Education | National | Technology

Sorry but DNA tests cannot confirm a person's Native ancestry






These vials were used as part of IAIA Blood Quantum Drive, an exhibition of works by students at the Institute of American Indian Arts in Santa Fe, New Mexico that addressed race and blood quantum issues in Indian Country. Photo from Facebook

DNA tests are great at demonstrating genetic relationships, even some that go back tens of thousands of years, but they can't confirm whether or not someone has Native ancestors, according to experts.

Professor Kim Tallbear, a member of the Sisseton-Wahpeton Oyate, offered a 47-tweet explanation of the issue on Tuesday after a failed Republican candidate claimed otherwise. Companies that offer genetic tests will never be able to pinpoint a person's specific or even general tribal heritage, she wrote.

"It’s unreasonable for scientists to conceive of tribe-specific markers," Tallbear wrote in one of her tweets. "'Tribes' mixed a lot, on their own & due to colonial policy."

But even if the companies refined their methods, a test still might not show whether someone has a Native ancestor, especially one in the distant past. The material that a person inherits from his or her parents boils down to a genetic lottery.

"It's all just by chance, what you inherit from your parents," Dr. Nanibaa' Garrison, a member of the Navajo Nation who studies genetics, told The Washington Post

Get the Story:
A DNA Test Won’t Explain Elizabeth Warren’s Ancestry (Slate 6/29)
Sorry, Scott Brown: A DNA test can’t tell us if Elizabeth Warren has Native American roots (The Washington Post 6/29)

Related Stories:
Trump rehashes 'Pocahontas' slur as Warren hits road for Clinton (6/28)
Northwest tribes seek reburial of ancestor known as Ancient One (06/08)
Study reveals some Native DNA in African American populations (06/01)
DNA studies boost links between Native people and ancestors (05/18)
Northwest tribes inch closer to reburial of Kennewick Man remains (04/28)
Cynthia-Lou Coleman: Media downplays tribal views on NAGPRA (02/15)
DNA from ancient infants linked to present-day Native populations (10/27)
Ruth Hopkins: Western science catches up to Native traditions (10/14)
Sen. Murray introduces bill to repatriate Kennewick Man to tribes (08/10)
Indigenous peoples in South America and Australia linked (07/21)
Washington governor supports repatriation of Kennewick Man (06/30)
Genetic analysis confirms Kennewick Man was Native American (06/18)
Genetic research confirms Alaska homeland for Inupiat people (05/04)
Tanya Lee: Don't let our racist history cloud genetics research (02/05)
The Atlantic: Native people wary of DNA tests and genetic studies (01/27)
Initial DNA tests show Kennewick Man linked to Native peoples (01/19)
DNA study finds distinct population of Native people in Arctic area (08/29)
Scientists publish lengthy book based on study of Kennewick Man (08/25)
WBUR: Tribes rebury one of their ancient relatives in Montana (07/23)
Remains of 12,600-year-old Native toddler reburied in Montana (06/30)
DNA of girl found in Mexico linked to present-day Native people (05/15)
DNA study shows link between ancient baby and Native people (02/14)
Research finds potential relative of Native Americans in Siberia (11/21)
Study links Native people in British Columbia to ancient remains (07/05)
Simon Moya-Smith: DNA research and the Bering Strait Theory (07/31)
Study reconfirms age of ancient remains and artifacts in Oregon (07/13)
DNA study points to at least three major groups of Indian people (07/12)
APRN: DNA study to explore connections among Alaska Natives (06/07)
Alaska Natives participating in DNA and cultural heritage study (06/06)
Study finds a link between Indian families and Jewish ancestor (05/30)
Nature: Puerto Ricans carrying DNA from their Taino ancestors (10/17)