid and (2) a tax “on gross receipts from utility services that are delivered to a retail consumer” in Florida (Utility Tax), “imposed upon every person for the privilege of conducting a utility or communications services business, and each provider of the taxable services remains fully and completely liable for the tax, even if the tax is separately stated as a line item or component of the total bill.” Administrative regulations specified that even when stated on the consumer’s bill, the “tax is imposed on the privilege of doing business, and it is an item of cost to the distribution company,” who “remains fully and completely liable for the payment of the tax, even when the tax is wholly or partially separately itemized on the customer’s bill.”

The Tribe and the Ark Entities successfully challenged both taxes in the district court. On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit, citing the Supreme Court’s 1973 decision in Mescalero Apache v. Jones, held that the rental tax was barred by 25 U.S.C. § 465, which provides that land taken into trust under the Indian Reorganization Act “shall be exempt from State and local taxation”: “In our view, Mescalero stands for the proposition that § 465 precludes state taxation of that ‘bundle of privileges that make up property or ownership of property.’ … The ability to lease property is a fundamental privilege of property ownership. … By taxing the ‘privilege’ of ‘engaging in the business of renting, leasing, letting, or granting a license for the use of any real property,’ the State of Florida is taxing a privilege of ownership.” Importantly, the Court questioned Ninth Circuit decisions prohibiting taxation of Indian land or permanent improvements on Indian land but upholding a state’s right to impose a tax on non-Indians’ “possessory interests” in Indian land.

Get the Story:
Brian L. Pierson: Eleventh Circuit Decides Important Tax Case: Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Stranburg (The National Law Review 9/1)

11th Circuit Decision:
Seminole Tribe v. Stranburg (August 26, 2015)

Federal Register Notices:
HEARTH Act Approval of Seminole Tribe of Florida Regulations (August 12, 2015)
Residential, Business, and Wind and Solar Resource Leases on Indian Land (December 5, 2012)

Related Stories:
Seminole Tribe wins major ruling in taxation dispute in Florida (8/26)
Official in Oklahoma makes bizarre claim about HEARTH Act (08/07)
DOJ sides with Tulalip Tribes in taxation dispute in Washington (08/04)
Agua Caliente Band won't pursue certain taxation claims in lawsuit (06/15)
11th Circuit hears arguments in Seminole Tribe taxation case (05/13)
Supreme Court won't take up Seminole Tribe's taxation case (01/13)
Glen Stankee: Seminole Tribe wins ruling in state taxation case (09/23)
Seminole Tribe wins ruling over state taxation at gaming facilities (09/11)
Opinion: Decision signals shift on state taxation in Indian Country (09/10)


Copyright © Indianz.Com
More headlines...

Latest Headlines:

Tribes in for long haul as oil continues to flow through Dakota Access
Mark Trahant: Don't plan on getting sick if you're from Indian Country
Tiffany Midge: I shall joke as long as the grass grows and the rivers flow
Director of Office of Indian Energy deletes offensive Twitter account
States cheer decision on grizzly bears amid tribal concerns about hunts
Washington asks high court to overturn Yakama Nation treaty victory
New York Times editorial board reconsiders stance on racist trademarks
Colville Tribes remove council member a week before citizens go to polls
Marijuana firm promises big investments with help of ex-Seminole chair
Lumbee Tribe ordered to release voter list to opponents of chairman
National Indian Gaming Association chooses David Bean as vice chair
Eastern Cherokee citizen promoted to vice president of casino marketing
Tribes in Connecticut waiting on governor to sign bill for new casino
Secretary Zinke removes protections for grizzlies over tribal objections
Court sets final deadline for remaining payments from Cobell settlement
Mary Annette Pember: Indian Child Welfare Act strengthens our families
Peter d'Errico: Navajo authors offer fresh perspective on sovereignty
Native woman was jailed and forced to ride with assailant during trial
Ute Mountain Ute Tribe challenges new permit for uranium operation
Montana tribes get new member of Congress who pleaded to assault
Connecticut tribes welcome court decision favoring new casino law
Pueblo tribes dispute state's demand for $40M in gaming revenues
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe remains confident of approval of casino
Nooksack Tribe accepting slot tickets while casino remains closed
Key House committee under fire for moving slowly on tribal agenda
Tribes go it alone on climate change as Trump team shifts priorities
Bryan Newland: President Trump's budget threatens tribal treaties
Steve Russell: The GI Bill changed the United States for the better
Harold Monteau: Democrats lack proactive agenda, proactive strategy
St. Regis Mohawk Tribe orders 20 non-citizens to leave reservation
Wilton Rancheria accused of working too closely with city on casino
Witness list for hearing on bill to reform the Indian Health Service
Arne Vainio: What does the princess want to be when she grows up?
Doug George-Kanentiio: 'Spirit Game' brings Iroquois lacrosse to life
Cronkite News: Navajo activist vows fight against racist NFL mascot
Eric Hannel: Addressing the health care crisis among Native Americans
Bill for tribal regalia at graduation ceremonies advances in California
Ramapough Lunaape Nation wins reversal of ruling on prayer camp
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe still waits on casino ruling from Trump team
Another former leader of Winnebago Tribe pleads in gaming theft case
Supreme Court ruling poses hurdle for opponents of racist NFL mascot
Change the Mascot campaign responds to negative Supreme Court ruling
Secretary Zinke set for another hearing on Interior Department budget
Mark Trahant: Republicans write health reform bill behind closed doors
Jeff Grubbe: Agua Caliente Band focuses on protecting our groundwater
Steven Newcomb: Asserting our traditions in the era of Donald Trump
Shasta Dazen: 'Family Spirit' program incorporates our tribal traditions
Secretary Zinke shuffles top Indian Affairs officials at Interior Department
Choctaw Nation travels to Ireland to dedicate 'Kindred Spirits' sculpture
Nooksack Tribe closes doors to casino after being hit with federal order
Muscogee Nation asserts authority at allotment where casino was proposed
Mark Trahant: Dakota Access decision offers a chance to return to respect
Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe hails 'victory' in Dakota Access Pipeline case
Nooksack Tribe told to close casino amid leadership and citizenship feud
Kristi Noem: Enough is enough - It's time to fix the Indian Health Service
Second hearing scheduled on bill to reform the Indian Health Service
Trump nominee for appeals court seen as favorable to tribal interests
>>> more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.