indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Native American Bank - Native people investing in Native communities
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines
Print   Subscribe
Appeals court hears slew of Indian cases amid focus on Supreme Court nominee

Filed Under: Law | National | Politics
More on: 10th circuit, amanda proctor, chuck schumer, cpn, crime, democrats, donald trump, inmates, muscogee, neil gorsuch, oklahoma, osage, republicans, seminole, sovereignty, supreme court, taxation, ukb
     
   

The headquarters of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation in Shawnee, Oklahoma. Photo: CPN Public Information Office

Wednesday was just another busy day for Neil Gorsuch and the federal appeals court where he has served as a judge for a decade.

While Gorsuch was being questioned in the nation's capital about his qualifications for the U.S. Supreme Court, his colleagues back in Colorado were hearing not just one but three Indian law controversies. One of them in fact was a case he mentioned more than once during his lengthy confirmation proceeding.

In writing the unanimous decision in Fletcher v. U.S., Judge Gorsuch sided with citizens of the Osage Nation as they went up against a powerful adversary. He ruled that they are entitled to a historical accounting of their trust funds by their own trustee, better known as the federal government.

The government, not surprisingly, isn't entirely happy with the outcome. Although the Department of Justice did not appeal Gorsuch's ruling to the Supreme Court, taxpayer-funded attorneys have been trying to limit the accounting in a way that would severely undercut the landmark victory secured by the Osage plaintiffs.


A sign on the Osage Nation in Oklahoma. Photo: Jimmy Emerson

As Amanda Proctor, an Osage citizen who is serving as co-counsel in the case, put it: "The issue on appeal is whether the accounting of Osage mineral trust income starts yesterday or in 1906," with 1906 being the year the United States took it upon itself to manage the resource-rich lands of the Osage people in Oklahoma.

A limited accounting would mean less work for the government and it would deprive the Fletcher plaintiffs of the monetary worth of the accounting. A similar case filed by the Osage Nation led to a $380 million settlement during the Obama administration.

"Our history with Native Americans is not the prettiest history," Gorsuch told the Senate Committee on the Judiciary on Tuesday.

But the individual Osages aren't able to rely on Gorsuch's experience on the matter because he isn't handling any cases while his nomination to the high court is pending. A different panel of three judges -- Paul J. Kelly, Jr., David M. Ebel and Robert E. Bacharach -- heard the appeal in Denver on Wednesday morning.


Chief James Floyd of the Muscogee Nation with young tribal citizens. Photo: MCN

At the same time, another panel in Denver was taking up a second Indian law case. The appeal in Citizen Potawatomi Nation v. State of Oklahoma touches on taxation and tribal-state relations, two areas in which Gorsuch has demonstrated expertise, according to a review of his Indian law record.

The Citizen Potawatomi Nation secured a big victory last year when a federal judge confirmed an arbitration award that prevents Oklahoma from imposing sales taxes on the reservation. The dollar amounts at issue are staggering -- an estimated $27 million could flow to the tribe's treasury,

"The Nation has numerous enterprises that support the tribal government and citizenry," the tribe wrote in a brief to the 10th Circuit as part of the case, which was heard by Judges Timothy M. Tymkovich, Mary Beck Briscoe and Michael R. Murphy. "The Nation imposes its own sales tax on sales of goods and services by tribal businesses on tribal lands to support governmental services and infrastructure for the Nation."

The third Indian law case heard by the 10th Circuit on Wednesday was Murphy v. Royal. It too is based on issues familiar to Gorsuch -- the rights of Indian criminal defendants and reservation boundaries.


The Byron White Courthouse in Denver, Colorado, is home to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. Photo: Gregory Bloom

Patrick Dwayne Murphy, a citizen of the Muscogee Nation, was sentenced to death for murdering George Jacobs, another Muscogee citizen. But when he contested the state's jurisdiction -- the crime occurred in 1999 on an Indian allotment -- he claims he wasn't fully heard on the matter.

"Oklahoma usurped the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal courts by prosecuting a case without jurisdiction to do so," Murphy's attorneys wrote in a brief to the 10th Circuit.

The Muscogee Nation, the Seminole Nation and the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians also submitted briefs in the case. While they are not taking a position on Murphy's guilt or innocence, they say the state and federal courts must accept that the Muscogee Reservation was never diminished by Congress even though portions were allotted to individual citizens.

"The Creek Nation has never been terminated," the Creek and Seminole brief stated in a case that was heard by Judges Tymkovich, Scott M. Matheson, Jr. and Gregory A. Phillips.

In Ute Tribe v. Utah, Gorsuch arrived at a similar conclusion when he said the reservation of the Ute Tribe in Utah has not been diminished. In his testimony to the Judiciary committee, he noted that the tribe has spent "a long time trying to control their tribal lands" against repeated attempts by the state to assert jurisdiction there.

All three cases are expected to be decided by the 10th Circuit in the coming months, by which time Republicans hope Gorsuch will be sitting on the Supreme Court. They are planning to bring his nomination up for a vote in early April and he could begin participating in cases as soon as he is confirmed.

But Democrats, frustrated by what they see as an unfair process, are setting up roadblocks. Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-New York), the Democratic leader in the Senate, said Gorsuch will have to overcome a filibuster, meaning he will need at least 60 votes to join the nation's highest court.

"Judge Gorsuch's nomination will face a cloture vote & as I’ve said, he will have to earn sixty votes for confirmation. My vote will be 'No,'" Schumer wrote on Twitter on Thursday.

The Supreme Court has been operating with just eight members following the death of Antonin Scalia in February 2016. Republicans refused to consider Merrick Garland, who was Barack Obama's nominee, and insisted on waiting until the outcome of the November election. Republican President Donald Trump ended up winning and he nominated Gorsuch on January 31.

Related Stories:
High court pick acknowledges poor treatment of 'sovereign' tribes (3/22)
Supreme Court nominee fares well in review of Indian law record (3/20)
Trump administration given more time for appeal in tribal gaming case (03/17)
Trump administration backs Cowlitz Tribe in Supreme Court brief (03/07)
Supreme Court turns down another tribal disenrollment dispute (02/27)
Tribes find common ground with Donald Trump on Supreme Court nominee (02/17)
Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee well versed in Indian law (2/1)
Trump team gets more time on Supreme Court tribal casino case (1/31)
Trump ready to announce nominee for Supreme Court vacancy (1/30)
Supreme Court declines petition in Indian Child Welfare Act case (01/09)
Trump administration given more time for appeal in tribal gaming case (03/17)
Trump administration backs Cowlitz Tribe in Supreme Court brief (03/07)
Supreme Court turns down another tribal disenrollment dispute (02/27)
Tribes find common ground with Donald Trump on Supreme Court nominee (02/17)
Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee well versed in Indian law (2/1)
Trump team gets more time on Supreme Court tribal casino case (1/31)
Trump ready to announce nominee for Supreme Court vacancy (1/30)
Supreme Court declines petition in Indian Child Welfare Act case (01/09)
Tribal sovereignty foe Scott Pruitt slated to join Donald Trump's administration (12/07)
Citizen Potawatomi Nation faces challenge to taxation victory (07/20)

Copyright © Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Stay Connected:
On Facebook

On Twitter

On Google+

On SoundCloud
Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Ute Tribe demands 'voice' as Trump orders review of Bears Ears (4/28)
Senate panel takes up bill to bring AMBER Alert funding to tribes (4/28)
Gun Lake Tribe prepares for grand opening of casino expansion (4/28)
Arne Vainio: We lost a fluent Ojibwe speaker in Larry Smallwood (4/28)
Native Sun News Today: Runners from Standing Rock head to Ohio (4/28)
James Giago Davies: People tell me it's better to read about pets (4/28)
Harold Monteau: Supreme Court stirs smelly pot of fish head stew (4/28)
Steven Newcomb: 'Picking Fights' book is a must-read for Natives (4/28)
Whiteclay liquor stores must close temporarily amid court battle (4/28)
Disputed leaders of Nooksack Tribe hit by Supreme Court decision (4/27)
Indigenous activists make presence known for climate march in DC (4/27)
Interior Department announces $5.7M in tribal preservation grants (4/27)
Mark Trahant: Senate candidate cites Standing Rock as 'awakening' (4/27)
Native Sun News Today: Battle over Whiteclay liquor just beginning (4/27)
Ivan Star Comes Out: Why are we still dealing with racism today? (4/27)
Albert Bender: Navajo family still waiting on justice for loved one (4/27)
Whiteclay liquor stores win surprise court ruling on liquor licenses (4/27)
Dakota Access firm faces fines for two spills of drilling fluid in Ohio (4/27)
Gathering of Nations gets ready for annual powwow in new venue (4/27)
Secretary Zinke lacks leadership team more than a month into job (4/27)
Republicans seek to avoid shutdown with temporary spending bill (4/27)
Supreme Court ruling seen as benefit to casino bus crash lawsuit (4/27)
Mashantucket Tribe charges off-duty officer for assault at casino (4/27)
Trump singles out Bears Ears as an 'abuse' of government's power (4/26)
Doug George-Kanentiio: Let's call Columbus by what he truly was (4/26)
Native Sun News Today: Lakota youth set up beekeeping business (4/26)
Cronkite News: Trump seeks to hire thousands of border officers (4/26)
Doug Pibel: New film teaches us about value of indigenous seeds (4/26)
Jenn Weddle: 'Best possible result' from court in sovereignty case (4/26)
Peter d'Errico: Oneida architect offers indigenous approach to law (4/26)
Whiteclay liquor stores aim to stay open pending fight for licenses (4/26)
Support for Standing Rock Sioux Tribe leads to recall in Alaska city (4/26)
Mishewal Wappo Tribe loses appeal in federal recognition lawsuit (4/26)
Police use tear gas & rubber bullets at indigenous protest in Brazil (4/26)
Mohegan Tribe wants gaming disputes resolved in judicial system (4/26)
Supreme Court hands defeat to tribal interests in sovereignty case (4/25)
Matthew Fletcher: 'Gamesmanship' brings defeat in Supreme Court (4/25)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.