Another rollercoaster week as #NoDAPL fight enters new phase


A rally in Seattle, Washington, on September 16, 2016, was among dozens of events held in solidarity with the #NoDAPL movement. Photo by John Duffy


• The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has yet to issue an easement for the Dakota Access Pipeline -- a decision is "likely to take weeks," according to an Obama administration attorney.
• The Dakota Access Pipeline is blocked from construction under an order from a federal appeals court in Washington, D.C.

The high-stakes battle over the Dakota Access Pipeline is moving into a new phase as the backers of the $3.8 billion project rest their fates on actions in faraway Washington, D.C.

A majority of the work on the 1,172-mile, four-state pipeline is complete. But a key portion remains on hold, both in the federal court system and within the Obama administration, and resolution could result in an even bigger financial and public relations hit for the backers of the costly and controversial effort.

At first, Dakota Access seemed to be on the path to victory. When a hearing in D.C. on August 24 failed to result in an immediate decision to halt construction, the company continued building on private lands near the home of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe in North Dakota.

Even after the tribe rushed back to court the following week with evidence of sacred sites and burial grounds on and near those lands, Judge James Boasberg declined to take action. So Dakota Access kept building, albeit amid ongoing resistance from the #NoDAPL encampments near the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation.

Yet when Boasberg finally issued a highly-anticipated ruling on September 9, the pipeline partnership still had reason to celebrate. To the detriment of the tribe's cause, the 58-page decision almost entirely focused on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, leaving the company in the clear to keep going.

"As Standing Rock acknowledges, Dakota Access has demonstrated that it is determined to build its pipeline right up to the water’s edge regardless of whether it has secured a permit to then build across," Boasberg observed in the lengthy decision.

But any sense of optimism that Energy Transfer Partners, the parent company of Dakota Access, displayed in public has since gone down the proverbial pipeline. A higher court ordered a halt to construction on Friday evening, just hours additional light was shed on the obstacles facing the project.

"With the case hanging over the pipeline, it's going to interfere with the pipeline," William Leone, an attorney for the Dakota Access partnership who served as a federal prosecutor during the Bush administration, said in court on Friday afternoon.

The proceeding was supposed to be a routine status update but it took some dramatic turns over the course of about an hour. At the onset, Judge Boasberg was clearly bothered by the Obama administration's unprecedented action that came shortly after his September 9 decision.

"I won't say I've been misled [but] I don't feel like the filings have been fully truthful," Boasberg said. 'That's my concern."

Michael Thorp, a senior attorney from the Department of Justice who had never argued in the case up until Friday, tried to explain why the extraordinary press release did not alter the government's stance in the lawsuit. But when he struggled to address Boasberg's repeated questions, a higher-level official stepped up to the plate.

"If we didn't share sufficient information with you ... I certainly apologize for that," said James Gette, who serves as section chief within the division at DOJ that handles environmental and Indian law cases. Before Friday, he hadn't argued in the case either.

While it took about 20 minutes for that apology to come out, Gette's words were obviously reassuring because Boasberg quickly dropped his line of inquiries about the press release. But the drama wasn't over as attention moved to Leone, who offered new details that help explain why Dakota Access has been so optimistic about completing the pipeline.

According to Leone, the Army Corps told Dakota Access that it had already granted an easement for the pipeline to cross the Missouri River at Lake Oahe. The document had even been "signed," he said, and all that was left was for the agency to notify Congress, a step seen as a mere formality in the process.

But Leone essentially accused the Army Corps of stabbing his clients in the back. He confirmed that the earlier August 24 hearing was the first he was made aware that the easement hadn't been approved.

"We are as confused and befuddled as you are," Leone told the judge on Friday.

The easement is in fact on hold and won't be approved until the Army Corps "can determine whether it will need to reconsider any of its previous decisions regarding the Lake Oahe site under the National Environmental Policy Act or other federal laws," according to the September 9 joint statement from the Department of Justice, the Department of the Army and the Department of the Interior.

But just when that will happen is a big question. According to Gette, an answer from the Army Corps is "likely to take weeks."

"It is not likely to take months," Gette said.

A speedy timeline is crucial to Dakota Access because its backers have vowed to start transporting oil by January 1, 2017. The longer the Army Corps takes, the harder it will be for Energy Transfer Partners to complete the project on time.

But even if an answer comes sooner rather than later, Dakota Access must deal with another Washington institution -- the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, whose order on Friday evening put a halt to construction within 20 miles on both sides of Lake Oahe.

While the injunction is only temporary, it still prevents the company from building "its pipeline right up to the water’s edge regardless of whether it has secured a permit to then build across," effectively undercutting the opinion that Boasberg issued earlier this month.

According to the D.C Circuit's order, the case will be handled by Judge Janice Rogers Brown, Judge Thomas B. Griffith and Judge Cornelia T.L. Pillard. They plan to schedule a hearing that could determine whether the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe, the other plaintiff in the lawsuit, are entitled to a more permanent injunction on construction of the pipeline. They could also determine to lift the injunction.

As of Monday afternoon, the D.C. Circuit had not yet scheduled a hearing, which leaves Dakota Access in limbo as it seeks to finish construction more than 1,500 miles from the nation's capital. Although work on the east side of Lake Oahe is done, according to Leone, the west side is still in play.

"The pipeline is 60 percent done," Leone said.

Of the judges assigned to the case, Brown quickly created a negative record in Indian law after she was nominated by former president George W. Bush, according to a 2008 review of her writings by Indianz.Com. She did not agree with the injunction that was issued on Friday, according to the order.

As the case in the D.C. Circuit proceeds, the underlying lawsuit remains active. Judge Boasberg ordered the Army Corps to file its formal answer by October 11 and to file what is known as administrative record -- essentially, the documents used during the agency's consideration of the pipeline -- by November 10. He also scheduled another status conference on November 10.

Additionally, Boasberg indicated he will consolidate the lawsuit with another one filed by the Yankton Sioux Tribe. That would make the case even more busy because it would bring in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, an agency of the Department of the Interior, as a defendant. Three tribes would be on the same side as plaintiffs.

"As Chairman of the Ihanktonwan, I and the Ihanktonwan Oyate support the efforts our relatives at Standing Rock and Cheyenne River are taking to protect what we as the Oceti Sakowin hold sacred. We stand with them and all our relatives in taking this action in defense of our people," Chairman Robert Flying Hawk said in a press release announcing the lawsuit.

DC Circuit Court of Appeals #NoDAPL Injunction:
Order: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (September 16, 2016)

Join the Conversation

Related Stories:
Judge dissolves restraining order against Standing Rock leaders (9/19)
Zoltán Grossman: Cowboys are quiet as tribes unite for #NoDAPL (9/19)
Dave Archambault: Disaster placed on Standing Rock's doorstep (9/19)
David Gipp: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe stands up for life and water (9/19)
Terri Miles: That 'information point' at the #NoDAPL encampment (9/19)
Peter d'Errico: Be bold in fighting Dakota Access Pipeline in court (9/19)
Appeals court halts Dakota Access Pipeline work pending hearing (9/16)
Sparring continues in #NoDAPL lawsuit as tribes seek halt to work (9/16)
Bronson Koenig hosts basketball clinic for youth at Standing Rock (9/16)
Senate passes water bill but fails to include #NoDAPL amendment (9/15)
White House to respond to #NoDAPL petition with 203K signatures (9/15)
Doug George-Kanentiio: Prophecy and the people at Standing Rock (9/15)
Mark Trahant: There is something we can do to help Standing Rock (9/15)
Native Sun News Today: #NoDAPL movement forges ahead to win (9/15)
Mary Annette Pember: Indigenous women lead prayers for water (9/15)
Steve Russell: Legal encounters and the Dakota Access Pipeline (9/15)
Emotions run strong as #NoDAPL seeps into debate on lands bill (9/14)
Defenders of the Water School is going strong at #NoDAPL camp (9/14)
Key House Democrats call for hearing on Dakota Access Pipeline (9/14)
Brandon Ecoffey: Pipeline destroys our sacred and cultural sites (9/14)
Jori Kaniehtakohe Rourke: Our people unite in #NoDAPL battle (9/14)
Hundreds rally at White House to block Dakota Access Pipeline (9/13)
Judge won't grant injunction to protect sacred sites in DAPL path (9/12)
Democracy Now: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe creates 'awakening' (9/12)
Mark Trahant: #NoDAPL movement forces long overdue debate (9/12)
Matthew Fletcher: Obama joins tribes on the right side of history (9/12)
Steve Russell: Anonymous makes appearance in #NoDAPL fight (9/12)
Liz Perez Halperin: Why this warrior stands up for Standing Rock (9/12)
Obama steps in with major action halting Dakota Access Pipeline (9/9)
Tribes move quickly to protect sacred lands within pipeline path (9/9)
Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe thanks Obama for #NoDAPL stance (9/9)
Indian Country eagerly anticipates decision in #NoDAPL lawsuit (9/9)
Lakota Country Times: Henry Red Cloud takes stand for #NoDAPL (9/9)
Ernestine Chasing Hawk: A history of resistance at Standing Rock (9/9)
Steve Russell: Legal encounters and the Dakota Access Pipeline (9/9)
Obama dodges #NoDAPL query as youth question commitment (9/8)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe urges calm ahead of #NoDAPL ruling (9/8)
Mark Trahant: White House must get involved in #NoDAPL fight (9/8)
Native Sun News Today: Law clamps down on #NoDAPL resisters (9/8)
Ivan Star Comes Out: #NoDAPL movement is about sacred water (9/8)
Jim Gray: Mainstream media is missing the major #NoDAPL story (9/8)
Gyasi Ross: Doing your part to ensure #NoDAPL keeps on winning (9/8)
Sheriff recruiting more law enforcement for #NoDAPL campsites (9/8)
#NoDAPL movement takes center stage at North Dakota summit (9/7)
Lakota Country Times: School going strong at #NoDAPL campsite (9/7)
Mark Charles: The #NoDAPL struggle continues after hearing in DC (9/7)
Dave Archambault II: The Dakota Access Pipeline musn't be built (9/7)
Eastern Cherokees contribute $50K to Standing Rock Sioux Tribe (9/7)
Jill Stein of Green Party faces charges for standing with #NoDAPL (9/7)
Dave Archambault: Dakota Access Pipeline destroys sacred sites (9/7)
Steven Newcomb: Vicious dogs unleashed on #NoDAPL resisters (9/7)
Mike Myers: Historic ties between the Haudenosaunee and Sioux (9/7)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe disappointed with ruling in #NoDAPL case (9/6)
Dakota Access fires back at tribes ahead of hearing in federal court (9/6)
Lakota Country Times: Tribes still united at #NoDAPL encampment (9/6)
Native Sun News: Death highlights dangers of Dakota Access work (9/6)
Hearing ordered after Standing Rock Sioux Tribe reports destruction (9/5)
Army Corps backs restraining order against Dakota Access Pipeline (9/5)
Quinault Nation sends Grandfather Canoe to #NoDAPL encampment (9/5)
Sarah Sunshine Manning: Dogs attack peaceful #NoDAPL resisters (9/5)
LaDonna Brave Bull Allard: We have no choice but to defend water (9/5)
Jacqueline Keeler: #NoDAPL resistance is part of something bigger (9/5)
Steve Russell: Federal Indian law and the Dakota Access Pipeline (9/5)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe reports cultural finds near pipeline path (9/2)
Mark Trahant: #NoDAPL poses test for Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine (9/2)
Native Sun News: Cartoonist brings humor to #NoDAPL movement (9/2)
Tribal activists cheer demise of controversial pipeline in Minnesota (9/2)
United Nations Forum backs Standing Rock Sioux Tribe on #NoDAPL (9/1)
Native Sun News: Northern Cheyenne Tribe joins #NoDAPL efforts (9/1)
Jim Kent: The real truth about the #NoDAPL resistance movement (9/1)
Mark Trahant: Candidate shows support for #NoDAPL movement (9/1)
Lakota Country Times: #NoDAPL roadblock remains a major issue (8/31)
Brandon Ecoffey: #NoDAPL resistance is the start of a movement (8/31)
Dave Archambault: Struggle unfolds on Standing Rock Sioux land (8/31)
Terri Miles: Indian Country unites to stare down the black snake (8/31)
Joel Heitkamp: Officials in North Dakota need a lesson in respect (8/31)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe confirms lack of easement for pipeline (8/30)
Supplies needed for #NoDAPL Defenders of Sacred Water School (8/30)
Lakota Country Times: Students witness history at pipeline camp (8/30)
Vi Waln: Media distorts peaceful nature of sacred #NoDAPL camp (8/30)
Mike Myers: Historic ties between the Haudenosaunee and Sioux (8/30)
Mark Anthony Rolo: Tribes remain at mercy of bad federal policies (8/30)
Defenders of the Water School opens at pipeline resistance camp (8/29)
Lakota Country Times: Resisters dispute emergency declaration (8/29)
Dave Archambault: Stopping the desecration of our Mother Earth (8/29)
Mark Trahant: State erects roadblock at peaceful #NoDAPL camp (8/29)
Latoya Lonelodge: Witnessing history at Camp of Sacred Stones (8/29)
Jon Eagle: Land remains sacred to the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe (8/29)
Albert Bender: Tribes join together at Camp of the Sacred Stones (8/29)
Steven Newcomb: Law of Christendom at play in #NoDAPL battle (8/29)
Arvol Looking Horse: Saving our Earth from energy development (8/29)
Tribal Tribune: Unity at Standing Rock Sioux Tribe's #NoDAPL camp (8/26)
Winona LaDuke: Corporate interests come to destroy our mother (8/26)
Sarah Sunshine Manning: #NoDAPL campaign awakens our people (8/26)
Dakota Access Pipeline lacks key approval to build by reservation (8/26)
Lummi Nation sends totem pole to #NoDAPL camp in North Dakota (8/26)
Dave Archambault: Why the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe is fighting (8/25)
Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe chair dispels rumors about camp site (8/25)
Sen. Bernie Sanders joining opposition to Dakota Access Pipeline (8/25)
Native Sun News: Thousands join #NoDAPL resistance movement (8/25)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe sees strong support at pipeline hearing (8/24)
Kayla DeVault: Navajo Nation must take a stand on Dakota Access (8/24)
Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe seeks prayers ahead of pipeline hearing (8/23)
Lakota Country Times: Oglala Sioux Tribe joins fight against pipeline (8/23)
Brandon Ecoffey: The Horse Nations prepare for battle over pipeline (8/23)
Simon Moya-Smith: Hillary Clinton remains silent amid pipeline feud (8/23)
Steven Newcomb: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe challenges domination (8/23)
Sheriff mistook sacred pipes for pipe bombs at pipeline protest site (8/23)
Tribes prepare for critical hearing in Dakota Access Pipeline lawsuit (8/22)
Mark Trahant: Pipeline fight highlights power of political organizing (8/22)
Lakota Country Times: Tribes unite to stop Dakota Access Pipeline (8/22)
Vi Waln: Our water system is being threatened by energy pipelines (8/22)
Winona LaDuke: Bigger problems ahead for Dakota Access Pipeline (8/22)
Dallas Goldtooth: Tribes shut out of Dakota Access Pipeline process (8/22)
Native Sun News: Resistance grows against Dakota Access Pipeline (08/18)
Harold Frazier: Obama must put a stop to Dakota Access Pipeline (08/15)
Tribes and Native youth join forces in campaign to stop oil pipeline (08/11)
Democrats embrace tribal sovereignty in platform for convention (07/08)
Dakota Access Pipeline to go underneath tribal burial site in Iowa (06/22)
Native Sun News: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe battles oil pipeline (06/08)
Iowa board approves energy pipeline work amid tribal objections (06/07)
Native Sun News: Tribes score big in fights against energy projects (05/26)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe seeks halt to construction of pipeline (05/12)
Native Sun News: Youth run 500 miles to protest new oil pipeline (05/11)
Native Sun News: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe aims to stop pipeline (04/27)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and Army Corps to discuss oil pipeline (04/26)
Native Sun News: Tribes gaining traction in war against pipelines (04/20)
Brandon Ecoffey: Tribes continue battle against energy pipelines (04/19)
Standing Rock Sioux Tribe sets up sacred camp to oppose pipeline (04/15)
Native Sun News: Tribes organize against Dakota Access Pipeline (04/13)
Iowa Tribe joins fight against oil pipeline on aboriginal territory (3/24)
Native Sun News: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe battles pipeline plan (3/14)
Native Sun News: Tribes fight another pipeline through Great Plains (07/07)
Meskwaki Tribe opposes oil pipeline through aboriginal territory (03/17)