Over two years ago, Sen. Byron Dorgan (D-North Dakota) asked
the Bureau of Indian Affairs for number of pending land-into-trust
"Is it dozens? Thousands? Millions?" Dorgan said at a Senate
Indian Affairs Committee hearing in May 2005.
A lot has changed since then. The BIA finally has a new leader in
assistant secretary Carl Artman and Dorgan, who was vice chairman
when he made the query, is now chairman due to the Democratic
takeover of Congress.
But one thing has remained the same. The BIA still doesn't know
how many land-into-trust applications are pending.
"It sounds like gross incompetence to me,"
Dorgan said yesterday. "We don't even know how many applications exist."
Artman, who began his post in March, acknowledged the problem.
He said there is no way to determine the number of pending
applications because each of the BIA's 12 regional offices
does things differently.
"This is something that we discovered over the last few months,"
It's not clear what the BIA was discovering between
the May 2005 hearing and the October 2007 one though.
In March, Artman told the National Congress of American Indians
of 2,000 pending applications. That was a few days
before he was confirmed by the Senate as the
tenth assistant secretary for Indian affairs.
"Having a backlog of 2,000 -- I've heard even more applications -- is ridiculous," Artman
A month later, associate deputy secretary Jim Cason, who ran
the BIA for more than a year after the sudden resignation of
Artman's predecessor, confirmed that figure.
At an Indian law conference in New Mexico, he said
2,000 applications were pending.
But when Indianz.Com asked about that number
just a couple of weeks later, Artman
changed his tune. He said there were only 1,300 pending applications,
far fewer than Cason's figure, but high nonetheless.
Yesterday's hearing brought a slightly more accurate account --
1,211 pending applications, Artman said.
"The numbers that you have are about as accurate as we can
get," he told the committee.
Beyond being unable to account for the pending applications,
the BIA can't give tribes and individual Indians
a deadline on when a decision might be
Some tribes and tribal members have waited as short as six months for an answer
while others have waited more than 20 years.
"For the last 25 years, we have absolutely no applications pass
through from fee to trust," said Ron His Horse Is Thunder,
the chairman of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe. "Absolutely none."
The tribe isn't terribly worried about its 10 pending applications for
a total of 19,000 acres, His Horse Is Thunder said.
It's the individual Indians
who suffer the most due to the BIA's delays, he told the committee.
"They have had their applications in for just as long as the tribe,"
he said. "I know that a couple of our tribal members have lost their
homes, have lost their land, due to tax foreclosures."
In hopes of streamlining the process,
Artman promised the release of a "handbook" on land-into-trust.
He said the handbook, which is coming in "weeks,"
would create a consistent system across all BIA regions for handling applications.
"It will at least have internal timelines and internal deadlines
that we'll adhere to, Artman testified.
He also said the Interior Department plans to develop a tracking
system for land-into-trust.
He suggested that the Trust Asset Accounting and Management System
(TAAMS) might be considered as a way to handle the applications,
although other options are being considered.
TAAMS, however, has been reported to have major usability issues
in the tracking of Indian trust leases. BIA employees in Palm Springs,
California, recently told the Interior Department's Inspector General
that they can't perform routine accounting or billing procedures
with the $40 million system.
"If we can't measure, we can't gauge success," Artman told the committee.
Dorgan said he would call Artman back in six months for a progress
"It just appears to be staggering incompetence," he said.
HEARING on Backlogs at the Department of the Interior: Land in to Trust
Applications; Environmental Impact Statements; Probate; Appraisals and Lease
(October 4, 2007)
Interior Department - http://www.doi.gov
County blasts delays in BIA's casino
(10/5) Senate hearing on Interior Department backlogs
(10/4) Witness list for hearing on Interior backlogs
(10/3) Senate hearing on Interior
No accounting of trust funds in Palm Springs
Cason explains misgivings on land-into-trust
(4/20)Artman jumps into job as new head of BIA
Artman highlights priorities as head of BIA
(4/5) Leadership changes at BIA under
(4/2) Carl Artman confirmed as
(3/6)Land-into-trust: The 'black hole' at the BIA
(2/21) BIA continues work on gaming land regulation
(12/04) Another GAO report looks at land-into-trust
(10/25) Group's list inflates off-reservation gaming