indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+
ph: 202 630 8439   fax: 202 318 2182
Fredericks Peebles & Morgan LLP
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Tribes take labor law battle to federal court
Tuesday, April 25, 2006

An extraordinary number of tribes and tribal organizations are participating in a precedent-setting labor law case that will affect tribes nationwide.

Last week, the National Congress of American Indians, the National Indian Gaming Association and nearly a dozen tribes submitted a brief in support of the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians. The San Manuel Band, owners of a successful casino, is engaged in a high-profile sovereignty dispute with the National Labor Relations Board.

Tribal governments are not mentioned anywhere in federal labor law. But the NLRB, in ruling that overturned 30 years of precedent, concluded that tribes must comply with the National Labor Relations Act when their businesses affect non-Indians.

"As tribal businesses prosper, they become significant employers of non-Indians and serious competitors with non-Indian owned businesses," the board wrote in a 3-1 decision in May 2004. "When Indian tribes participate in the national economy in commercial enterprises, when they employ substantial numbers of non-Indians, and when their businesses cater to non-Indian clients and customers, the tribes affect interstate commerce in a significant way."

The ruling sparked an outcry among tribes and prompted a showdown in Congress among lawmakers who are normally united on tribal issues. On two separate occasions, Democrats, who count labor unions as strong allies, were able to beat back Republican proposals that would have held back the effects of the decision.

With the political battle now lost, tribes are focusing their energies on the court level. The 48-page brief, a final version submitted to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals last Wednesday, criticized the NLRB for running roughshod over tribal sovereignty.

The brief notes that the National Labor Relations Act was enacted 1935, only a year after the Indian Reorganization Act was passed to encourage strong tribal governments. The tribes point out that federal, state and local governments are covered by the labor act.

"Given Congress's focus on the deplorable economic conditions, it is inconceivable that Congress would have thought of tribes as part of the class of private-sector employees it intended to regulate under the NLRA," the brief argues.

Citing subsequent acts of Congress and numerous executive orders that affirm tribal rights, the brief says the NLRB decision can't be sustained. "Application of the NLRA to tribal enterprises would abrogate important sovereign rights retained by the tribes under federal law and materially curtail their ability to function as the effective community governments envisioned by Congress," the tribes told the D.C. Circuit, which is still accepting briefs and has not set a date for a hearing.

The case arose when the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union attempted to organize employees of the San Manuel casino. The union has been an outspoken opponent of several tribes in southern California, where the San Manuel Band is based.

The NLRB didn't rule on the merits of the dispute but instead said it would assert jurisdiction over tribes and their enterprises on a case-by-case basis. Considerations include the nature of the enterprise -- commercial or governmental -- and whether the business employs or caters to non-Indians.

The ruling also stated, as a matter of policy, that labor law applies to tribes unless it affects "exclusive rights of self-government in purely intramural matters" or abrogates treaty rights. The San Manuel Band, like dozens of other tribes across the nation, lacks a treaty with the United States.

If the NLRB decision stands, tribes and their businesses could be brought before the agency for alleged violations of labor law. It's a time-consuming and costly process -- the San Manuel case was pending for five years before the ruling was issued.

In the interim, the NLRB lost a key sovereignty case. The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, in a January 2002 decision that wasn't taken to the U.S. Supreme Court, affirmed the right of tribes, as governments, to set their own labor-related laws.

"Like states and territories, the Pueblo has a strong interest as a sovereign in regulating economic activity involving its own members within its own territory," wrote Chief Judge Deanell R. Tacha in a case involving Ohkay Owingeh, a New Mexico tribe formerly known as San Juan Pueblo, "and it therefore may enact laws governing such activity."

Collectively, the brief submitted in the San Manuel case represents over half of the 560-plus federally recognized tribes in the nation. NCAI has more than 250 members while NIGA has more than 150 members, with some overlap between the two groups. When the case was before the NLRB, 20 tribes, tribal organizations and Alaska Native organizations took part.

At the same time of the San Manuel ruling, the NLRB issued a decision affecting a health corporation operated and owned by 58 Alaska tribes. Both rulings overturned labor law precedent.

San Manuel Band v NLRB:
Briefs, Decisions and Documents (Native American Rights Fund)

National Labor Relations Board Decisions:
San Manuel Indian Bingo and Casino | Yukon Kuskokwim Health Corporation

Relevant Links:
National Labor Relations Board - http://www.nlrb.gov
San Manuel Indian Bingo and Casino - http://www.sanmanuel.com
Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union - http://www.hereunion.org

Related Stories:
NLRB reaffirms tribal sovereignty ruling (10/06)
Tribal labor law rider killed by wide margin in House (06/27)
Fight looms on tribal labor amendment in House (6/27
Republicans sign onto tribal labor law exemption bill (06/13)
California tribe's workers to negotiate union contract (05/05)
Unions turn on each other in tribal sovereignty clash (05/04)
Labor union challenges tribe's Indian preference (12/07)
Federal labor board to hold hearing involving tribe (12/6)
NCAI between 'rock and a hard place' on labor rider (09/13)
Tribal labor amendment fails in House vote (9/13)
Rep. J.D. Hayworth: I told you so! On tribal labor (06/25)
California tribe ponders next move in labor case (6/23)
Court ruling adds to debate over tribal-labor relations (06/14)
Editorial: Unions should be allowed at casinos (6/10)
Labor board ruling draws sharp barbs from tribes (6/9)
Labor board's tribal ruling a surprise to many (6/8)
Board rules tribes subject to labor law (6/4)
Arbiter allows pro-union flyers by tribal employees (03/26)
Pro-union hearing blasts Calif. tribe for sovereignty (03/17)
N.M. tribe seals winning case on labor laws (12/09)
Settlement pending in tribal labor dispute (08/07)
Court denies tribal exemption from labor laws (01/17)
Tribal labor bill draws complaints (04/18)
Pueblo wins sovereignty case (1/14)

Copyright 2000-2006 Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Native Sun News: IHS hospital at Pine Ridge undergoes review (7/25)
Ivan Star Comes Out: Group disturbs tranquility at Bear Butte (7/25)
Indian Health Service discloses privacy breach of patient data (7/25)
BIA extends comment period on federal recognition regulation (7/25)
Navajo Nation president calling for FBI probe of brutal murders (7/25)
Jennie Stockle: Justice for victims of Cedarville mass shooting (7/25)
John Christian Hopkins: Waiting for Belgian waffles at Denny's (7/25)
Steven Pevar: Indian chldren are being taken from their homes (7/25)
IHS pays $53M to settle another contract support cost dispute (7/25)
Shinnecock Nation asserts control over tobacco amid pressure (7/25)
Four sentenced for stealing HHS funds from Oglala Sioux Tribe (7/25)
Unsettled: BIA questions Passamaquoddy forest management (7/25)
ASU News: First graduates of Indian studies master's program (7/25)
Blog: Tanka Fund aims to grow Indian Country's bison economy (7/25)
Opinion: A troubling relationship with Native peoples in Canada (7/25)
Opinion: Auction of tribal property in France sets bad precedent (7/25)
Puyallup Tribe cancels upcoming Ted Nugent concerts at casino (7/25)
Mayor gives conflicting view on Tohono O'odham Nation casino (7/25)
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe plans to start work at gaming site (7/25)
Pojoaque Pueblo defends provisions in proposed gaming deal (7/25)
Iipay Nation puts Internet gaming servers on Mohawk reserve (7/25)
Native Sun News: Cobell beneficiaries still waiting on payment (7/24)
Navajo Nation president to discuss brutal murders with mayor (7/24)
NCAI President Cladoosby offers cedar hat to BIA's Washburn (7/24)
Woman waiting in line at SCIA hearing reportedly had bedbugs (7/24)
S.E. Ruckman: Tribal members share frustrations on IHS care (7/24)
Mark Rogers: System exploits misery of our nation's veterans (7/24)
Fort Belknap Tribes depend on revenue from Internet lending (7/24)
Oglala Sioux Tribe still working on plan for legal alcohol sales (7/24)
Two Native girls charged with assault for hockey game brawl (7/24)
Chickasaw Nation welcomes public to new community center (7/24)
Oregon tribe plans major development at historic village site (7/24)
Unsettled Ch. 26: Passamaquoddy dealings cloaked in secrecy (7/24)
KCAW: BLM supports Alaska Native corporation in land dispute (7/24)
Mixed martial arts fighter from Lumbee Tribe proud of heritage (7/24)
Granddaughter of former team owner condemns racist mascot (7/24)
Opinion: Chief Black Hawk was notorious leader of Ute people (7/24)
Remote tribes facing threats from drug trafficking and logging (7/24)
BIA indicates Tohono O'odham Nation can use land for gaming (7/24)
Pojoaque Pueblo wants to take state out of casino operations (7/24)
Iipay Nation started planning Internet poker games last year (7/24)
Fighter seriously injured at Trinidad Rancheria's casino event (7/24)
St. Regis Mohawk Tribe concerned about potential gaming site (7/24)
Native Sun News: Great Plains tribes call for full contract funds (7/23)
Native Sun News: Candidate wants Obama to meet with tribes (7/23)
Audio: Senate Committee on Indian Affairs hearing on gaming (7/23)
President Obama nominates Jonodev Chaudhuri to lead NIGC (7/23)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.