indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+
ph: 202 630 8439   fax: 202 318 2182
Dynamic Homes
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Supreme Court takes action on tribal car tag case
Monday, December 12, 2005

The U.S. Supreme Court delivered some potentially bad news to the Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation on Monday, a week after ruling against the Kansas tribe in a fuel tax case.

In an order, the justices granted a petition filed by the state of Kansas to overturn a 10th Circuit Court of Appeals decision that upheld the tribe's right to issue motor vehicle tags. But rather than hear the dispute, the high court vacated the favorable ruling and remanded the case for further review.

The move -- called a "GVR" for grant, vacate and remand -- means the lower courts will have to reconsider the case in light of last week's decision in the tax case. On December 6, the justices ruled that the state of Kansas could impose a tax on fuel sold to the Prairie Band.

The decision was a blow to the tribe, whose gasoline station buys fuel from a non-Indian distributor based off the reservation but sells it to customers on the reservation. The high court, by a vote of 7-2, ruled that the tax was legal because it didn't implicate tribal sovereignty.

Despite the negative outcome, the justices bypassed a critical question that had been raised in the fuel case and remains unanswered in the car tag case. At issue is a balancing test between competing tribal, state and federal interests.

Justice Clarence Thomas, who wrote the majority opinion, said the balancing test didn't come into play in the fuel case. "It does not apply where, as here, a state tax is imposed on a non-Indian and arises as a result of a transaction that occurs off the reservation," he said.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg saw it differently. In a dissent joined by Justice Anthony Kennedy, she said tribal and federal interests in promoting tribal economies outweigh the state's interest in imposing the tax, even if it occurs off the reservation.

"The Nation's interests coincide with 'strong federal interests in promoting tribal economic development, tribal self-sufficiency, and strong tribal governments,'" she wrote, citing a related decision.

The Prairie Band hopes to capitalize on that view when the case is returned to the lower courts. The tribe argues that it has an inherent right to issue motor vehicle registrations and car tags.

"We are confident that under either the balancing test or discrimination standard, the 10th Circuit will reaffirm its decision that the state of Kansas is illegally prohibiting the use of the Nation's vehicle registrations," Zach Pahmahmie, the chairman of the tribal council, said yesterday.

The discrimination standard comes into play because the state of Kansas has recognized car tags issued by tribes in Oklahoma as well as those issued by other states. But the state says it doesn't have to recognize the Prairie Band tags off the reservation, raising public safety and sovereignty defenses.

This past March, a three-judge panel of the 10th Circuit had rejected the state's arguments. Writing for the majority, Judge Monroe G. McKay said "it is accepted that tribally titled and registered vehicles will have to leave the reservation and travel on Kansas highways."

He added: "Kansas' sovereignty and public safety interests do not automatically trump the tribe's interest in self-governance."

But now that the ruling has been vacated, whether the lower courts will reach a similar conclusion is not known. The Supreme Court had been holding on to the state's petition in the car tag case since September, and the justice waited until they made a decision in the fuel tax case before acting on it.

The last time the Supreme Court made a "GVR" in a significant Indian law case was in 1996, when the state of South Dakota challenged the constitutionality of the land-into-trust process under the Indian Reorganization Act. At least three federal circuits have since upheld the legality of the IRA.

Relevant Documents:
Supreme Court Order List (December 12, 2005)

Car Tag Decision:
Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation v. Kansas (March 25, 2005)

Fuel Tax Decision:
Syllabus | Opinion [Thomas] | Dissent [Ginsburg]

Relevant Links:
Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation - http://www.pbpindiantribe.com
NARF-NCAI Tribal Supreme Court Project - http://www.narf.org/sct/index.html

Related Stories:
Tribes not worried about Supreme Court ruling (12/9)
Indian law cases await U.S. Supreme Court action (12/8)
Supreme Court upholds state tax on reservation fuel (12/7)
Washington to use gas tax decision against tribes (12/7)
Supreme Court relists Prairie Band car tag case (12/7)
State asks Supreme Court to review car tag case (07/06)
O'Connor resigns from nation's highest court (7/5)
Justice's tenure filled with key Indian law cases (7/5)
Supreme Court wraps up October 2004 term (06/28)
U.S. Supreme Court vacancy impacts tribal rights (06/20)
14 states file brief in Supreme Court tribal tax case (05/13)
Appeals court sides with tribe in car tag dispute (03/28)
Supreme Court takes on tribal-state tax dispute (03/01)
Court sides with tribe in law enforcement dispute (11/12)
Court bars state from imposing gas tax on tribe (08/13)
Judge blocks state from interfering with tribe (8/3)
Kan. tribe wins round in car tag dispute (6/26)

Copyright 2000-2005 Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Stay Connected:
Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Tim Giago: An independent candidate awakens 'Party' zombies (9/22)
Mark Trahant: Huge crowd turns out for People's Climate March (9/22)
Doug George-Kanentiio: All children are gifts from the Creator (9/22)
Native Sun News: Native women take stand against violence (9/22)
Clara Caufield: Northern Cheyenne Tribe heads into election (9/22)
Navajo Nation to announce trust fund settlement this Friday (9/22)
S.E. Ruckman: A remarkable day with arrival of Cobell checks (9/22)
Jon Tester: Bill protects Special Diabetes Program for Indians (9/22)
Ron Allen: Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe keeps workers engaged (9/22)
Dante Desiderio: Working together to address tribal tax issue (9/22)
Vena A-dae Romero: Asserting sovereignty through our food (9/22)
Mark Rogers: Leadership in Native America is at a crossroads (9/22)
Dave Lundgren: BIA must take a closer look at rights-of-way (9/22)
Peter d'Errico: Video uses humor to battle racist NFL mascot (9/22)
Opinion: Racist sports mascots preserve 'imaginary' Indians (9/22)
Justice Sotomayor studied Indian law after joining top court (9/22)
House subcommittee holds hearing on bill for Hualapai Tribe (9/22)
Colville Tribes participate in repatriation ceremony in Canada (9/22)
Shinnecock Nation tightens regulation of tobacco businesses (9/22)
Forest County Potawatomi Tribe won't share casino revenue (9/22)
Coeur d'Alene Tribe can't offer poker games pending appeal (9/22)
Lytton Band might purchase property next to gaming facility (9/22)
Nottawaseppi Huron Band reopens casino after electrical fire (9/22)
Guilty verdict in robbery of Saginaw Chippewa casino winner (9/22)
Editorial: Poarch Creek gaming deal deserves consideration (9/22)
Native Sun News: Tribes united against Keystone XL Pipeline (9/19)
Regina Brave: The earth that once was will soon be no more (9/19)
Chelsey Luger and Gyasi Ross: A conversation about suicide (9/19)
Cobell settlement checks being cashed across Indian Country (9/19)
Congress passes measure for tribal general welfare programs (9/19)
Native Sun News: US Senate candidates debate Native issues (9/18)
Cobell settlement checks landing in Indian Country mailboxes (9/18)
Sen. Walsh welcomes arrival of last Cobell settlement payout (9/18)
Rep. Daines praises House action on tribal general welfare bill (9/18)
Winnebago attorney joins BIA as a deputy assistant secretary (9/18)
NWIFC schedules briefing on 'Treaty Rights 101' on Capitol Hill (9/18)
Norbert Hill: It's past time to drop the Washington NFL mascot (9/18)
Peter d'Errico: Connecting mascots to racism and termination (9/18)
Opinion: Eliminating NFL team's racist mascot is just the start (9/18)
Student newspaper punished over refusal to print the R-word (9/18)
Officer investigated for 'drunk uneducated animals' comment (9/18)
9th Circuit rules against Chemehuevi Tribe in land deed case (9/18)
Mashable: Oglala Sioux man still pushing MazaCoin currency (9/18)
City won't allow vote on Tohono O'odham Nation casino plan (9/18)
9th Circuit poses tough questions in Big Lagoon casino case (9/18)
North Fork Rancheria banks on voter approval of casino deal (9/18)
KBIC judge dismisses lawsuit challenging plan for new casino (9/18)
Oneida Nation concerned about location of commercial casino (9/18)
Mashantucket Tribe's gaming executive to resign next month (9/18)
Column: Time for Mohegan Tribe to show its hand over casino (9/18)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.