indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Fredericks Peebles & Morgan LLP
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines
Print   Subscribe
Internal tribal disputes continue to trip up federal court system

Filed Under: Law | National | Politics
More on: 9th circuit, auburn, banishment, california, disenrollment, icra, nooksack, per caps, sovereignty, supreme court, washington
     
   

The United Auburn Indian Community owns and operates the Thunder Valley Casino Resort in Lincoln, California. Photo: FolsomNatural

Tribal citizens who have been punished by their governments are finding few allies in the federal court system but that isn't stopping them from seeking justice.

Federal judges have repeatedly expressed reluctance to get involved in internal tribal disputes, whether it's about elections or enrollment. Tribes, after all, are "sovereign nations" -- as U.S. Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch said this week -- and should be able to handle their own affairs.

But while activists and advocates have made inroads in getting the public, the media and even the executive branch to pay more attention to civil rights abuses in Indian Country, a recent decision from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals confirms that tribes have little to fear when it comes to their sovereignty.

The case arose out of a dispute within the United Auburn Indian Community. In 2011, the California-based tribe punished four women -- including a former chair and a former council member -- for criticizing the way their leaders were handling matters on the reservation.

"When the tribe’s credibility with other governments and businesses, as well as its lenders, employees and partners, is damaged so publicly, it requires swift action," the tribal council said in a statement at the time.


Indianz.Com SoundCloud: Jessica Tavares v. Gene Whitehouse

As punishment for speaking out, Jessica Tavares, Dolly Suehead, Donna Caesar, and Barbara Suehead were ordered to stay off tribal property and had their lucrative per capita payments suspended for a period of time. Tavares, the former chairwoman, was hit the hardest -- her exclusion order lasts for 10 years and her per cap was suspended longer than any of the others.

But while a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit acknowledged that the punishment imposed on Tavares was "severe," the majority on the court said it lacked jurisdiction to review the tribe's banishment order. The tribe never detained her so she can't invoke a provision in the Indian Civil Rights Act that would bring the dispute into the federal system, they concluded.

"A temporary exclusion is not tantamount to a detention," Judge M. Margaret McKeown, who was nominated to the bench by Bill Clinton, wrote for the majority. Congress, she said, was mindful of tribal sovereignty when it limited the circumstances in which a tribe could be held accountable for civil rights abuses under ICRA, which first became law in 1968.

As for the per caps, all three judges on the panel agreed that the suspension of the payments didn't meet the definition of "detention" either. Tavares lost her share of the tribe's gaming revenues for 3.5 years, costing her an estimated $2 million, while her colleagues went without their payments for five months.

The "loss of quarterly distributions paid to all tribal members is 'insufficient to bring plaintiffs within ICRA’s habeas provision,'" McKeown wrote, quoting from another case in which a tribe punished its critics by suspending their monetary payments.


Gene Whitehouse currently serves as the chairman of the United Auburn Indian Community. Photo: Chapa-De Indian Health Auburn

But a third member of the panel departed when it came to the 10-year exclusion of Tavares. Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw, another Clinton nominee, noted that ICRA is supposed to protect the rights of tribal citizens who engage in "free expression" on their lands.

"Tavares presents us with precisely the kind of case over which Congress intended to establish federal jurisdiction: having exercised her right to free expression which Congress, through the ICRA, had explicitly guaranteed her, Tavares suffered retaliation from the UAIC in the form of 'severe restraints on individual liberty' not shared by other members of her tribe," Wardlaw wrote in her dissent.

Despite the disagreement, there's no indication that the 9th Circuit is shifting its thinking when it comes to tribal sovereignty or, more specifically, disenrollment matters. In case after case, the judges on the court have stood by precedents that require them to stay out of those kinds of disputes. Twice so far this year, the Supreme Court has refused to hear disenrollment cases from California, which is home to more than 100 tribes.

"In many cases, a tribe’s decision to temporarily exclude a member will be another expression of its sovereign authority to determine the makeup of the community," Judge McKeown observed in the decision.

The tide, though, may be turning in response to a new case from Washington, which also falls in the 9th Circuit. There, the Nooksack Tribe is suing the federal government for withholding an estimated $14 million in federal funds amid an internal dispute.

"Federal interference over matters of internal tribal concern is generally prohibited," the tribe's attorneys wrote in a March 16 request for a preliminary injunction against the new Trump administration.

Government attorneys have yet to respond to the motion or to the tribe's complaint, which was filed in February. But they aren't hiding from the fact that the dispute is tied to the ouster of more than 300 people from the Nooksack rolls.

In a notice submitted on Tuesday, they pointed out that the tribe is already being sued for allegedly punishing five people on the reservation by denying them "money and property." And 271 people who were disenrolled the tribe are trying to join the new lawsuit. A judge has scheduled two upcoming hearings, including one on Friday, to start sorting out the mess.

9th Circuit Court of Appeals Decision:
Tavares v. Whitehouse (March 14, 2017)

Related Stories:
Harold Monteau: Tribal governments are abusing their own people (03/23)
High court pick acknowledges poor treatment of 'sovereign' tribes (3/22)
Supreme Court turns down another tribal disenrollment dispute (02/27)
Gabe Galanda: The Obama administration's disenrollment legacy (01/25)
Disenrollment epidemic affects dozens of tribes across the nation (01/18)
Leader of Nooksack Tribe defends purge of 'non-Indians' from rolls (11/23)
Indian Health Service warns Nooksack Tribe about disenrollees (11/22)
Bureau of Indian Affairs rebuffs Nooksack Tribe on disenrollment (11/17)
Gabe Galanda: Every tribe should be troubled by disenrollments (11/17)
Nooksack Tribe moves to disenroll 306 after holding referendum (11/10)
Nooksack Tribe moves to disenroll 306 after holding referendum (11/10)
Cedric Sunray: Cherokee Nation tries to 'Trump' federal Indian Arts and Crafts Act (10/24)
Saginaw Chippewa Tribe removes members amid per cap issues (10/20)
Bureau of Indian Affairs questions Nooksack Tribe's government (10/18)
Nooksack Tribe creates new court and puts chairman in charge (10/14)
Descendants of treaty signer back on rolls of Grand Ronde Tribes (10/06)
Grand Ronde Tribes yet to add descendants of chief back to roll (09/20)
St. Croix Chippewa Tribe ordered to reinstate five ousted members (08/17)

Copyright © Indianz.Com
More headlines...

Latest Headlines:

President Trump promises 'freedom' for tribes seeking to exploit resources
Officials in North Dakota claim ignorance on Dakota Access security firm
Trump administration gives up in NFL team's racist trademark dispute
Onondaga Nation protests lack of input in decisions at public school
Appeals court ruling opens door for tribal jurisdiction over public schools
Cronkite News: Navajo Nation prepares for changes at coal power plant
Steven Newcomb: Federal Indian law comes from a White man's mind
Dakota Access security firm was denied license but kept working anyway
Lawsuits expected after President Trump changes Bears Ears boundary
Voters of Blackfeet Nation reject changes to decades-old constitution
Oneida Nation challenges Oneida Nation over use of 'Oneida' trademarks
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe shifts course on casino land-into-trust bid
Saginaw Chippewa Tribe announces hotel as part of casino expansion
Tribes celebrate as governor in Connecticut signs new casino bill into law
Kickapoo Tribe casino bus crash lawsuits on hold amid insurance dispute
Family from Crow Tribe wins right to pursue lawsuit against federal agent
Mark Trahant: Republican health care reform bill impacts Indian Country
Steve Russell: Republican answer to Obamacare only benefits the wealthy
Hualapai Tribe learns more about citizen who was killed on duty in Vietnam
Zia Pueblo wants symbol removed from flag of city in far-away Wisconsin
Northern Cheyenne Tribe won't touch coal deposit despite economic woes
Life-saving road for Native village inches forward in Alaska and in D.C.
Two more Pueblo tribes challenge state's demand for gaming revenue
Wilton Rancheria won't comment on status of gaming compact talks
Trump administration rolls out first rule under historic trust reform law
Interior Department sends out another $13.1M in Cobell buy-back offers
Senate Committee on Indian Affairs headed to New Mexico for hearing
House committee again leaves out Indian Country in hearing on Interior
Mark Maxey: Oklahoma tries to crush Native protesters with new law
Carletta Tilousi: Havasupai Tribe threatened by uranium development
Opinion: Don't be fooled by Jimmie Durham's claims of Cherokee heritage
Opinion: Economic development for Indian Country in upcoming farm bill
Government worker suspended after calling Native principal a 'rabid s----'
Kiowa citizen Tristan Ahtone to report on tribes for High Country News
New York Times features Dina Gilio-Whitaker in editorial on health care
Tribes break ground on monument to their history in Virginia's capitol
Warm Springs Tribes battle large wildfire that broke out behind casino
Spokane Tribe casino doesn't bother Air Force despite claims in lawsuit
Tribes in for long haul as oil continues to flow through Dakota Access
Mark Trahant: Don't plan on getting sick if you're from Indian Country
Tiffany Midge: I shall joke as long as the grass grows and the rivers flow
Director of Office of Indian Energy deletes offensive Twitter account
States cheer decision on grizzly bears amid tribal concerns about hunts
Washington asks high court to overturn Yakama Nation treaty victory
New York Times editorial board reconsiders stance on racist trademarks
Colville Tribes remove council member a week before citizens go to polls
Marijuana firm promises big investments with help of ex-Seminole chair
Lumbee Tribe ordered to release voter list to opponents of chairman
National Indian Gaming Association chooses David Bean as vice chair
Eastern Cherokee citizen promoted to vice president of casino marketing
Tribes in Connecticut waiting on governor to sign bill for new casino
Secretary Zinke removes protections for grizzlies over tribal objections
Court sets final deadline for remaining payments from Cobell settlement
Mary Annette Pember: Indian Child Welfare Act strengthens our families
Peter d'Errico: Navajo authors offer fresh perspective on sovereignty
Native woman was jailed and forced to ride with assailant during trial
Ute Mountain Ute Tribe challenges new permit for uranium operation
Montana tribes get new member of Congress who pleaded to assault
Connecticut tribes welcome court decision favoring new casino law
Pueblo tribes dispute state's demand for $40M in gaming revenues
>>> more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.