GRAMMY performance registers many complaints
Tuesday, February 10, 2004
OFFENSIVE? Andre 3000 of OutKast peforms hit song "Hey Ya" to Indian theme at 46th annual Grammy awards ceremony. February 8, 2004. Photo � AP.
An Indian organization from California is calling for a boycott of the CBS
network and the GRAMMY organization in response to a musical performance
that many throughout the country are calling racist and offensive.
The Native American Cultural Center in San Francisco is organizing
the boycott based on "the most disgusting set
of racial stereotypes aimed at American Indians that I have ever seen on TV,"
one board member said.
"It was on par with white people dancing sexually in black
face, or yarmulkes, or the vestments of the Catholic
Church," Sean Feitas said. "I am shocked and outraged."
Andrew Brother Elk, chair of the NACC, said he filed a formal complaint
with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) over the "racially
insulting" performance by the hip-hop group OutKast, which won a number of
awards, including Album of the Year,
at the 46th annual GRAMMY ceremony on Sunday night.
"It is time for those in the entertainment industry to realize that racial
stereotypes in the media feed social and political
disrespect towards the victims of this behavior.
American Indians do not deserve such victimization,
nor does any racial group," Brother Elk said.
In letters and posts to Indian web sites, readers reacted negatively
to the sight of OutKast frontman Andre 3000 performing the hit
song "Hey Ya!" After an introductory tape of drum music played,
dancers wearing green-colored feather headdresses, fringe
skirts and braided wigs
emerged from a large tipi on stage. The University of Southern
California marching band later appeared, its members'
faces covered in war paint.
"I feel that this was a truly sad, offensive, and disappointing
choice for the theme of the performance by artists that I have
admired for a long time," wrote Indianz.Com reader mtncrow.
"To see my tribal beliefs and customs mocked and paraded in such a
negative and stereotypical view was embarrassing," a
Kickapoo and Otoe-Missouria woman said on PowWows.com
Fans at an OutKast web site run by Arista Records,
the group's label, were not amused either. "Many of my students
love your music, as did I until tonight's performance," a Native man
who said he was a singer and Native music educator wrote. "My people did not face
500 years of broken trusts, dreams and countless millions of
lives lost to be a Grammy night gimmick."
The National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences
(NARAS), the organization that puts on the GRAMMYs, praised
OutKast's display as indicative of the show's many "unusual
"The evening's final performance also had the audience on its feet,"
the NARAS web site stated, "complete with
sci-fi stage set [and] fluorescent green Native-American costumes."
Andre 3000 rehearsed the performance on Friday, according
to NARAS, whose web site said it would feature a "giant, smoking
tepee/spaceship at center stage."
CBS has come under fire for a provocative performance by
singers Janet Jackson and Justin Timberlake. The FCC has
launched an investigation to determine how Jackson's
breast was exposed during a Superbowl half-time show
produced by MTV, which is owned by CBS.
Both networks have said they did not sanction the display,
which Timberlake said was not planned. Nevertheless, CBS
instituted a 5-minute delay for Sunday night's show
to guard against potentially offensive performances.
Additional pictures and discussion can be found on the Indianz.Com message board
Powwows.Com [registration required]
Native American Cultural Center -
GRAMMYs - http://www.grammy.com
Related Stories:Jemez Pueblo
group, Black Eagle, wins GRAMMY
(2/9) Native music on tap for GRAMMY awards
(12/05) Native GRAMMY picks a shift from
GRAMMY picks announced
(1/7) Youngblood wins Native music award at
& Mike win Grammy
(02/28)Grammy ceremony airs tonight
GRAMMY nominee a family
profiled by NYTimes
(1/16)Native GRAMMY moves into second year
(1/7) Gathering of Nations cuts
ties to SOAR
wins first Native GRAMMY
(2/22) GRAMMY show full of surprises
Spotlight on the
(1/26) GRAMMY nominees
(1/4) GRAMMYs to honor
Copyright � 2000-2003 Indianz.Com