Debate: Transform Columbus Day or treasure it?
Thursday, September 28, 2006
Hannah Hayes' view: "While his legacy in the Jefferson County School curriculum is one of an explorer, it should be noted that Columbus’ early travels were motivated by the search for slaves and greed for gold. Historical Spanish archives that resurfaced in 2005 yielded a report from his successor, Francisco de Bobadilla that recounts Columbus’ governorship in the New World as tyrannical. The atrocities that Bobadilla said were inflicted upon settlers are horrifying.
Columbus Day should be stripped from our calendar and replaced with a day to honor a union of cultural diversity and the true roots of this country."
Kelly Weist's view: "The history of Columbus and all explorers has been one of a clash of cultures. Cultures that existed in lands that were subsequently discovered by other, more sophisticated cultures were often impacted adversely by disease, war and famine; the funny thing is that it went both ways. Disease, war and famine visited the “discovering” cultures as well, but the activists don’t want to acknowledge that. Instead, they want to rewrite history in such a way to as to force political correctness on all of us.
Genocide takes intent. You have to really want to obliterate a group of people, erase them from the face of the Earth. Think of the Holocaust, or the current jihad by Islamofascists. So even if the charges they level against Columbus are true, which they aren’t, it isn’t genocide."
Get the Story:
Devil's Advocate: Columbus: explorer of oppressor?
(The Canyon Courier 9/27)
Relevant Links:
Transform Columbus Day -
http://www.transformcolumbusday.org
Related Stories:
Column: Bad Eagle supports Columbus Day parade
(9/27)
Comanche man to
perform at NMAI despite critique (9/26)
Scalia leads Columbus Day parade in New York
(10/11)
Columbus Day parade, protest turn
out peaceful (10/10)
Another Columbus
Day parade and protest in Denver (10/7)
Colorado AIM offers deal on Columbus Day parade
(10/04)
Denver mayor 'sick and tired' of
Columbus Day protest (9/29)
Column:
Columbus Day is only a parade for protesters (01/28)
Column: Columbus Day protesters overreacting
(1/27)
Editorial: Law should protect
Columbus Day parade (1/26)
Columbus Day
parade likened to cross-burning (1/26)
Denver forced to end Columbus Day protest cases
(1/25)
Column: Columbus Day parade is
not 'hate speech' (1/25)
Denver won't
drop case against Columbus protesters (1/24)
Columbus Day protesters acquitted in Denver
(1/21)
Natives changing perspective on
'Indian' holidays (11/10)
Opinion: Be
proud of Wal-Mart, and Columbus too (10/15)
Letter: Indians better off thanks to Columbus
(10/14)
Native students don't celebrate
Columbus Day (10/12)
Column: Columbus
ignored as Natives persevere (10/11)
Editorial: It's that time of the year (Columbus
Day) (10/08)
Column: It's wrong to
compare Columbus to Hitler (10/07)
Columbus Day protesters seek day in
court(1/14)
Were
terrorists plotting on Columbus Day? (10/17)
Columbus Day not a celebration for
all (10/15)
Letters:
Columbus Day marches and more (10/15)
Another year, another Columbus Day
(10/14)
You can't stop
the Italians! (10/11)
It's Columbus Day, Be nice to the
Italians! (10/10)
Editorial: Be nice to the Italians
(10/9)
Another year,
Another Columbus Day (10/7)
Columbus Day events given
permits (7/17)
Cost of Columbus
Day topping $100,000 (10/9)
Italians to boycott Columbus Day
(9/19)
Columbus Day started in
Colorado (9/10)
'Columbus' may
be dropped from parade (8/29)
Event is not Columbus protest, says
group (7/17)
Columbus Day battle
brews (7/12)
Italians celebrate
Columbus Day early (7/11)
Group
awarded Columbus Day permit (7/10)
Peaceful protest greets parade (10/9)
Copyright © 2000-2006 Indianz.Com
Subscribe