indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Fredericks Peebles & Morgan LLP
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Court upholds off-reservation gaming provision in IGRA
Friday, April 30, 2004

A provision in federal law that gives states the ability to limit off-reservation gaming does not violate the U.S. Constitution or the trust relationship, a federal appeals court ruled on Thursday.

In a unanimous decision, the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld language in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act that grants states veto authority over off-reservation land acquisitions. Three Wisconsin tribes raised a series of constitutional challenges to the provision but all were rejected by the court.

A panel of three judges also said Congress has the power to enact laws that aren't necessarily in the best interests of tribes. "The Supreme Court has not yet invalidated a federal statute on the ground that it did not advance the federal government's trust obligation to Indian tribes," Judge Joel M. Flaum wrote for the majority.

The ruling is a defeat for the Red Cliff, Lac Courte Oreilles and Mole Lake Ojibwe bands. The three tribes sought approval to convert an old racetrack into a Class III casino and chose an urban location because their remote reservations have not been conducive to gaming.

The proposal immediately drew fire from tribes in Wisconsin and Minnesota that claimed their successful operations would be adversely affected. The pressure led the Clinton administration to deny the Ojibwe coalition's request in 1995. Under an out-of-court settlement, the BIA eventually agreed to reconsider the application.

In the meantime, Congress launched an investigation into more than $350,000 the opposing tribes gave to Democratic interests. The probe found no wrongdoing but raised charges that tribes were buying decisions at the Bureau of Indian Affairs.

The high-stakes controversy has continued as dozens of tribes in states across the nation seek to acquire land far from their current land base and, in some cases, in other states. Critics deride the practice as "reservation shopping."

In Senate testimony last month, the BIA official in charge of gaming said his staff has found no reason to deny such land applications. George Skibine, the acting deputy assistant secretary for policy and economic development, said it "it would definitely be an economic benefit" for tribes to gain approval for casinos in more lucrative areas.

But attorneys at the National Indian Gaming Commission, which regulates the $15 billion tribal casino industry, arrived at a different conclusion in a dispute over an out-of-state casino. Analyzing the section in IGRA at issue in the Ojibwe case, acting general counsel Penny Coleman issued a legal opinion stating that it "limits, not expands, the right to game."

"It is clear that Congress intended to allow some gaming to occur on lands acquired after enactment of IGRA under this provision, but specifically disallowed gaming on newly acquired lands far from the current prior reservation," the March 24 opinion stated.

Known as Section 2719, the provision bars gaming on land taken into trust after 1988 unless certain exceptions are met. At issue in the Ojibwe case is the exception that requires the BIA to determine that an off-reservation acquisition is in the best interest of the tribe, or tribes, and won't harm other tribes.

Then, the BIA is required to send the decision to the state governor for his or her concurrence in a process known as a two-part determination. Since 1988, there have only been three successful decisions of this kind.

Political and financial pressure on states and the federal government is high for these types of acquisitions. Currently, tribes in California, Wisconsin, Oklahoma and New York are seeking to build casinos in areas hundreds of miles away from their current land base.

The BIA has given preliminary approval to the St. Regis Mohawk Tribe to build a casino in the Catskills region of New York. This decision, which took more than three years to analyze, is relatively non-controversial because the state passed legislation to approve three off-reservation casinos.

But tribes from Wisconsin and Oklahoma also want to assert gaming rights in the state where their ancestors once lived. The BIA is considering whether to approve the Wisconsin-based Stockbridge Munsee Band of Mohican Indians' request for a Catskills casino. A federal judge has been asked to determine if the Seneca-Cayuga Tribe of Oklahoma can legally game in New York.

In California, tribes are seeking to avoid the lengthy and costly two-part determination process altogether. The Lytton Band of Pomo Indians was able to acquire 10 acres in the Bay Area without state approval under a Congressional rider. The law has been upheld by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

The Coast Miwok Tribe won Congressional authority to obtain land for a reservation where it plans to build a casino. The provision was tied to restoration of the tribe's federal recognition.

Provisions in technical corrections bills sponsored by outgoing Sen. Ben Nighthorse Campbell (R-Colo.), chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee, also benefit California tribes seeking casinos. But these have come under heightened scrutiny in the last two years and Campbell is reported to have withdrawn one such provision from an upcoming bill.

Get the Decision:
LAC COURTE OREILLES BAND OF LAKE SUPERIOR CHIPPEWA INDIANS OF WISCONSIN v. US (April 29, 2004)

Relevant Links:
Chippewa Meadows Gaming & Racing - http://www.chippewameadows.com

Related Stories:
IGRA amendments mired in debate over revenues (04/13)
NIGC rules against Okla. tribe's casino in Kansas (03/26)
Senate panel debates changes to Indian gaming act (03/25)
Wis. gaming lawsuit moved to new court (8/27)
Wisconsin Governor vetoes Ojibwe casino (5/15)
Gaming suit aimed at ousting state's role (5/11)
Norton fields questions from tribal leaders (2/23)
BIA approves off-reservation Ojibwe casino (2/21)
Babbitt casino report released (8/23)
Tribe suing DOI over casino (7/18)

Copyright 2000-2004 Indianz.Com
More headlines...

Latest Headlines:

The Conversation: The toxic legacy of uranium mining in United States
Failed Indian Health Service nominee lashes out after being abandoned
Winnebago Tribe sees boost in home ownership as more return to rez
YES! Magazine: Promoting reparations for Indigenous & Black farmers
Cronkite News: Students stage walkout to call for reform of gun laws
Tribes take Wind River Reservation boundary case to Supreme Court
Northern Cheyenne Tribe returns ousted leader to office with new vote
Peoria Tribe prepares for election as long-time leader faces challenge
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe waits for Trump team's decision on casino
Nominee for Indian Health Service drops out amid doubts about record
Tribes see continued challenges as more cases head to highest court
Supreme Court ends conservative attack on Indian Child Welfare Act
Washoe Tribe plans to expand offerings at casino with new compact
Bill John Baker: Cherokee Nation makes strides in health care system
Graham Lee Brewer: Native man's death opens old wounds in Canada
YES! Magazine: Let's learn from states where gun violence has fallen
Former Lummi Nation chairman Larry Kinley passes on at age of 71
Oglala Sioux Tribe eyes investigation into misuse of education funds
Most 'isolated' towns are near reservations in Montana and Nevada
Top Indian positions in Trump administration remain without leaders
Agency that targeted tribal lenders in line for even more big changes
Osage Nation citizen wins vote as mayor of Oklahoma's largest city
Standing Rock Sioux citizen lands Native history position at Harvard
Indictment cites 'wokeaztec' account in Russian influence campaign
Matika Wilbur: A modern world doesn't erase indigenous intelligence
Cronkite News: Students plan national walkout in bid for gun reform
Kevin Noble Maillard: I took 7th grade students to see 'Black Panther'
Chumash Tribe security officers involved in fatal shooting at casino
Yavapai-Apache Nation finally ready to open 122-room casino hotel
Maine lawmaker seeks court ruling to help tribes with casino plans
Mark Trahant: Another Native woman aims to make history in 2018
Sylvia Chi: Indigenous activists lead energy divestment movement
Mark Maxey: A fight for indigenous rights and environmental rights
Tribes battle state of South Dakota over removal of Indian children
National Congress of American Indians leader slams 'fugitives' bill
Trump budget includes funds to assist six newly-recognized tribes
National Congress of American Indians wraps up big winter session
Cronkite News: Lawmakers question management of Indian schools
Trump administration continues to back Indian Health Service pick
Lac du Flambeau Band ties recent murder to gangs and drug dealers
Bill affirms Alabama-Coushatta Tribe and Tigua Tribe gaming rights
San Pasqual Band hears concerns about digital billboard at casino
Tribal leaders cheer surprise speaker as meeting in D.C. winds down
Sen. Elizabeth Warren at the National Congress of American Indians
Indian Health Service budget promises funding for opioid epidemic
National Congress of American Indians kicks off big winter session
Tribes looking for more support to pass controversial sovereignty bill
Trump administration includes Indian schools in infrastructure plan
Witnesses for Senate Indian Affairs Committee hearing on Census
Mark Trahant: White House sends messages with its new budget
Cronkite News: Tribes call for respect for their sovereignty in D.C.
National Congress of American Indians: State of Indian Nations
Sen. Tom Udall delivers response to the State of Indian Nations
>>> more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.