indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+
ph: 202 630 8439
Fredericks Peebles & Morgan LLP
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Supreme Court to resolve self-determination dispute
Tuesday, March 23, 2004

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a dispute over a federal funding policy that tribes say is costing them hundreds of millions of dollars.

Lawsuits over contract support costs have been brought by a handful of tribes but the issue affects all of Indian Country. This year alone, tribes who manage federal programs will run up against a $142 million shortfall, according to estimates from the National Congress of American Indians.

"If the U.S. has a contractual relationship with anybody out there in the U.S., it honors those contracts," Ron Allen, the treasurer of NCAI and chairman of the Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe of Washington, said last month. "Today, the U.S. is not honoring the full contracts that it has with existing tribes."

Over the last 30 years, tribes have taken over programs previously managed by the Bureau of Indian Affairs and the Indian Health Service. But tribes have long questioned whether they are receiving enough support funds to effectively carry out the programs.

In a case brought by the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma, the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the tribe is owed full support costs for administering IHS programs. The unanimous decision, issued by a three-judge panel in July 2003, held the Department of Health and Human Services liable for failing to pay.

The ruling conflicted with an earlier one from the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. A three-judge panel in November 2002 said the Cherokee Nation and the Duck Valley Shoshone-Paiute Tribe of Nevada will have to live with the funding shortages.

In agreeing to resolve the dispute, the Supreme Court consolidated both cases. The Bush administration at first opposed review of the 10th Circuit case but changed its mind after losing in the Federal Circuit.

The dispute is rooted in the landmark Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act. The law, passed in 1975, authorizes tribes to enter into contracts to manage BIA and IHS programs.

The law dictates that tribes receive no less than the amount the government would have spent on the programs. It also requires the government to provide tribes with additional funds needed to carry out the contracts.

In briefs to the high court, the Department of Justice says the federal agencies are at the mercy of Congress when doling out the contract support costs. Government lawyers cite two limits: the amount Congress appropriates for the contracts; and a restriction on "reprogramming," or shifting other funds, to cover any shortfalls.

"Those limits reflect the fact that self-determination agreements are not government procurement contracts -- they are not purchases for the federal government," one brief stated. "Instead, they are governmental funding arrangements under which the tribes are substituted for a federal agency both in furnishing governmental services and in receiving federal funding for that purpose."

The Federal Circuit ruled that this line of thought wasn't an adequate defense for the Secretary of Health and Human Services, who oversees the IHS. "We cannot agree that the Secretary had discretion to refuse to reprogram to meet his contractual obligations," wrote Judge Timothy B. Dyk.

The 10th Circuit, on the other hand, deferred to agency discretion, which is based on the Congressional limits. "This court finds the contracts at issue are conditioned on the IHS having sufficient funding," wrote Judge Stephen H. Anderson.

Tribes have not had luck in pressing their views before the Supreme Court. Since 2001, Indian interests have lost the overwhelming majority of cases that reach the justices.

An avenue out of a potential negative decision is already being pursued by tribal leaders. NCAI is urging members of Congress to amend existing law in order to fund contracts fully.

"It is time to change the system for funding these government contracts," NCAI president Tex Hall wrote in a November 7 letter to the Senate Indian Affairs Committee and the House Resources Committee. "Indian tribes should no longer be treated as 'second class' contractors."

Lower Court Decisions:
Fed Circuit: Thompson v. Cherokee Nation (July 3, 2003) | 10th Circuit: Cherokee Nation v. Thompson (November 26, 2002) |

Relevant Documents:
Docket Sheet No. 03-853: Thompson v. Cherokee Nation | Docket Sheet No. 02-1472: Cherokee Nation v. Thompson | Department of Justice Petition No. 03-853 | Department of Justice Supplemental Brief No. 02-1472

Related Decisions:
9th Circuit: Shoshone-Bannock v. Thompson (October 16, 2001) | 9th Circuit: Navajo Nation v. HHS, No. 99-16129 (April 8, 2003)

Relevant Links:
Contract Support Costs, NCAI - http://www.ncai.org/main/pages/issues/
governance/contract_support.asp

Related Stories:
Supreme Court weighs self-determination dispute (03/09)
Court rules tribe owed self-determination funds (07/07)
Appeals court turns down Navajo Nation again (04/09)
Court rebuffs tribes on contract funding dispute (11/27)
Navajo Nation challenges contract policy (10/04)

Copyright 2000-2004 Indianz.Com
More headlines...
Stay Connected:

Local Links:
Federal Register | Indian Gaming | Jobs & Notices | In The Hoop | Message Board
Latest News:
Native Sun News: Violence against Native women is on the rise (10/24)
Morgan Howard: Corporate dividends confict with Tlingit values (10/24)
David Wilkins: Abandon the Doctrine of Discovery in Indian law (10/24)
Rep. Don Young to speak to Alaska Natives amid controversy (10/24)
Native Sun News: Oglala Sioux Tribe heads to election season (10/23)
Al Caroll: Recognize tribal sovereignty in new US Constitution (10/23)
Michael Baines: Senate candidate battles Alaska Native rights (10/23)
President Barack Obama urges early voting for Alaska Natives (10/23)
Ho-Chunk Nation woman named president of Girl Scouts board (10/23)
3rd Circuit won't force town to repatriate Jim Thorpe's remains (10/23)
Navajo Nation's top court orders new ballots without candidate (10/23)
Alaska Federation of Natives ready to open annual convention (10/23)
Alaska governor to sign Native languages bill six months later (10/23)
Rep. Don Young blames government 'largesse' for suicide rate (10/23)
Washington player says tattoo represents Cherokee heritage (10/23)
Crow Tribe seeks renewal of Indian Coal Production Tax Credit (10/23)
Native advocates come together to combat domestic violence (10/23)
Agua Caliente Band and DOJ submit briefs in water rights case (10/23)
Former health executive from Chippewa Cree Tribe sentenced (10/23)
Final person sentenced in theft from Blackfeet Nation program (10/23)
Opinion: Tribes exploit loopholes in America's political system (10/23)
Otoe-Missouria Tribe announces plans for new gaming facility (10/23)
Rival leaders of Chukchansi Tribe to meet amid casino closure (10/23)
Navajo Nation challenges lawsuit over death of casino patron (10/23)
Law Article: Judge restricts BIA authority in Class III dispute (10/23)
Column: Election won't end North Fork off-reservation casino (10/23)
Eyapaha Today: Oneida singer follows in mother's footsteps (10/22)
Native Sun News: Candidate seeks investigation into program (10/22)
Ivan Star Comes Out: Lakota people disrespect our language (10/22)
Cedric Sunray: Standing together to fight tribal disenrollment (10/22)
SCIA to hold listening session at NCAI on Indian education bill (10/22)
FNDI urges passage for Indian Teacher Loan Forgiveness Act (10/22)
Chumash Tribe praises BIA movement on land-into-trust bid (10/22)
Steven Newcomb: The role of Latin in empire and colonization (10/22)
Christopher Chavis: Navajo court got it wrong in fluency case (10/22)
Navajo Nation presidential hopeful to be removed from ballot (10/22)
Aging BIA school on Navajo Nation awaits replacement funds (10/22)
Review: NMAI treaties exhibit underscores misunderstandings (10/22)
Alaska Native elders and youth share issues at annual meeting (10/22)
Shinnecock Nation allows felons to hold office in certain cases (10/22)
2nd Circuit hears appeal from former chairman of Pequot Tribe (10/22)
Rep. Don Young criticized for comments to high school students (10/22)
Candidates differ on Spokane Tribe's off-reservation casino bid (10/22)
more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.