indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
The Rise of Tribes and the Fall of Federal Indian Law
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Appeals court dismisses land claim in favor of state
Wednesday, June 29, 2005

A divided federal appeals court dismissed the 64,000 acre Cayuga land claim on Tuesday, ruling that the U.S. Supreme Court has "dramatically altered the legal landscape" of Indian land claims.

Two judges of the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals said the Cayuga Nation of New York and the Seneca-Cayuga Tribe of Oklahoma waited too long to reclaim their original reservation. After 25 years of litigation, they tossed the entire lawsuit, nullified $248 million award to the tribes, and entered a judgment for the state of New York.

The dramatic conclusion was based on an expansive interpretation of the U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision in the Sherrill v. Oneida Nation case. Judge Jose Cabranes and Judge Rosemary Pooler said the high court, for the first time, ruled that Indian land claims can be dismissed if they are too "disruptive" to non-Indian communities.

"Under the Sherrill formulation, this type of possessory land claim -- seeking possession of a large swath of central New York State and the ejectment of tens of thousands of landowners -- is indisputably disruptive," Cabranes wrote for the majority.

Therefore, non-Indians can raise defenses that would not otherwise be allowed in tribal land claims cases, the majority reasoned. In the case of New York, the state argued that the tribes waited too long to seek possession and monetary damages for 64,000 acres that were stolen a series of treaties that were never ratified by the federal government, as required by federal law.

Even thought the court said it was "undisputed" that the transactions were illegal, the judges refused to remedy the wrong due to lengthy delay in the filing of the claim. They cited language in the Sherrill case that referred to impact such a delay has on the "justifiable expectations" of non-Indian communities.

The judges also said the nature of the initial complaint -- to claim possession of the 64,000 acres and eviction of current landowners -- presented far too much of a burden on non-Indians. Even though a lower court ruled that ejectment is not an option and that a $248 million judgment rather than land was a proper remedy, Cabranes concluded the tribes should be penalized for the way they framed the case 25 years ago.

"The nature of the claim as a 'possessory claim,' as characterized by the district court, underscores our decision to treat this claim like the tribal sovereignty claims in Sherrill," the majority stated.

The decision prompted a lengthy dispute from Judge Janet Hall. Although she agreed that the Sherrill has changed the legal landscape, she said "it does not reach as far as the majority reads it."

She said Sherrill certainly bars the tribes from being awarded the land at issue. But she said the claim at issue in that case -- whether the Oneida Nation can revive its sovereignty over ancestral territories -- is not present in the Cayuga case.

"Nothing in City of Sherrill suggests a total bar on the ability of Indian tribes to obtain damages for past wrongs where Congress has explicitly provided for it," Hull wrote.

Hull said the majority overstated the effects of the Sherrill case. The Supreme Court limits tribes to the type of legal "relief" they seek in land claims cases but not the remedies --- such as monetary damages -- available to them, the judge noted.

She also said the majority failed to justify its decision to treat the United States in the same manner as the tribes. The federal government intervened in the case as a trustee for the tribes and cannot be subject to the "laches," or length of time, defense raised by the state, Hull argued.

The 2nd Circuit ruling is the latest fallout from the Sherrill decision of March 29. Local governments have hit the Oneida Nation with millions of dollars in bills for failing to pay property taxes for land within its ancestral territory.

The Supreme Court, in the 8-1 decision, said it was careful not to disturb its previous holding that the Oneida Nation has a right to seek redress for the theft of 250,000 acres. But local officials have used the decision to seek authority over tribe, as well as the Cayuga Nation and the Seneca-Cayuga Tribe.

The Sherrill decision also effectively killed land claim settlements for four tribes, including the two Cayuga tribes and two tribes from Wisconsin. Gov. George Pataki (R) had reached deals to allow the tribes to open casinos in the Catskills in exchange for dropping their lawsuits.

Pataki has since submitted a bill to settle the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe's claim for a casino. But he said the 2nd Circuit ruling will definitely play a role in future deals.

"Today's decision is a tremendous victory for property owners and taxpayers in central New York," he said in a statement. "We will continue to take whatever steps are necessary to protect New Yorkers - from Grand Island to Long Island - as we move forward to resolve any remaining land claims within the state."

Get the Decision:
Cayuga Nation v. New York (June 28, 2005)

Sherrill v. Oneida Nation Decision:
Syllabus | Opinion [Ginsburg] | Concurrence [Souter] | Dissent [Stevens]

Related Stories:
County opposes Cayuga Nation on land-into-trust (05/25)
Cayuga Nation, county reach deal on inspections (05/12)
Column: Tribes just can't come and take 'our' land (05/11)
Cayuga Nation land case back before federal judge (05/05)
County gets order to inspect tribe's gas station (04/29)
Supreme Court ruling impacts New York land claims (4/19)
Cayuga Nation seeks BIA protection for lands (4/15)
Pataki, county blast Oneida Nation's trust land bid (4/14)
County to challenge Cayuga Nation sovereignty (4/14)
Oneida Nation seeks trust land in wake of ruling (4/14)
Cayuga tribes confident on land claim appeal (4/12)
Supreme Court decision derails Pataki settlements (4/11)
Seneca-Cayuga Tribe to pay taxes on acquired land (4/8)
Supreme Court called less sympathetic to Indians (4/7)
Fallout from Supreme Court ruling on Oneida Nation (4/6)
BIA official calls high court ruling 'quite depressing' (03/31)
Major defeat for Oneida Nation in Supreme Court case (3/30)
Cayuga Nation land rights upheld by federal judge (4/26)
Cayuga Nation's plans for land worry some in village (04/07)
Cayuga Nation's plans for land worry some in village (04/07)
Report: Seneca-Cayuga Tribe has bigger plans in store (04/06)
Tribes ask court for $1.7B and title to lost land (04/01)
Federal appeals court to hear Cayuga land claim (3/31)
NIGC accused of 'ducking' casino land issue in N.Y. (03/23)
Seneca-Cayuga Tribe seeks deal to end land claim (03/19)
Judge in N.Y. hears Seneca-Cayuga land dispute (03/12)
Seneca-Cayuga Tribe could fund arts center in N.Y. (2/26)
Arguments set for appeal of Cayuga land claim (2/25)
Seneca-Cayuga Tribe makes offer to Pataki (11/19)
Court orders Cayuga Nation to stop renovations (10/23)
Cayuga Nation proposes land claim, tax settlement (10/21)
Cayuga Nation buys another gas station (10/06)
Bill would terminate out-of-state sovereign rights (09/26)
Appeals expected in Seneca-Cayuga Tribe's land case (09/10)
Judge to decide fate of Seneca-Cayuga Tribe's land (9/9)
Cayuga tribes slowly reclaiming ancestral territory (09/02)
Okla. tribe says court decision bolsters case (07/24)
Cayuga Nation welcomes Indian Country decision (07/23)
Oneida Nation wins treaty lands case (7/22)

Copyright 2000-2005 Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Stay Connected:
On Facebook

On Twitter

On Google+

On SoundCloud
Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Lakota Country Times: Indian lawmakers oppose drug testing bill (2/10)
Vince Two Eagles: The rez of the story about treaty-making in US (2/10)
Chase Iron Eyes: Real sovereigns don't disenroll their own people (2/10)
Albert Bender: Tribes should reclaim land from unratified treaties (2/10)
John Lavelle: Supreme Court weighs key tribal sovereignty issue (2/10)
Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders win big in New Hampshire vote (2/10)
Prairie Island Indian Community unveils $19M gaming expansion (2/10)
Seminole Tribe's gaming compact takes a step forward in Florida (2/10)
Schaghticoke Tribal Nation insists on pursuing Connecticut casino (2/10)
National campaign launched to stop tribal disenrollment epidemic (2/9)
President Obama seeks $2.9B budget for Bureau of Indian Affairs (2/9)
Office of Special Trustee budget request remains steady at $140M (2/9)
Bureau of Reclamation emphasizes tribal water rights settlements (2/9)
Lakota Country Times: Indian health at center of Medicaid debate (2/9)
Mark Trahant: Native candidates fall behind in the big money wars (2/9)
Vi Waln: Arrogance keeps Keystone XL plans alive in South Dakota (2/9)
Charles Kader: Haudenosaunee territory will always be Indian land (2/9)
Mike Myers: Indigenous teachings still guide our ways of life today (2/9)
Albuquerque Indian Center faces closure without additional money (2/9)
Leader of Bois Forte Band promises fight against substance abuse (2/9)
Coushatta Tribe wins ruling in long-running dispute with contractor (2/9)
Pamunkey Tribe looks to a stronger future with federal recognition (2/9)
Isle de Jean Charles Band to relocate with help of $48M HUD grant (2/9)
Nambe Pueblo hopes small casino stands out in a crowded market (2/9)
St. Regis Mohawk Tribe sends fewer gaming funds to communities (2/9)
Tribes in Connecticut still working on process for potential casino (2/9)
Girls basketball team proudly wears Navajo hairstyle during game (2/8)
National Indian Gaming Commission slated to get a third member (2/8)
Senate committee to host roundtable on Tribal Law and Order Act (2/8)
Senate Indian Affairs Committee postpones field hearing into EPA (2/8)
Senate designates National Tribal Colleges and Universities Week (2/8)
Bill John Baker: Cherokee Nation invests in our people's wellbeing (2/8)
Kevin Washburn: Republicans punish tribe in public lands measure (2/8)
Harold Monteau: Democrats stack the deck for only one candidate (2/8)
Cutcha Risling Baldy: Don't let Leonard Peltier die in prison system (2/8)
Robert Jumper: Keep Eastern Cherokee council meetings on record (2/8)
Brian Pierson: Menominee Nation loses decision at Supreme Court (2/8)
Probe continues into unsolved homicide of 11-year-old Native girl (2/8)
Burns Paiute Tribe might seek to reopen judgment for stolen lands (2/8)
Shinnecock Nation approves plans to join medical marijuana field (2/8)
Teams protest corporate sponsor of Native basketball tournament (2/8)
Rosebud Sioux Tribe faces obstacles with repatriation of students (2/8)
Wallace Coffey resigns as chair of Comanche Nation after 25 years (2/8)
Broker accused of lying to tribal client about $190M in investments (2/8)
Seminole Tribe showcases long-lost declaration of independence (2/8)
Pope Francis to celebrate mass at Indian church for trip to Mexico (2/8)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.