indianz.com your internet resource indianz.com on facebook indianz.com on twitter indianz.com on Google+ indianz.com on soundcloud
phone: 202 630 8439
Fredericks Peebles & Morgan LLP
Advertise on Indianz.Com
Home > News > Headlines

printer friendly version
Judge advances suit over royalty mismanagement
Friday, October 3, 2003

The federal government has a trust responsibility to ensure the collection and payment of royalties even when tribes take greater control of their affairs, a federal judge ruled last week.

In a long-running dispute over oil and gas royalties, the Bush administration argued that its trust duties were lessened because the Eastern Shoshone Tribe and the Northern Arapaho Tribe signed a cooperative audit agreement with the Minerals Management Service (MMS). "[S]omewhere along the line, the United States should be entitled to rely on obligations that the tribes assumed," government attorneys said in court papers.

On September 26, Judge Emily C. Hewitt of the U.S. Court of Claim denied the government's defense. Rejecting a summary judgment motion, she said the agreement "does not diminish the trust duty owed" to the tribes because it was meant to "enhance" and not replace the trust relationship.

"As a threshold matter, it is clear to the court that there is an obligation imposed by law on defendant to ensure the prompt and proper collection and disbursement of royalties," Hewitt wrote in the 27-page decision.

The two tribes, which share the Wind River Reservation in Wyoming, filed suit in 1979. In the part of case at issue in the court's decision, they allege MMS failed to collect the full amount of royalties from a settlement between oil and gas companies. They also allege they lost out on money for other leases because MMS failed to collect data when its computers broke down.

Government attorneys responded that MMS doesn't have to ensure the tribes received all their royalties because they accepted auditing duties under a cooperative agreement with the agency. They asked to be relieved of paying damages on the settlement and on the other leases.

Citing the Supreme Court's recent decisions in U.S. v. Navajo Nation and U.S. v. White Mountain Apache Tribe, Hewitt concluded that MMS has a duty to account for the royalties even though the tribes assumed a greater role. She noted that the Federal Oil and Gas Royalty Management Act (FOGRMA), which authorized cooperative agreements, was passed because Congress recognized that the Department of Interior wasn't honoring its obligations.

"The portions of FOGRMA that allowed for cooperative agreements reflected the reality that, at the time the legislation was passed, the Secretary was not fulfilling his responsibilities to the Indian tribes," Hewitt wrote.

The ruling allows the tribes to move forward on seeking additional money from the settlement. Arco, one of the companies involved, only paid royalties on $20 million of a $39 million settlement. The tribes contend they are owed royalties on the full amount.

The tribes can also move forward on recovering money on the other leases although Hewitt limited how much damages they may be owed. She denied two breach of trust claims, concluding that they didn't satisfy the Navajo-White Mountain framework.

The Navajo and White Mountain decisions were handed down this past March. In the Navajo case, the Supreme Court said the federal government didn't owe damages for a coal lease because the tribe negotiated the terms. Interior's role as a trustee, the majority wrote, was reduced to an advisory one. The White Mountain Apache Tribe won its case because the court said the government had control over the tribe's trust asset.

Although Bush officials have played down the impact of the two decisions because breach of trust claims are fact-specific, Hewitt has cited them as precedent. Government attorneys have cited them in other trust cases in an attempt to escape liability.

MMS is responsible for collecting about $6 million in annual oil and gas revenues from federal and Indian lands.

Get the Decision:
Shoshone v. U.S. (September 26, 2003)

Earlier Decision:
Shoshone v. U.S. (June 9, 2003)

Relevant Links:
Eastern Shoshone Tribe - http://www.easternshoshone.net
Northern Arapaho Tribe - http://www.wrtsc.org/NorthernArapaho.htm
Minerals Management Service - http://www.mms.gov

Related Stories:
Osage Nation trust suit survives first test (07/31)
Judge strikes down a trust claim in royalty suit (07/03)
Audit files for Navajo lease recreated (6/11)
Navajo leaders criticize upheaval at trust fund office (05/09)
Judge upholds ongoing trust relationship (04/29)
Supreme Court upholds common law trust claim (3/5)
High court ruling makes 'passive' trustee of U.S. (3/5)
A mixed bag for Indian trust (3/5)
Bush strategy assumes no trust mismanagement (11/05)
Andersen reports cited in tribal trust cases (08/12)
Norton handed worst nightmare (7/25)
Royalty ruling impacts Indian trust (04/30)
Trust accounting looms for tribes (3/20)
Bush administration bets on accounting (3/18)
GAO: Full reconciliation impossible (2/8)

Copyright � 2000-2003 Indianz.Com
More headlines...

Latest Headlines:

The Conversation: The toxic legacy of uranium mining in United States
Failed Indian Health Service nominee lashes out after being abandoned
Winnebago Tribe sees boost in home ownership as more return to rez
YES! Magazine: Promoting reparations for Indigenous & Black farmers
Cronkite News: Students stage walkout to call for reform of gun laws
Tribes take Wind River Reservation boundary case to Supreme Court
Northern Cheyenne Tribe returns ousted leader to office with new vote
Peoria Tribe prepares for election as long-time leader faces challenge
Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe waits for Trump team's decision on casino
Nominee for Indian Health Service drops out amid doubts about record
Tribes see continued challenges as more cases head to highest court
Supreme Court ends conservative attack on Indian Child Welfare Act
Washoe Tribe plans to expand offerings at casino with new compact
Bill John Baker: Cherokee Nation makes strides in health care system
Graham Lee Brewer: Native man's death opens old wounds in Canada
YES! Magazine: Let's learn from states where gun violence has fallen
Former Lummi Nation chairman Larry Kinley passes on at age of 71
Oglala Sioux Tribe eyes investigation into misuse of education funds
Most 'isolated' towns are near reservations in Montana and Nevada
Top Indian positions in Trump administration remain without leaders
Agency that targeted tribal lenders in line for even more big changes
Osage Nation citizen wins vote as mayor of Oklahoma's largest city
Standing Rock Sioux citizen lands Native history position at Harvard
Indictment cites 'wokeaztec' account in Russian influence campaign
Matika Wilbur: A modern world doesn't erase indigenous intelligence
Cronkite News: Students plan national walkout in bid for gun reform
Kevin Noble Maillard: I took 7th grade students to see 'Black Panther'
Chumash Tribe security officers involved in fatal shooting at casino
Yavapai-Apache Nation finally ready to open 122-room casino hotel
Maine lawmaker seeks court ruling to help tribes with casino plans
Mark Trahant: Another Native woman aims to make history in 2018
Sylvia Chi: Indigenous activists lead energy divestment movement
Mark Maxey: A fight for indigenous rights and environmental rights
Tribes battle state of South Dakota over removal of Indian children
National Congress of American Indians leader slams 'fugitives' bill
Trump budget includes funds to assist six newly-recognized tribes
National Congress of American Indians wraps up big winter session
Cronkite News: Lawmakers question management of Indian schools
Trump administration continues to back Indian Health Service pick
Lac du Flambeau Band ties recent murder to gangs and drug dealers
Bill affirms Alabama-Coushatta Tribe and Tigua Tribe gaming rights
San Pasqual Band hears concerns about digital billboard at casino
Tribal leaders cheer surprise speaker as meeting in D.C. winds down
Sen. Elizabeth Warren at the National Congress of American Indians
Indian Health Service budget promises funding for opioid epidemic
National Congress of American Indians kicks off big winter session
Tribes looking for more support to pass controversial sovereignty bill
Trump administration includes Indian schools in infrastructure plan
Witnesses for Senate Indian Affairs Committee hearing on Census
Mark Trahant: White House sends messages with its new budget
Cronkite News: Tribes call for respect for their sovereignty in D.C.
National Congress of American Indians: State of Indian Nations
Sen. Tom Udall delivers response to the State of Indian Nations
>>> more headlines...

Home | Arts & Entertainment | Business | Canada | Cobell Lawsuit | Education | Environment | Federal Recognition | Federal Register | Forum | Health | Humor | Indian Gaming | Indian Trust | Jack Abramoff Scandal | Jobs & Notices | Law | National | News | Opinion | Politics | Sports | Technology | World

Indianz.Com Terms of Service | Indianz.Com Privacy Policy
About Indianz.Com | Advertise on Indianz.Com

Indianz.Com is a product of Noble Savage Media, LLC and Ho-Chunk, Inc.