indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Dynamic Homes
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines
Print   Subscribe
Supreme Court deadlocks in closely-watched tribal jurisdiction case

Filed Under: Business | Law | National
More on: 5th circuit, antonin scalia, any howe, bonnie juneau, dollar general, john dossett, jurisdiction, matthew fletcher, mbci, ncai, supreme court, tribal courts, women
     
   

Native women send a message to the U.S. Supreme Court as the justices heard arguments in Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians, a tribal jurisdiction case, on December 7, 2015. Photo by Indianz.Com

The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday failed to come to a majority in Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians, a closely-watched tribal jurisdiction case.

By a 4-4 vote, the justices upheld a 5th Circuit Court of Appeals decision that sided with the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians. The tie means Dollar General, a publicly-traded company that reported $18.9 billion in net sales in 2014, must answer to a lawsuit filed in the tribe's court.

"The judgment is affirmed by an equally divided Court," the anti-climactic ruling stated.

The deadlock does not set a precedent so it doesn't benefit Indian Country as a whole. But it allows the family of a minor tribal member who alleged abuse at a Dollar General store on the reservation to continue to seek justice in the Choctaw court system.


Indianz.Com SoundCloud: U.S. Supreme Court Oral Argument in Dollar General Corp. v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians December 7, 2015

On a larger scale, though, the tie represents the best possible outcome in a case that had tribal advocates everywhere worried. The Supreme Court decided its last tribal jurisdiction case by a 5-4 vote and it looked like Dollar General was headed in that same direction.

"It was pretty clear at the argument that the typical conservatives -- the five conservatives -- were not very happy about this case and the four judges who are less conservative seemed to be on our side," John Dossett, the general counsel for the National Congress of American Indians, said in February. "But it wasn't looking good."

Those five conservatives included Justice Antonin Scalia. Had he not passed away in February, he likely would have sided with Dollar General in holding that the company was not subject to tribal jurisdiction.

But the remaining members seemed hopelessly deadlocked without his vote. As the clock ticked on the case -- it was the oldest on the docket without a decision -- they were unable to reach a clear consensus.


The U.S. Supreme Court on June 23, 2016, issued a one-sentence decision in Dollar General v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians, a closely-watched tribal jurisdiction case.

"I suspect that they were trying to put together some sort of majority until the last minute, and then just gave up," Amy Howe, the editor of the influential SCOTUSBlog, wrote on Thursday morning.

The owner of SCOTUSBlog is attorney Thomas Goldstein, who represented Dollar General at the Supreme Court. Howe worked at the Goldstein & Russell firm before becoming editor of the site full-time.

The four conservative-leaning members of the court are Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Samuel Alito. They were part of the majority in Plains Commerce Bank v. Long, which determined that the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe lacked jurisdiction over a non-Indian bank.

It would be highly unlikely for any of those four to have changed their minds about tribal jurisdiction since that 2008 decision. That left them in conflict with the four more liberal members of the court -- Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Justice Stephen G. Breyer, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, and Justice Elena Kagan.

Sotomayor has emerged as Indian Country's most visible ally and Kagan, who is the most junior member of the court, has become a reliable voice for tribal interests. But the Supreme Court did not explain the tie so it's impossible at this point to know where the justices stood on Dollar General.

"Perhaps the Chief Justice assigned himself the majority after oral argument (he did write Plains Commerce and so has a track record), and struggled mightily to hold a majority for the past several months," law professor Matthew Fletcher, who called the tie a "huge win" for the Mississippi Band, wrote on Turtle Talk on Thursday.

It took the justices 199 days to resolve the case and Native women were among those paying close attention. They turned out in force on the day of oral arguments on December 7, 2015, to stand up for tribal sovereignty.

"We need to be able to protect our women and our children," Bonnie Juneau, a council member for the Tulalip Tribes of Washington, said at the time. "Justice should be applied no matter where you live."

U.S. Supreme Court Decision:
Dollar General v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians (June 23, 2016)

U.S. Supreme Court Documents:
Docket Sheet No. 13-1496 | Questions Presented | Oral Argument Transcript: Dollar General v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians

5th Circuit Court of Appeals Decision:
Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians (March 14, 2014)
Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians (March 14, 2014)

Related Stories:
Supreme Court enters final stretch of historic yet unusual term (6/20)
Native women confront high rates of violence in Indian Country (06/17)
Supreme Court still holding onto ruling in tribal jurisdiction case (6/16)
Noah Feldman: Supreme Court puts more Indian people in federal prison (06/16)
Supreme Court decision hailed as a victory for tribal sovereignty (06/14)
Matthew Fletcher: Takeaways from Supreme Court's new decision (06/14)
Supreme Court upholds use of tribal convictions in federal system (06/13)
Long wait continues for decision in tribal court jurisdiction dispute (6/13)
Supreme Court debates 'inherent' tribal sovereignty in new ruling (6/9)
Clock keeps ticking on closely-watched tribal jurisdiction dispute (06/06)
Opinion: Eight justices isn't enough for functioning Supreme Court (6/6)
Another week goes by without decision in tribal jurisdiction case (5/31)
Long wait hints at Supreme Court tie in closely-watched tribal jurisdiction case (05/23)
Supreme Court still holding onto decision in tribal jurisdiction case (5/19)
Still no decision from Supreme Court in tribal jurisdiction dispute (5/16)
Supreme Court pick puts some Indian law cases on questionnaire (05/11)
Still no decision from Supreme Court in tribal jurisdiction case (04/26)
Supreme Court still hasn't issued decision in tribal jurisdiction case (4/21)
Supreme Court case prompts defense of tribal judiciary systems (4/19)
Supreme Court ready to hear fourth Indian law case on the docket (4/18)
Bill in Senate expands tribal jurisdiction over non-Indian offenders (04/14)
Vacancy on Supreme Court already impacts high-profile cases (03/30)
Leader of Navajo Nation pushes for action on Supreme Court pick (03/22)
Chair of Sault Ste. Marie Tribe calls for action on court nominee (03/17)
Supreme Court nominee comes with some Indian law experience (03/16)
Dollar General defends plan to open in majority Native community (03/08)
Klamath Tribes oppose Dollar General store due to court challenge (03/01)
Aaron Payment: Tribal sovereignty hangs in the balance at Supreme Court (02/29)
Updates from Day 2 of National Congress of American Indians winter session in D.C. (02/24)
No Supreme Court opinions this week following Scalia's death (02/22)
Mississippi Choctaw family seeks $2.5M in Dollar General case (12/11)
Matthew Fletcher: Supreme Court takes up tribal jurisdiction case (12/8)
Native women rally at Supreme Court for tribal jurisdiction case (12/7)
Steven Newcomb: Supreme Court ready to cut sovereignty again (12/7)
Peter d'Errico: Anti-Indian forces play hardball in Supreme Court (12/7)
Mike Myers: Tribal jurisdiction opponents flock to Supreme Court (12/04)
Ned Blackhawk: Supreme Court case jeopardizes tribal rights (11/25)
Peter d'Errico: Anti-Indian wars continue in our Supreme Court (11/24)
Native women schedule Quilt Walk for Justice at Supreme Court (12/01)
Native women to rally at Supreme Court for upcoming case (11/11)
DOJ to help with arguments in Supreme Court jurisdiction case (11/09)
Vice President Joe Biden reflects on triumphs of Obama's Indian policies (10/28)
Native women defend tribal jurisdiction in Supreme Court case (10/26)
Tribes urged to bring states on board for Supreme Court case (10/20)
Cheyenne & Arapaho Tribal Tribune: Supreme Court case tests tribal jurisdiction (10/14)
Supreme Court schedules oral arguments in two Indian law cases (10/12)
States oppose tribal jurisdiction in upcoming Supreme Court case (10/07)
Bryan Newland: The racist foundation of Supreme Court rulings (09/08)
Supreme Court agrees to hear first tribal jurisdiction case in years (06/15)
Supreme Court needs more time to review tribal jurisdiction case (06/08)
SCOTUSBlog: DOJ urges denial of petition in tribal court dispute (05/20)
DOJ files brief in tribal jurisdiction case before Supreme Court (05/14)
Supreme Court asks DOJ for views in Mississippi Choctaw case (10/06)

Copyright © Indianz.Com
More headlines...

Latest Headlines:

Trump administration rolls out first rule under historic trust reform law
Interior Department sends out another $13.1M in Cobell buy-back offers
Senate Committee on Indian Affairs headed to New Mexico for hearing
House committee again leaves out Indian Country in hearing on Interior
Mark Maxey: Oklahoma tries to crush Native protesters with new law
Carletta Tilousi: Havasupai Tribe threatened by uranium development
Opinion: Don't be fooled by Jimmie Durham's claims of Cherokee heritage
Opinion: Economic development for Indian Country in upcoming farm bill
Government worker suspended after calling Native principal a 'rabid s----'
Kiowa citizen Tristan Ahtone to report on tribes for High Country News
New York Times features Dina Gilio-Whitaker in editorial on health care
Tribes break ground on monument to their history in Virginia's capitol
Warm Springs Tribes battle large wildfire that broke out behind casino
Spokane Tribe casino doesn't bother Air Force despite claims in lawsuit
Tribes in for long haul as oil continues to flow through Dakota Access
Mark Trahant: Don't plan on getting sick if you're from Indian Country
Tiffany Midge: I shall joke as long as the grass grows and the rivers flow
Director of Office of Indian Energy deletes offensive Twitter account
States cheer decision on grizzly bears amid tribal concerns about hunts
Washington asks high court to overturn Yakama Nation treaty victory
New York Times editorial board reconsiders stance on racist trademarks
Colville Tribes remove council member a week before citizens go to polls
Marijuana firm promises big investments with help of ex-Seminole chair
Lumbee Tribe ordered to release voter list to opponents of chairman
National Indian Gaming Association chooses David Bean as vice chair
Eastern Cherokee citizen promoted to vice president of casino marketing
Tribes in Connecticut waiting on governor to sign bill for new casino
Secretary Zinke removes protections for grizzlies over tribal objections
Court sets final deadline for remaining payments from Cobell settlement
Mary Annette Pember: Indian Child Welfare Act strengthens our families
Peter d'Errico: Navajo authors offer fresh perspective on sovereignty
Native woman was jailed and forced to ride with assailant during trial
Ute Mountain Ute Tribe challenges new permit for uranium operation
Montana tribes get new member of Congress who pleaded to assault
Connecticut tribes welcome court decision favoring new casino law
Pueblo tribes dispute state's demand for $40M in gaming revenues
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe remains confident of approval of casino
Nooksack Tribe accepting slot tickets while casino remains closed
Key House committee under fire for moving slowly on tribal agenda
Tribes go it alone on climate change as Trump team shifts priorities
Bryan Newland: President Trump's budget threatens tribal treaties
Steve Russell: The GI Bill changed the United States for the better
Harold Monteau: Democrats lack proactive agenda, proactive strategy
St. Regis Mohawk Tribe orders 20 non-citizens to leave reservation
Wilton Rancheria accused of working too closely with city on casino
Witness list for hearing on bill to reform the Indian Health Service
Arne Vainio: What does the princess want to be when she grows up?
Doug George-Kanentiio: 'Spirit Game' brings Iroquois lacrosse to life
Cronkite News: Navajo activist vows fight against racist NFL mascot
Eric Hannel: Addressing the health care crisis among Native Americans
Bill for tribal regalia at graduation ceremonies advances in California
Ramapough Lunaape Nation wins reversal of ruling on prayer camp
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe still waits on casino ruling from Trump team
Another former leader of Winnebago Tribe pleads in gaming theft case
Supreme Court ruling poses hurdle for opponents of racist NFL mascot
Change the Mascot campaign responds to negative Supreme Court ruling
Secretary Zinke set for another hearing on Interior Department budget
Mark Trahant: Republicans write health reform bill behind closed doors
Jeff Grubbe: Agua Caliente Band focuses on protecting our groundwater
>>> more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.